Death Penalty

Good Essays
4. Death Penalty
There are two main theories involved with the death penalty: the theory of retribution and the utilitarian theory of punishment. The theory of retribution, as in, an eye for an eye; they deserve punishment equal to what their crime is. The utilitarian theory of punishment argues that one may only punish in order to produce the best possible future outcome for everyone.
In Chapter 4 “The Death Penalty Debate”, C.S. Lewis presents a different theory. In “The Humanitarian Theory of Punishment” article, Lewis is rational in fearing that control of the justice system would be relegated to so call experts and criminals would lose their rights as human beings. Lewis’s suggested a different route which includes the Retributive theory with the Humanitarian theory. Lewis believes that the Retributive theory is not driven by revenge but instead by humanity’s drive to maintain control on their society. It is then considered legitimate and not immoral. Lewis points out that no good can actually come out of the Humanitarian theory. Lewis argues the practicability of the Humanitarian theory in the context of England in the 1970’s but his fears are related to contemporary day society in the United States as well. The Humanitarian theory denies us of our rights as human beings and “carries on its front a semblance of mercy which is wholly false”, Lewis wrote. The idea of using punishment as a cure brings up major problems with the Humanitarian theory. This leaves us to ask who will decide what punishment is an appropriate cure for a criminal. This means that there would be a selected group of experts trained to do so. Lewis, sickened with the idea, calls them “penologists”. In the court system of England that Lewis is using as a basis, the citizen juries not only help determine guilt or innocence of the accused but also the severity of the punishment. Lewis sees the retributive theory as an inherent and crucial part of society. He also states that citizen juries

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Death Penalty

    • 1910 Words
    • 8 Pages

    1101 The death penalty has been and always will be a controversial issue. Most people have strong opinions and arguments to support their side. Arguments for both sides can be extremely convincing but it boils down to personal opinions. In fact, each state governs the death penalty differently. Although there are opposing views to the death penalty, I am in favor of the death penalty because of the retribution, morality, and its deterrence. The death penalty gives retribution…

    • 1910 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Death Penalty

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages

    What is the death penalty? ‘Punishments are imposed on a person, not on racial or economic groups. Guilt is personal. The only relevant question is: does the person to be executed deserve the punishment?’ (Ernest van den Haag, 1986) According to Amnesty International, 139 countries have abolished the death penalty. In 2010, only one country, Gabon, abolished the death penalty for all crimes. During 2010, 23 countries executed 527 prisoners and at least 2,024 people were sentenced to death in 67 countries…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Death Penalty

    • 2792 Words
    • 12 Pages

    ABSTRACT: This essay was mainly about death penalty. The information of essay was partially taken from the internet, through discussion among tutor and friends as well as general knowledge from outside sources. The objective of carrying out death penalty is to show that justice for extreme crime still exists. Electrocution, hanging, gas chamber, firing squad and lethal injection are the methods of execution in death penalty. In contrast, death penalty is a necessary evil that serves as deterrent…

    • 2792 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Death Penalty

    • 2855 Words
    • 12 Pages

    The death penalty has been a controversial issue for many years. It was established centuries ago and has been accepted by society. It was put into place to punish those who had committed an offense against laws of the institution that was in place at the time. Within our society the death penalty has been associated with several symbols. ‘An eye for an eye,’ is a symbol that has come to be the representation of the death penalty; which was one of the original ideas behind it. Times have changed…

    • 2855 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Death Penalty

    • 2240 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The death penalty is unjust and inhumane for nations to carry out. In addition, it is irrational for the United States government to choose to condemn an individual to death. The death penalty should be banned. The main reasons the death penalty must be eliminated is for the inequality of race, gender, and class. The punishment isn’t a crime deterrent, and isn’t cost effective. Also, the potential error within the judicial system with capital punishment leads to the end of an individuals’ life, a…

    • 2240 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Death Penalty

    • 2910 Words
    • 12 Pages

    The Death Penalty Informal Logic PHI103 Theresa Ramsey February 13, 2012 Some people believe that the death penalty is wrong and some believe it is right. But how does anyone have the right to take someone else’s life. The death penalty is an issue that many people have talked about throughout many of years. Many people should be punished for the things they have done but I don’t think we should kill them we as the people shouldn’t have the right to take anyone life away. I believe in karma…

    • 2910 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Death Penalty

    • 2548 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Death Penalty in the Philippines Santos Lamban, PAHRA The Philippines was the first Asian country that abolished the death penalty in 1987 . But six yearsafter it has reimposed the death penalty, the Philippines has overtaken its Asian neighbors and hasthe most number of death convicts.Within less than a year, however, the military establishment was lobbying for its reimposition as ameans to combat the "intensifying" offensives of the CPP/NPA guerrillas. Gen. Fidel V. Ramos, thenChief of the…

    • 2548 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Death Penalty

    • 1735 Words
    • 6 Pages

    current use of today. The death penalty rests on strong foundation of symmetry and rightness. 11 The primary goal has evolved from one for state security to a more focused goal of doing justice and controlling crime.12 The globalization and the inequality are both factors in the controversy of the deterrence of capital punishment. Cesare Bonesana di Beccaria, a philosopher in Italy, wrote “An Essay on Crime and Punishment” in 1764.8 The concerns he stated about the use of death as a punishment are very…

    • 1735 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Death Penalty

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages

    DEATH PENALTY 1 ESL 151 12/12/2012 2 Committed crimes that can carry to the death penalty are known as capital crimes. Different kinds of crimes can be punished by the death penalty, such as rape, incest, murder…

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Death Penalty

    • 1122 Words
    • 5 Pages

    November 2012 The death penalty was reinstated in the United States in 1977, and since then murderers and rapist have been executed for the violent and harsh crimes they were found guilty of committing. In the past thirty years over 1,200 prisoners have been put to death for crimes in which they were convicted. The government of each state executes these prisoners by way of the electric chair, gas chamber, and the most common way lethal injection. A survey, from the Death Penalty Information Center…

    • 1122 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays