Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

DBQ on Industrial Leaders: "Robber barons" vs. "Industrial Statesmen"

Good Essays
533 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
DBQ on Industrial Leaders: "Robber barons" vs. "Industrial Statesmen"
Author Mark Twain described the latter half of the nineteenth century as the "Gilded Age," meaning golden, because of the economic opportunities that America had to offer during these times. However, there were some people who sought success selfishly before attempting to revolutionize the economy. The men who took advantage of these opportunities were more robber barons than they were industrial statesmen. More often than not, greed overcame their decisions as capitalists.

During the Gilded Age, the leaders of industry worked towards self-interest, and thus were called "robber barons." In this time period, the focus of these barons was to earn as much money as possible. Many Americans were disgusted with this plan. The less-than-fortunate ridiculed the greedy business leaders and demanded fairness (doc. B). Several workers even hoped to attain equality, and worked toward this goal through strikes, such as the Pullman Strike of 1894. However, for the lucky ones sitting at the top of the social ladder, mass money-making was the foremost goal. This was achieved through two different methods: vertical integration and horizontal integration. The latter was used by John D. Rockefeller, the king of oil. Horizontal integration is the process of buying the smaller companies that might compete with one company. For example, Rockefeller's Standard Oil Company smaller oil and gas companies (doc. C). Vertical integration is the process of controlling all aspects in a business. The Gilded Age brought corporate greed at its fullest, especially during the 1880s and 1890s. Industries, especially the Standard Oil Company, were looked down upon, but nothing could stop the power of those titanic business empires (doc. D). Thus was the life of a robber baron; stomp out the competition, take as much money as possible, and disregard the poor.

Despite the disgraceful actions of the robber barons, industrial leaders were sometimes the shining examples of industrial statesmen. The greatest example was the economic revolution that occurred. America was, and is, made up of immigrants because it is widely know as the "land of opportunity." Here, a man could earn his living depending on how hard he works. The industrial leaders represented a common man earning his wealth instead of inheriting it. For example, Andrew Carnegie was a Scottish-American who started with meager beginnings. His family was impoverished, and in 1851, he started working as a telegraph messenger for $2.50 a week. Through wise business decisions over the years, he became a successful millionaire. The course of earning money brought a significant change to the world of finance (doc. A). In fact, some Americans preferred this lifestyle. According to Carnegie's "The Gospel of Wealth," the "irregularity of wealth" is better than "universal squalor" (doc. E). He means that it's plausible for the poor to become the rich, and the rich to help the poor. He, among other greats like Rockefeller, felt it was important to give back to society. Some entrepreneurs donated millions to others, thus becoming great industrial leaders (doc. H).

In general, the industrial leaders of the nineteenth century were robber barons before industrial statesmen. However, now that America is aware of the good that business titans can do, perhaps future generations will take after the statesmen.

Source:

Documents specified in the 2005 AP American questions

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    John D. Rockefeller was not a Robber Baron because he did nothing wrong, he was a product of the Industrial era, and played by its rules to attain the greatest victory, absolute economic success…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    3. As a reporter covering the strike at the Homestead Mill, I would say that Frick and Carnegie are Robber Barons. Although they claim to be Captains of Industry, creating jobs and invigorating the economy, they take and take and take. Carnegie and Frick eliminate all…

    • 646 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Captains of Industry

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages

    More often than not, America’s capitalists are accused of being the “robber barons” of industrial America. The myth is that these men took advantage of a naïve and growing economy and collected its benefits without giving anything in return. True, the majority of America was poor in relation to the few high-class people, but the idealist efforts and contributions of these men cannot be denied. If not for these men and their efforts, there would have been no one to spread the road to America’s industrial control.…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    US History Gilded Age

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Although some historians believe that the late 19th century was a golden age in American history, to many living during the time it was an era filled with corruption and hardship and thus was coined by the author Mark Twain, the Gilded Age. “The term Gilded Age represented the view of many during the time period and stood for a society that appears magnificent on the outside but is quite brittle under the superficial golden layer” [1/26/11]. For example, the economy during this time was called a triumph of industrial capitalism and was marked by great wealth, yet during this period the United States went through two costly depressions. Moreover, this period saw a rise in progressive movements but was also marked with inequality, segregation, persecution and sexism that thwarted any hopes for social development and progression. Lastly, the corruption of the political system and unrestricted influence of Big Business diminished the role of the democratic process and hindered civil liberties. The Gilded Age of American History was an era of unresolved problems with dreams of success followed only by failed aspirations and adversity.…

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As the American Civil War came to an end, an era of phenomenal economic growth was spurred by a second Industrial Revolution. It touched all geographic areas of America, evident in increased farm output and labor efficiency. The magnificent flow of goods generated could be efficiently transported by freshly lain transcontinental railroads made of Bessemer steel. Presiding over these late nineteenth century developments was a new class of extremely wealthy industrialists, the main beneficiaries of the era’s prosperity. They dominated substantial sectors of the new economy such as steel, oil, banking, and rail transportation. While these individuals created and donated outstanding wealth, they also engineered one of American history’s most corrupt and unequally heterogeneous time periods, dubbed the Gilded Age by Mark Twain. Such ambiguity blurs the legacy of these incredible few, who some call “robber barons” and other call “captains of industry”. However, neither polarity is completely accurate. The wealthiest Americans during the Gilded Age had both positive and negative effects on American society.…

    • 2538 Words
    • 73 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Apush- Monopolies

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages

    America’s industrial growth during the period from 1870 to 1900 was greatly impacted by growth of large corporations that affected the economics and politics of our nation. As corporations began to grow, so did their power and influence. Their numbers grew to be so significant that they were known to be one of the major forces within the United States, with both a great amount of power and the ability to control much within the United States. Their power and influence expanded and impacted the economic and political aspects of our nation. These corporations dominated American business and defined the American culture. The Gilded Age, a term coined by Mark Twain, was used to describe the conditions within the United States during this time. The nation was “lined with gold”, but had many struggles and obstacles that spread through the social, political, and economic aspects of the United States. These big businesses initiated many transformations within the United States and set the foundation for America becoming the world’s greatest industrial nation. In the time period between 1870 and 1900, corporations used their influence and power to control and transform both the economic and political systems of the United States. In response, Americans organized and implemented changes within the society to counteract the detrimental effects of these massive monopolies.…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    ruthless means. The definition of a Captain of Industry is a business leader whose means of…

    • 600 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Andrew Carnegie History

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the early part of the Twentieth century large monopolies ruled the industrial world bringing about long hours, low wages, and harsh working conditions. This was also the time when the thought or the attempt to unionize was completely out of the question as far as most leaders of industry were concerned. Andrew Carnegie was the one of the so-called robber barons that took a stand against the unfair working conditions. Carnegie preached the rights of laborers and felt they should unionize to protect their jobs. (Amer Exp 2) As a result of Carnegie's strong reputation his stand for…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Industrial capitalists of the late 19th century were “Captains of Industry” for many reasons. There were a couple modes on the matter. The first was that the wealth of the parents would go to the first son, so that to insure that the family name be carried on. Some thought that this was bad because it depends on the children to take care of everything, and that in the end it hurts the state that they don’t get any and that it all goes to the first child.…

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    As mentioned earlier, during the Gilded Age, there was a belief in monopolies by robber barons of society and taking out businesses. For example, a businessman named John D. Rockefeller known as a robber baron of society during this time period. This was because he ended up taking over the oil business by building trusts. These trusts then made him in control of the entire oil business and eventually eliminating all competing oil businesses. Although, these…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Gilded Age, also known as the age of steel, was a sequence of reformation including: industrial and technological advances, economic growth, labor unions, politics, women’s rights, and foreign affairs. The foundations of industrialism were established in the United States during the first sign of industrialization, which occurred between the American Revolution and the American Civil War. But by the time of the Civil War, however, these advances were limited to only discrete segments of the country. However, in 1860 the United States, confident and ready, began era of extraordinarily industrialization, that would renovate the country into a society that became profoundly dependent on industry. Industrial workers faced numerous hardships throughout The Gilded Age including but not limited to: poverty, brutal working conditions, and little to no pay. These men, women, and children were labored ` until they became ill, or they died. The Industrial workers faced numerous difficulties getting their voices heeded to. However, their tactics and strategies through various methods such as attempting to form labor unions (AFL, Knights of Labor, IWW) and organizing strikes (Pullman Strike, Homestead Strike) proved to be unsuccessful by the late 1900’s.…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In document A it shows the picture named “Puck”. In this picture it shows the workers on the bottom, putting all this work into holding up this company up, or in the picture the ship and the owners or the business men do nothing but make all the money. This truly shows that the owners should be counted as “Robber Barons” mostly because they aren’t helping anyone but themselves by making other people to do their job, and not paying them even close to what he could pay them. In document D it demonstrates the picture “The Great Race for the Western Stakes 1870”. In this document these two men are competing to build off the railroad, but the difference is, Vanderbilt, the person on the left of this picture, with the two R.R’s is very successful and rich and just not giving anyone else the chance to have any success, while the one to the right just wants to try and expand his R.R company, but Vanderbilt, isn’t letting that happen. In document E this cartoon is titled “The Trust Giants Point of View”. This document shows Rockefeller looking down upon the Whitehouse, making a point that he’s bigger and better than everyone with his oil industry. All three document show these men showing that they are “Robber Barons” by how badly they treat society and how they look down on everyone else.…

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    To what extent is it justified to characterize the industrial leaders of the 1865–1900 era as either “robber barons” or “industrial statesmen”?…

    • 1558 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    It has come to my attention that during the late 1800’s there has been many industries that shaped the rules and regulations of our society today. There have been many names that these companies have been named but two of them really stand out to me. They are “Captains of Industry,” and “Robber Barons.” I firmly believe that these companies can be looked at as “Robber Barons” instead of “Captains of Industry” because these companies take advantage of their employees (including children), they leave the people powerless, and also, they eventually leave these poor citizens unemployed.…

    • 715 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The capitalists of this period were rightly considered captains of industry because of the many job opportunities they created. Thousands if not millions of Americans found work thanks to Carnegie’s US Steel or Rockefeller’s Standard Oil, or working on the railroads owned by Cornelius Vanderbilt. These jobs lured rural Americans off their farms and immigrants onto ships to come in search of an opportunity to make something of themselves, to become the star of their own Horatio Alger novel. However, many critics complained that those jobs did not pay very well, and pointed out that a large gap was emerging between the rich and the poor. It reminded some commentators of the medieval system of lords and…

    • 1348 Words
    • 39 Pages
    Good Essays