Preview

Dalby's Misinterpretation Of Geishas

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2026 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Dalby's Misinterpretation Of Geishas
Japan has a very distinct culture, from the art of kabuki theatre to anime and manga; Japanese traditions have grown over time. One distinguishing facet of the Japanese culture is the "geisha." The practice of the "geisha" tradition is elegant, stunning, and sophisticated while it empowers women simultaneously. This environment enabled the development for Japanese women to gain a form of influence or power that did not exist to the majority of women throughout the world. The Oxford English Dictionary defines “geisha” as “a Japanese girl whose profession is to entertain men by dancing and singing; loosely, a Japanese prostitute” (n.1). This definition roughly refers to geishas as prostitutes over several incidents in time. For a while now, …show more content…
If more people were able to acknowledge that a geisha is paid solely for her company, there would most likely be a change in how they perceived.
Another misinterpretation of "geishas" can be found in the 2005 movie release of Memoirs of a Geisha. This movie was based off the book written by Arthur Golden, who visited Japan to study more on the flower and willow world of the "geishas". He has sold more than 44 million copies in thirty three different languages. A famous "geisha" of Kyoto's Gion district, Mineko Iwasaki, now retired, allowed Golden to research and question her experience about being a "geisha." However, once the novel was published she was not pleased with the results:
I spent seven to eight hours a day for two weeks talking to him, but he did not get anything right," Iwasaki told U.S. News." He has made a mockery of Japanese culture." She says geishas are more artisans than courtesans--more focused on the arts of music and dance and conversation, which they study for years, than those of the futon. She adds that she was promised anonymity but was named in the book's acknowledgments, and now people think she is the model for Golden's main character, Sayuri, a young rural girl sold into a geisha house. "For me, personally, this is a libel," Iwasaki says. (Galloway, Joseph L)
…show more content…
It seems that some tourists do not understand the manners of respecting a "geisha" when she is walking down the street to her next teahouse venue. In "Japanese Geisha to Be Trained in a New Art: Self-defense," Julian Ryan reports that the Higashiyama Police Station is training the "geishas" in the art of self-defense. Many tourists have misunderstanding of what modern "geishas" do for a living and often grab them thinking they are women who do more than entertaining men at night. Due to this misconception, it is offensive to the "geishas" and residents when foreigners, intentionally or unintentionally, disrespect these women. Visitors who are unaware of these tradition risks a "geisha’s" safety in her workplace (The Telegraph). This may be happening due to the portrayal of "geishas" in the media. One example is during the month of October in America, Halloween is a holiday that allows people to wear costumes of their favorite characters, people, or whatever they choose. Retailers sell costumes that range from boys and girls to women and men. Most of the costumes for women are sexy; miniskirts, tight fitting clothing, high heels, fishnet stockings, etc. These costumes often take an innocent children’s cartoon costume and sexualize the concept. Included in the sexy Halloween costumes, "geishas" make their appearance on the market. The costume depicts a woman wearing a scantly

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Maxine Hong Kingston’s memoir the “ Woman Warrior” has a very alluring writing style. Her beautifully written words drag readers into the abyss of fable and reality. Nevertheless, to many her writing style may seem unnerving and difficult to pinpoint, and can make one question the ability to fathom English ! Consequently, readers are pulled into the paradox between words and meaning. Kingston’s memoir is like no other writer, her words are a graceful dance that swing the reader along for the ride. Her diction is the dance in motion: throughout the book, she says words that mean much more than a mere definition. For example, the use of the word “ghost” is used to convey not just a supernatural phenomena, but an outsiders…

    • 243 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Japanese cultural values and their aspiration for being a united society have grown out of the nation's unique history and cultured philosophy. These ancient roots have touched every aspect of Japanese business from the way formal gatherings are conducted to the significance placed on after-hours socializing. By realizing and adjusting to this business culture, Western executives keen to do business in Japan will be able to be more productive in associating with their Japanese colleagues and will increase the likelihood of achieving the objectives of their conferences. It is important to comprehend the role of the female entertainer in Japanese culture, which is why the Geisha has a particular role. However, geisha women are often confused with prostitutes.…

    • 687 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “But Hatsumomo threw herself at Shojiro and began hitting him everywhere. I do think that in a way she went crazy,” (330). Hatsumomo, a prized and popular geisha, turns into something else altogether. Sadistic acts such as treating children with disrespect, sabotaging the livelihood of others, and physical violence were the root cause of her downfall. These actions reflect on her hateful yet confident personality. Hatsumomo, who is oftentimes the center of attention, illustrates how being narcissistic and remorseless will never help achieve a goal. Hatsumomo ruins her future prospects by committing cruel actions, which are motivated by her desire of becoming the heir of the Okiya.…

    • 585 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Memoirs of a Geisha is full of admiration, primarily to Western readers who are unaccustomed with the spiritual Japanese geisha. As a geisha, you is positioned to entertain men with dance, conversation, and song. Many people believe geishas are considered as prostitutes, but really they represent the past of Japan more than they represent prostitutes. Marc Canter mentioned how these geishas go through a variety of changes in their roles in the past and are now absolutely different from where they started out at. Are geishas still considered as prostitutes? Arthur Golden, in his novel Memoirs of a Geisha, revealed that “there’s a world where appearances are dominant; where a girl's virginity is auctioned to the highest bidder; where women are…

    • 255 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Geisha Make-Up History

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages

    During initiation the maiko is helped with her make-up by either her older sister or okasan, after this she applies the make-up herself. After a geisha has been working for three years, she changes her make-up to a more simple style, the reason for this is because she has now become mature which shows in her own natural beauty. For formal occasions the mature geisha will still apply white make-up. For geisha over thirty, the heavy white make-up is only worn during special dances which require her to wear make-up for her part.…

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    After the girl has finished her shikomi training by becoming proficient in all of the geisha classes and passing a dance exam. The passing of all of her classes and dance exams cause each of the individual girls to move to the secondary stage of training where she is relieved of her duties. Up until these exams the girls would have maid-like duties. The second stage of geisha training is called minarai. During this time of training, a full geisha chooses a geisha in training. During this time of training the geisha will refer to the young girl that she is training as “little sister”, just as the young geisha in training calls the geisha “big sister”. This secondary training is done in the field, but the geisha in training does not participate…

    • 162 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Japanese society is known for being ruled mostly by men. Men own property and dominate their families; women are often sold into marriage. However, the symbolism in Tanizaki’s story is of the beautiful black spider tattooed on the unnamed girls back. The fact that she remains unnamed is yet another example of the dominance of men in society. While men tend to dominate, Tanizaki uses the story of the tattooer, Seikichi, and the young girl to depict the influence women can have over men using their sexuality. Though the story is in no way physically sexual, that is the two do not make love, this man, this artist, pours his soul into the back of this young girl giving her complete control over him. An example of this lustful power can be found…

    • 200 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The 2005 film ‘Memoirs of Geisha’, directed by Rob Marshall, is a film which follows the life of a young Japanese girl who is taken from the life of which she was accustomed to and is forced to live in and become part of a world which is exceedingly isolating, restricting and where conformity is highly valued. Sayuri, the protagonist in the film, finds that the only way for her to overcome her feelings of disconnectedness and isolation is to actually intentionally isolate and disconnect herself from her desires, love, emotions, and ultimately herself.…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Lady Murasaki was born around 973 in Kyoto between Fujiwara no Tametoki and her mother. She got married with Fujiwara no Nobutaka when she was in early 20s, and raised a child named Daini no Sanmi. She was an intelligent women and made many accomplishments. The most famous accomplishment of Lady Murasaki was The Tale of Genji. The Tale of Genji described Hikaru Genji, who was smart and good looking, and his romantic life. It took about 12 years to complete the story, which contained over 50 chapters at the end. I think this is quite a long time to finish writing a story, since in these days, we can finish writing stories in a shorter length of time due to the high technology we have. Lady Murasaki had a rival called Sei Shōnagon, who was the author of The Pillow Book. Nowadays, Lady Murasaki has become famous and her accomplishments are still influencing modern-day Japan. Lady Murasaki, compared to Sei Shōnagon, was different in many ways, but was similar in many ways as well, which I found rather surprising. I am glad that I decided to write a research paper on Lady Murasaki, because I have always wondered about her life and The Tale of Genji. I learnt a lot about Lady Murasaki, and enjoyed working on this…

    • 2398 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    In a girl with the pearl earring the protagonist, Griet, is sent to be a maid the artist Johannes Vermeer and his growing family. In this household she becomes close to Vermeer’s work, and eventually the secretive painting of Griet seeps out into the rest of the family and the town beyond.…

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many powerful people use their influence to change fate. During World War II, geisha are suppose to go to the factories to work. Sayuri has this same fate until Nobu, a powerful official working in an influential company, is able to send her to a “safe haven.” He’s able to use his power that he has so Sayuri doesn't have to go to work in the factories. While Sayuri is now in debt to him because of his actions, she is…

    • 659 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is known that during seventeenth century Japan, women were seen as being inferior to men and had no major role in society. Their only actual role was to remain loyal to their husbands, act as an obedient mother, and uphold the household duties, while having no actual authority in the household of which they maintained. It was expected for women to behave in a passive and subservient manner towards not only their husbands, but all men. They were expected to act this way, while in return receiving little or no respect from society. They hardly received an education and if they were lucky enough to obtain any it was restricted to basic literacy. They were simply taught household duties and that was their only function in civilization.…

    • 1300 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What Makes Geishas Unique

    • 1051 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The geishas of Japan have a very distinctive yet unique feature that draws forth the attention of many people from all over the world, especially in the world of art. Even though they are humans, they are considered as a very prized form of art. The definition of geisha is an artistic person (Rowthorn 2011). They are considered as a masterpiece due to their gorgeous features that includes a variety of hairstyles, each with their own meaning and use and the feature that jumps out most is their makeup. Despite their origin in ancient Japan as female servants and prostitutes (DeMello 2012), geishas have turned into a prized possession with their true beauty and performance in the art world.…

    • 1051 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The key moment when one experiences a move towards a psychological or moral maturity is different for every single person, every single novel, and every single protagonist in a story. Sometimes, there are more than one “key moment” in a person's life, as in the case of Sayuri, the protagonist of the novel, Memoirs of a Geisha, by Arthur Golden. This historical fiction story tells of a young Japanese girl from a small fishing village, who is sent away to the big city of Gion in order to train to be a geisha. Throughout the novel, Sayuri sometimes loses her meaning and purpose in life, in being a geisha, but always eventually finds it; often times through encounters with other characters, sometimes by herself and her own thoughts. She meets…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Memoirs Of A Geisha Essay

    • 1459 Words
    • 6 Pages

    “Remember Chiyo, geisha’s are not courtesans and we are not wives. We sell our skills not our bodies. We create another secret world, a place only of beauty. The very word “Geisha” means artist and to be a geisha is to be judged as a moving work of art” (Golden).…

    • 1459 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays