Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision-Making

Better Essays
Topics: Ethics, Morality
Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision-Making
Mary Grein
ACC/260
March 14, 2010
Dana Catlin

Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision-Making
At times one has to make decisions with no guidance from others or any rules in which to guide them. Sometimes one allows our “gut feelings” or hearts help to make a decision. Other times ones conscience or moral standings will help with the decision. Using the Ethical Decision- Making Framework (EDM) is a philosophical approach to help make the correct decision. The three philosophical approaches are: consequentalism, deontology, and virtue ethics. This paper is a critique of each type of approach from the previous three scenarios from week four. 1. Scenario one: The mayor of a small seaside town has to decide if building a mall estimated to bring in $150 million in tourism each year is worth destroying the only nursing home and senior citizens recreation center in the town. The home consists of 100 seniors and 30 employees.
A. Using the consequentalism approach, asks what the consequences would be. In this case, building the mall would benefit the entire community. Keeping the nursing home and recreation center would only benefit the 130 people involved with it. The number of people benefiting from the mall outweighs the people at the nursing home.
B. Using the deontology approach asks what are the duties and obligations involved. Since the mayor of the town is making the decision, his obligation and duty is to do what is best for his community. Either choice would fall into this approach. Building the mall would help the town economically, or keeping the nursing home would benefit the residence and employees.
C. Using the virtue ethics approach asks what is morally right or wrong. This approach would be the worse approach. Sometimes morals do not always make the correct decision. Putting oneself as a villain, kicking senior citizens out of their home, is moral thinking,



References: Brooks, L.J. (2007). Business & professional ethics for directors, executives, & accountants (4th ed.). Mason, OH: Thomson Southwestern.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making The mayor of a small town was face with a difficult decision which would have ether help the community or help the elderly. In this critical decision you have to think what’s going to best for everyone of this economic situation. The mayor had to look at every side to understand the pros and cons of what will happen if he makes the choice to go either way. I think the mayor should accommodate both the city and the elderly. In the first…

    • 906 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making When looking at ethical decision making in a philosophical approach you must consider the consequentialism ethics, deontology ethics, or the virtual ethics of any case you are evaluating. The following is a discussion of three different scenarios and the different approaches in decision making for these cases. This author will talk about what makes each scenario ethical…

    • 1370 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Appendix B Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making Matrix Determine the ethical course of action for the following three scenarios from the perspective of each of the three philosophical approaches: consequentialism, deontology, and virtue ethics. Then, complete the matrix below by writing a few sentences stating the ethical course of action and the reasoning from that approach’s perspective. Clearly differentiate the reasons for each of the three approaches. Keep in mind…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    STRAYER UNIVERSITY CRJ 220 ETHICS & LEADERSHIP IN CRIMINAL JUSTICE PROFESSOR: JASON DOUGLAS Philosophical Approach to Ethical Decision Making Tasha L. Thomas 01/22/2012 Abstract Ethics is the branch of philosophy that examines questions of morality, or right and wrong. In this paper we will discuss the philosophical approaches used in ethical decision making. The two approaches that will be elaborated on are the utilitarian approach and the universal approach. Several questions will…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Decision Making Approaches

    • 2728 Words
    • 11 Pages

    to make decisions. Most managers or executives have to engage in some aspect of decision making including coming up with ideas, evaluative alternatives, or implementing directives (Brousseau et al., 2006). However, it could be a critical issue for decision makers to build up proper decisions in various situations. Hence, how to adopt suitable technique in decision making processes is a significant text for them. This essay firstly is going to discuss the benefits of automated decision making due to…

    • 2728 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Approaches to Decision Making I chose scenario number two. Managers oversee as well as them having to come up with the best decisions to solve issues or difficulties overall to preserve their division and have it run smooth. There are various decision making approaches, but I will only talk about two and they are bounded rationality and rational. When decisions are being made that have an impact on others, it is vital to have…

    • 598 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    ethical decision making

    • 15994 Words
    • 64 Pages

    “right” answers. What are your reactions to the three ethical dilemmas? What other information would be helpful to know about these situations to make a decision? CHAPTER FOCUS Virtue or Character Ethics Principle-Based Ethics: Developing Moral Rules Utilitarian Theories: Doing the Most Good for the Most People Deontological Theories: Balancing Rights and Obligations Justice in Health Care Values and Health Policy Ethics of Care Ethical Problems Faced by Community Nurses: The Research…

    • 15994 Words
    • 64 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Ethical Decision Making

    • 1945 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Assuming as a manager of a large Australian clothing retailer with a manufacture mainly based in Bangladesh, the manager would have to be involved in various types of decision making processes for the well-being of its organization. For instance due to the Rana-Plaza incident, a safety accord has been generated which is an understanding of an organization towards its employees to upgrade factories conditions with basic standards such as fire escapes and many more √ ("Kmart, Target Sign Up to Safety…

    • 1945 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Ethical Decision Making

    • 1553 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The importance of ethical decision making Ethical decision making involves acting in a morally correct and socially responsible way. The law is based on ethical principles. However, the law is only ethically relevant to the period in time which it was made. This means that the law will never be able to account for every course of action and that the responsibility lies with the decision makers to ensure they act in an ethical manner. White collar crime in Australia has resulted in the collapse…

    • 1553 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Ethical Decision Making

    • 1651 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Ethical Decision-Making Critical Thinking: Strategies in Decision Making Ethical Decision-Making In today's business and personal world, ethical decisions are made on a daily basis. Most of these decisions are based on company ground rules. The others are based on personal ground rules. All decisions can have a number of ground rules that help us determine whether our decision is ethical or unethical. Each decision whether it is based on company or personal ground rules will have its own set…

    • 1651 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays