Preview

A Critique of "Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor"

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
3054 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
A Critique of "Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor"
Since 1991, the southern half of Somalia, a poverty stricken African nation, has seen various tribal militias battle for dominance and power over individual regions of the country. Violence has plagued Mogadishu, the capital, since warlords ousted the former president. Mere months after the collapse of the government, men, women and children in torn clothes ran helplessly towards packages dropped from military planes towards the hot sand of their tiny village. This action was one of many attempts to help underdeveloped nations receive food by the United Nations' World Food Programme. Within his article titled "Lifeboat Ethics: the Case Against Helping the Poor", Garret Hardin, a well-known philosopher of ecology, analyzes the difficulty and ultimate ruin associated with providing aid to these nations. Hardin's argument for the preservation of well-to-do societies is embodied by his extended metaphor of each society as a lifeboat, with the citizens of developed nations riding calmly amongst a sea of drowning poverty-stricken individuals. Ultimately, Hardin argues for a very harsh thesis: regardless of the current situation, privileged nations simply should not provide aid to those individuals trapped within the vortex of underdeveloped nations. His argument is consequentialist: he claims that the net result of doing so would be negative and would, in the long run, court large-scale disaster. Although Hardin's argument appears logic-based, his excessive metaphors fail when applied to real-life scenarios, for oftentimes he misconstrues facts to create a claim that may be perceived as more accurate than reality illustrates. Furthermore, any counter-arguments Hardin feels may refute his claim are pushed aside, avoiding factual evidence that may prove his argument inaccurate or misleading. Much like a lifeboat, Hardin leaves the assertions of the "humanitarian apologists" to drown so as to avoid the overturn of his claim.

Within the section titled "Adrift in a Moral
Continue Reading
View Writing Issues

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Garett Hardin Lifeboat Ethics Summary
    • 635 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Garett Hardin Lifeboat Ethics Summary

    In the passage, Garett Hardin illustrates in “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor,” he describes his stand on global overpopulation and how it may effect on the resources. Hardin creates a scenario based on lifeboat to represents how the globe is divided into two class: rich and poor nations. Hardin, implies how the lifeboat represents the limit capacity of the lifeboat. The author is assuring if population keeps overleaping, that our resources are becoming limited.…

    • 635 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Politics in Humanitarian Aid
    • 821 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Politics in Humanitarian Aid

    The continent of Africa and nearly all of its countries have become dependent on European humanitarian aid. This means that the countries of Africa have no political check and thus must rely on the hegemony of European nations. As the ability of these African countries, for example, to be free from self-dependence forms large inequalities of power, it leaves the door open for modern humanitarian aid to see its consequences become much more severe, especially opening up the door for colonialist actions by donor antagonists or violent actions such as those from rebels against French hegemony in Mali. Placing political restrictions on humanitarian aid to foreign countries creates the political check between the recipient countries of aid, such as those in Africa, alleviating the consequences and even the need for strong and prevalent humanitarian aid, even increasing the effectiveness of aid.…

    • 821 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping Poor
    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping Poor

    In the seventies and eighties, a neoconservative development broke with the official talk of America's great intentions. New voices started to substitute an intense, hardcore anticipation of what was required for national survival in an overpopulated world. Garrett Hardin is a main neoconservative scholarly who in his generally distributed about compositions assaults the conventional compassionate perspectives of the "blame ridden," "inner voice stricken" liberal. He has a doctorate in science from Stanford University, has taught at the University of California at Santa Barbara, and has addressed at different colleges. He is the writer of books and articles on "human biology"- the investigation of how human life is maintained on our planet.…

    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Garrett Hardin's Lifeboat Ethics
    • 268 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Garrett Hardin's Lifeboat Ethics

    In college it is a common sight to see students crowding a room on the first day to try to get a spot in a class that is a requirement to graduate, but most of them already know they might not be able to get a spot in the class. This phenomenon is an example of the idea of “lifeboat” ethics. Garrett Hardin, the writer of Lifeboat Ethics, said in his writings “So we sit here, say fifty people in our life boat... let us assume that it has room for ten more… [we] see one hundred others swimming in the water outside, begging for admission in to our boat...” (Hardin 415). Hardin’s Lifeboat Ethics is about the concept that we’re on a boat and we’re trying to decide who will get on the lifeboat and survive. Though we are not in the open sea, our…

    • 268 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Rhetorical Analysis Of Lifeboat Ethics
    • 2561 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Rhetorical Analysis Of Lifeboat Ethics

    I chose Lifeboat Ethics: The Case against Helping the Poor, by Garret Hardin, to analyze because, out of all the readings I have ever done for English, this particular one is by far the most memorable. It is also perfectly suited for my argument, because it is appropriately as offensive as it is logical. The essay, in short, is a rhetorical argument that claims that helping the poor or unfortunate people of the world-though it is considered the “right” thing to do- is, in actuality, harmful to the very future of our species. The actual message of the essay, however, is not what I want to endorse. When this essay was assigned to my class junior year,…

    • 2561 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Lifeboat Ethics By Nancy Ehrenberg: Article Analysis
    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Lifeboat Ethics By Nancy Ehrenberg: Article Analysis

    In the United States and in many other countries when women get pregnant, they often talk about the immediate bond between mother and her unborn child. However, in other countries and cultures, women don't feel a bond with their unborn children until the child is born healthy, happy and grows to a certain age. There are people who think the issue of bonding with your child is culturally based and others argue that this bonding takes place naturally. While Nancy Scheper-Hughs argues that mother-infant bonding is culturally based and occurs over a period of time, Lucinda J. Peach refutes this argument by saying that there is an immediate and natural bond between a mother and unborn child. I will compare and contrast these two articles and their…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor
    • 678 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor

    The world consists of different people, civilizations, and ways of life. There are many situations that call for different ways of handling them, like poverty, overpopulation, resources, and famine aid. Two very different points of view about these issues are espoused in two very different essays written decades apart, “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor” by Garrett Hardin and “A Modest Proposal” by Jonathan Swift. Hardin’s view of civilization and the world, although harsh, has facts that could help improve the issues. Even though Swift’s opinion has personal perspective, it isn’t very realistic.…

    • 678 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    PHI 208 Week 2 assignment
    • 1300 Words
    • 6 Pages

    PHI 208 Week 2 assignment

    In Peter Singer’s 1972 post titled “Famine, Affluence and Morality”, he conveys that wealthy nations, for example the United States, has an ethical duty to contribute much a lot more than we do with regards to worldwide assistance for famine relief and/or other disasters or calamities which may happen. In this document, I will describe Singers objective in his work and give his argument with regards to this problem. I will describe 3 counter-arguments to Singer’s view which he tackles, and after that reveal Singer’s reactions to those counter-arguments. I will explain Singer’s idea of marginal utility and also differentiate how it pertains to his argument. I will compare how the ideas of duty and charity alter in his suggested world. To conclude, I will provide my own reaction about this problem supporting singer’s argument. Should wealthier nations have a moral duty to relieve poorer nations if a disastrous event were to happen? I think that we all must contribute in times of need even if this means substantially modifying the way in which we live for the objective of assisting other people so long as it doesn't cause us to suffer.…

    • 1300 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Famine Affluence And Morality Analysis
    • 296 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Famine Affluence And Morality Analysis

    In the essay “Famine, Affluence, and Morality” author, Peter Singer, exercises his theory about everyone’s moral obligation to help world hunger. Every day people make choices, whether it be what pants to wear, what food items to buy at the store, or whether or not you donate money to those suffering. Across the world there are avoidable sufferings according to Singer as long as people do their part; “if it is in our power to prevent something very bad from happening, we ought to morally do it” (889).…

    • 296 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Peter Singer Essay Example
    • 1261 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Peter Singer Essay Example

    Famine, Affluence, and Morality “is an essay written by Peter Singer in 1971 and published in Philosophy and Public Affairs in 1972. It argues that affluent persons are morally obligated to donate far more resources to humanitarian causes than is considered normal in Western cultures. The essay was inspired by the starvation of Bangladesh Liberation War refugees, and uses their situation as an example, although Singer's argument is general in scope. The essay is anthologized widely as an example of Western ethical thinking” (wikipedia.org 2013).…

    • 1261 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Garrett Hardin Lifeboat Ethics Analysis
    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Garrett Hardin Lifeboat Ethics Analysis

    In Garrett Hardin’s “Lifeboat Ethics” he explains that the world we live in is unequal and becoming increasingly poor. He tries to explain that if the poor isn’t controlled then the Earth will become overpopulated and unrestrained. I believe that Hardin’s writing of “Lifeboat Ethics” is effective and persuasive. His writing is persuasive because with every action to fix the poorness of our world he has a counter, Hardin uses numbers and percentages to show how the population increases of poor countries versus rich ones, and he also paints pictures in people’s heads very well.…

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    “Lifeboat Ethics: the Case Against Helping Poor”, summary
    • 261 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “Lifeboat Ethics: the Case Against Helping Poor”, summary

    In his article “Lifeboat Ethics: the Case Against Helping Poor,” Garrett Hardin argues that our planet faces the problem of overpopulation. The reproduction rate in poor countries is much higher than in rich countries. Therefore, while population of poor nations is increasing tremendously, the ratio of rich nations steadily decreases. Hardin also introduces the concept of “The Tragedy of The Commons’’ and explains it as a negative effect on consumers of common resources around the world. It has already occurred in today’s society and not only polluted our environment but also led to overpopulation. The initiative of rich countries to help the poor resulted in creation of The World Food Bank. Yet, Hardin claims that this program stops the development of poor nations and lets them rely on rich countries when emergency occurs. While trying to find a solution for this problem and help the poor, the Rockefeller and Ford Foundations made the “Green Revolution” program, the goal of which is to teach poor nations to grow “miracle wheat” and “miracle rice.” Hardin argues that this program resulted in the spread of cancer and overloading the environment; thus, by trying to save people from starvation, other harms were created. Hardin beliefs that immigration is another push factor of the overpopulation issue because it allows people to escape from poor nations and burden the ecosystem of rich countries. Consequently, in “Lifeboat Ethics: the Case Against Helping Poor,” Garrett Hardin suggests that our planet could be saved only by following these advices otherwise, there will be nothing left to the next generations.…

    • 261 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    A Change Must Come
    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages

    A Change Must Come

    Singer’s goal in his article, “Famine, Affluence and Morality,” was to inform the viewers of their moral obligation to people suffering from obtaining their basic necessities. In relaying this to his audience, Singer used East Bengal’s current state of suffering as an example. Right now, people who reside in East Bengal are currently suffering because of lack food , shelter, and medical care. While referring to the current situation in Bengal, Singer argues that relatively affluent countries react to situations like Bengal’s in improper manner and it can not be justified. What Singer wants his audience to understand is that if we can prevent something horrible from happening, without causing more harm, we should do it. Singer not only believes that we ought to do it but he also feels that it is something we should , morally. In other words, it is the right thing to do to prevent anything bad from happening.…

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Research Paper On Somalia's Famine
    • 1190 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Research Paper On Somalia's Famine

    Famine fluctuates with war, so famine is an expected event, that’s comes and goes. As long as there will be civil war. With the current division of the country and the current uprising of a Al Shabaab makes the nation a war -zone with almost 8 front lines. This is all we have to understand about Somalia's famine: a process that has no solution with a war in place. Countries in Africa that are not in war find it difficult to approach poverty and development issues. Somalia, a country listed as last in the Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) by Transparency International in 2009 and ranked next to last between Iraq and Afghanistan by the Institute for Economy and Peace on its Global Peace Index (GPI), it is easy to assume that this country has a long way to go, to even think about the famine as an approachable issue in the current situation. War is just the engine of this chaotic situation within Somalia where a vicious circle is the non-exit spiral of hunger and…

    • 1190 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Obesity in Americans
    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Obesity in Americans

    It is especially important to examine this criticism of American affluence in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. An assumption underlying much of the discussion is that, at the very least, wealth did America no good in its battle with nature. An editorial in last weekend's UK Guardian caught the tone: 'America is the richest and most powerful country on Earth. But its citizens, begging for food, water and help, are suffering agonies more familiar from Sudan and Niger. The worst of the third world has come to the Big Easy.' The implication is that America's wealth is somehow pointless.…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More

Related Topics