Critical Book Review : No Shame in My Game

Topics: Wage, Minimum wage, Working class Pages: 4 (1597 words) Published: May 23, 2005
When someone thinks of the poor they instantly imagine a homeless man sleeping in a cardboard box or the nearest garbage can, but the working poor especially in the inner-city is commonly overlooked by society. However the working poor, in this case the working poor in the inner-city, are people advancing to try and make their lives better. They are taking minimum wage jobs so that they can barely afford a roof over their heads. Within Katherine Newman's novel No Shame In My Game, she studies the working poor in the inner-city to draw conclusions about how to help them and dispute common stereotypes and the images people commonly view. Newman's conclusions along with the way she had conducted her case study will be evaluated for her positive and negative points while searching for any biases she may have portrayed within her novel.

Even before I started reading Katherine Newman's novel No Shame In My Game I had learned a little about Newman's background, which may cause her to have a bias towards her case study. Newman is clearly within the middle class even perhaps towards the upper end. She is a Harvard anthropologist that would seem to have never experienced such situations as her subjects. Like most of the middle class she could simply have thought that the poor were only the few men in cardboard boxes in rough neighborhoods and not truly consider the working poor in the inner-city until the case study was started and her thesis written. This could greatly affect her procedures in observing data with her hundreds of subjects over the span of a few years. The thinking of someone who is not within the working class may flaw the order and process at which the case study was conducted. There may be variables that Newman did not consider and did not research that could change her data and conclusions. Using the social scientific method to collect data and revise her hypothesis involves knowing all the angles and variables that are applied, but if an extra...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Essay on My book
  • Essay about Book Review on The Hunger Games
  • The Hunger Games Book Review Essay
  • Hunger Games Book Review Essay
  • Essay on Critical Book Review
  • critical review Essay
  • Essay on Killing Kennedy Critical Book Review
  • The Inner Game of Tennis Book Review Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free