Preview

Critical Analysis on Hird's "Gender's Nature: Intersexuality, Transsexualism and the Sex Gender Binary"

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
912 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Critical Analysis on Hird's "Gender's Nature: Intersexuality, Transsexualism and the Sex Gender Binary"
Critical Reading on Gender’s Nature: Intersexuality, Transsexualism and the Sex/Gender Binary

In this article, Hird’s uses feminist theory to support her studies, involving postmodernist concepts to the morphological notion of ‘sex’. She advanced on by unifying her study with evidence from two bodily forms: intersexuality and transsexualism that are currently challenging the modern ‘sex/gender’ binary. The purpose for Hird to take intersexuality and transsexualism into her argument is to demonstrate that it is not unusual for people to be born with an indefinite sex; ‘sex’ is socially inscribed and ambivalent; transsexuals who refuse to identify themselves undermine the two-sex and gender system or determine on an obscure sexual identity.
Hird recognizes that the sex/gender binary result in women’s oppression and the bifurcation between ‘sex’ and ‘gender’ rise the issue of challenging the hierarchical relationship that subservient women to men. However, she argues that these fix notions of feminism and ‘sex/ gender’ need rigorous attention in order to perceive understandings about nature and it’s relevancy to sex/ gender.

Hird illustrates how feminist theories respecting ‘sex/ gender’ binary and indicate that ‘sex’ is biological and natural that initiates the social construction of gender.
She clarifies how interrelated assumptions occur and ‘sex/gender’ binary often taken for granted due to the combination between nature and biology. Futhermore, when understanding the natures value, she supports her arguments base on feminist theorist Judith Butler (1990) points that “gender operates as an act of cultural inscription’.
Hird seems to be successful in supporting her notion that challenges the ‘sex/gender’ binary, where the constitution of the physical body inflict the cultural inscription of gender. Hird applies Wittig’s (1993) theory of lesbian identity as an example, where the ‘sex/gender’ premise fails to work. Lesbians

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Biology alone determines whether a person is female or male, not culture, but cultural myths outline the roles women and men play in society. These cultural myths constitute to the lack of differentiation between sex and gender, imposing the idea of nature versus nurture. While one is born either female or male due to biology, one’s culture ultimately makes one into a woman or a man. Society has predisposed images of what it means to be feminine or masculine. These gender roles limit the individual’s potential, making humans into performers that must conform to their “appropriate” roles. Being a man should not rely on appearing dominant, aggressive, or never admitting to weaknesses, nor should a woman’s life depend on her reproductiveness…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Compulsory Heteronormativity

    • 4212 Words
    • 17 Pages

    will be dominantly on heteronormativity. I will try to prove that both heteronormativity and gender are social constructs, which means that they are all learned behaviours by society through culture, tradition and religion. I will show a world where any norms and taboos exist, to turn our origins of nature. I will support my argument…

    • 4212 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    What Is Normal?

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In her article Believing is Seeing, Judith Lorber writes of the very fine line between gender and sex. She argues that neither sex nor gender is a pure category of classification. They are more so just a combination of the two of them in the social construction of gender statuses. Her article uses sports and technological competence to show how society transforms physiological differences into gendered social bodies. Lorber’s perspective, “goes beyond the accepted feminist views that gender is a cultural overlay that modifies physiological differences” (Lorber 569), and instead, argues that the physical differences in the male and female bodies are what lead people to behave in ways that fit their category. This is what ultimately causes gendered physical transformation. This paper will use sports, technological competence and basic human nature to examine the idea that society is the cause of gendered people.…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    There are differing views when it comes to defining gender. Some use gender to focus on biological differences such as sex, physical differences or hormones (Guarian 2002: 20). Others refer to ‘gender’ as the social constructions of masculinity and femininity (ATL 2004: 9 and Francis et al 2005: 73) meaning boys’ and girls’ behaviours and attitudes, which are not necessarily fixed by their biological make up. There is therefore a need to realise that ‘gender’ can be and often is regularly an interchangeable term that can be suited to both of these definitions.…

    • 2133 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The ideology that gender is socially constructed is a view that has been present in a number of philosophical, sociological and psychological theories. This view shares the understanding that gender is a result of enculturation through a prescribed ideal, and that society deems what is considered socially appropriate behaviour. Carol Vance, a feminist scholar, argues that gender and sexuality are not to be understood as “natural”, but rather as a socially constructed truth (Grewal, Kaplan 29). This reflects that society is shaped globally through social order. Each culture and society shares a social order that is unique to a particular set of customs, values and practices. These customs are engrained within society as individuals share a…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A consideration of how psychology approaches the study of sex and gender reveals, amongst others, four significant theoretical perspectives that are for the most part quite distinct in terms of their objects of knowledge and consequent methods of analysis. Biological psychology is concerned with explaining the differences between male and female in terms of hormones, genes and brain structure. It is mechanistic, with a strong empirical tradition. Evolutionary psychology attempts to explain differences between sexes in terms of behavioural selection for reproductive fitness. Whilst in large part necessarily theoretical, it embraces empirical methods as a means of testing theories. Social constructionist psychology approaches sex and gender through the study of discourse in various historical, cultural and social contexts and so is hermeneutic. Finally psychoanalytic psychology primarily uses clinical observation and the study of infants to gather evidence of how humans acquire and develop a sense of sex and gender (cited in Holloway et al, 2007, pp.127ff). (6)…

    • 3118 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In this essay I discuss that "doing gender means creating differences between girls and boys and women and men...." (West & Zimmerman 2002:13) I am concentrating on the female perspective, how societyputs forth expectations of what is 'natural' or biological even though, in some cases, it can be quite demeaning and degrading. I am using some examples from the local media and also a few childhoodexperiences that have helped me to now strongly suspect that the quote from Simone Beauvoir (1972) "One is not born a woman, but rather becomes one" most likely has quite a bit of truth to it.…

    • 1814 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Serano does the same for the more accepted theory in WGS, the social constructionist view of gender, which Judith Lorber describes when she writes, “gender, like culture, is a human production that depends on everyone constantly ‘doing gender’” (54). As Serano explores these ideas, students also encounter key concepts such as subconscious sex, a term she coined as “the gender we subconsciously feel ourselves to be” and questions the term gender identity (78), which Launius and Hassel define as “a person’s gendered sense of self” (192). In turn, students encounter a non cis-gendered perspective on gender. They begin to think critically about the other texts they encounter in this course, and to question various perceptions of gender in society. Truly, this text is important as it not only helps to explain how WGS have historically thought about gender, but it begins to encourage students to truly engage with and question what they have learned inside and outside of the…

    • 576 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In her essay, One is Not Born a Woman, Monique Wittig explains, “‘Women’ is not each one of us, but the political and ideological formation which negates ‘women’ (the product of a relation of exploitation). ‘Women’ is there to confuse us, to hide the reality ‘women’ . . . For what makes a woman is a specific social relation to a man, a relation that we call servitude.” Monique Wittig attacks the concept of naturalizing biology and the ‘woman’ category. She believes that the form of a woman’s identity is a product of normal and intrinsic human facts. Thus, her main point is that one is not born a woman but becomes a woman based upon the social constructs of gender and sexuality. This analysis serves to expose the holes in Wittig’s arguments, especially her criteria for a sex-less society.…

    • 1409 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The gendering process frequently involves creating hierarchies between the divisions it enacts. One or more categories of sexed identities are privileged or devalued. In modern western societies, gender divides into two. This is not necessarily the case in other times, places and colures. Gender in the modern west usually refers to two distinct and separate categories of human beings as well as to the division of social practices into two fields. “The gendering of social practices”, according to Beardsley, “may be found, for example in contemporary western societies, in a strong association between men and public life and between women and domestic life, even though men and women occupy both spaces” (10). The more gender differences are narrowed down, the more optimistic scope feminism…

    • 584 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    From the article I have read, this demonstrated the differentiation between the two words “sex” and “gender.” This revealed how many individuals display certain characteristics of what gender they choose to be. Others like to stay in what is considered normal and full of structure because of the ability of being able to reproduce. The article describes how it affects society whether it’s in the personal life and in the work place. We are made to be set in certain gender roles because of culture such as their example of African culture and other cultures who proclaims the ways of how to act, how to dress, and mature and nurtured in the sex they were born with.…

    • 380 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Night To His Day Analysis

    • 454 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In this week’s assignment, we were asked to read Judith Lorber’s Night to His Day: The Social Construction of Gender, and to discuss the following areas. First I will summarize in ordinary language the concept of "gender as structure”. Then we will look how Judith Lorber demonstrated the significant differences that gender categories have for the individual and for society.…

    • 454 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The article, “Two Sexes Are Not Enough” by Fausto-Sterling, makes us question the way in which we choose to classify human beings. The title of this article alone raises several questions to the surface such as, “how many sexes are enough for what?” and, “why are two sexes not enough in the first place”? Ultimately, Fausto-Sterling argues for an increased number of sexes and calls for a distinction between sex and gender (Fausto-Sterling). This distinction is important because within society we often easily mistake the two or interchange their definitions. In class, we discussed that her reason behind her argument looks at “power of discourse to falsely classify humans”.…

    • 490 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gender and Utopia

    • 1219 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Normative definitions of gender were first called into question in the 1960s by feminists who contested the subordination of women in a patriarchal society based on structuralist theories; de Beauvoir famously exclaimed: "One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman" rejecting gender as a state of nature but rather claiming it to be a cultural construction. Queer theory aims to transform public sensibilities towards the relationship between sex, gender and sexuality in the social context and thereby change our understandings of gender and sexual identities. It deconstructs these hegemonic categories which reduce identities to hetero-normativity - gender roles conformed to cultural norms of all-male/all-female and heterosexuality as the normal sexual orientation - and which in turn keep the patriarchal matrixes of society in…

    • 1219 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Queer Theory Essay

    • 2816 Words
    • 12 Pages

    Queer theorists have different ideas on what is 'Queer ' and what is not 'Queer ' and some Queer theorists believe there is no set doctrine in which to be 'Queer ' because that would adhere to the 'norm 's ' of heteronormativity. Examining different 'Queer ' thoughts can help aid our own formulation of what is 'Queer ' and what 'Queer theory ' is to the individual and how it can help develop understandings around sexuality, gender, history, societies, cultures and heteronormativity.…

    • 2816 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics