Critical Analysis of a Wagner Matinee

Good Essays
Ben Braden
Mr. Tatge
Advanced Composition (1)
24 April 2013
Critical Analysis
The Other Side of Love “For those I love I will sacrifice” is a quote by - ("Cite it somewhere"). Many people in life come upon the problem of thinking they found love, but actually lose another love in the process. Willa Cather employs this situation as she uses the character Aunt Georgiana to illustrate how Georgiana must do this while pursuing the love of a man in her famous short story “A Wagner Matinée.” On top of Aunt Georgiana losing love, Cather implements the facts of the hard life people on the frontier have to live. Aunt Georgiana gives up her true love of music for the upstart love of a man to only later realize what great sacrifice she has made.
Aunt Georgiana follows her new love Howard to only find hardships while losing the music that filled her life with joy. Clark begins telling us about Aunt Georgiana’s love Howard Carpenter by saying, “she kindled the callow fancy of the most idle and shiftless of village lads.” Cather begins with this to show us that this man is not one with much desire to succeed and make life easy for him or his family. Making this one of the poorer choices Georgiana has made. However, she developed “absurd and extravagant passions” for this young man that she could not avoid. So much that Aunt Georgiana could not get over this “inexplicable infatuation” for Howard and eloped with him. Aunt Georgiana has fallen in love with this man and has decided to sacrifice her love of music to pursue her love with him. After eloping they then moved to the Nebraska frontier as to avoid the criticism of her family and friends. Cather throws in the part about moving away to avoid criticism to show that others knew and tried to help Georgiana avoid this terrible sacrifice she would be making. Then Clark remembers back to when he lived with his aunt she seldom talked to him about music, and to her her martyrdom was not wholly sordid. This shows how she knows



Cited:

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    A Wagner Matinee

    • 519 Words
    • 3 Pages

    A Wagner Matinee Willa Cather Within a lifetime there are many decisions you have to make. In my lifetime there have not been many big decisions but I have always been reminded that choices you make now will affect you forever. My family has always taught me that you may have only one chance to make the right choice, so choose wisely. Most of the time my father will tell me that I have to make my choice by what my heart tells me and what…

    • 519 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Wagner Matinee Analysis

    • 419 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the short stories, "The Story of an Hour" by Kate Chopin and "A Wagner Matinee" by Willa Cather a similar theme is portrayed about women’s role. Both stories include the main female role giving up something of great significance in her life. For instance, in "The Story of an Hour", Mrs. Mallard gives up her freedom when marrying her husband. In the same manner, in "A Wagner Matinee", Aunt Georgiana gave up her passion and love for music by eloping and moving to Nebraska. Here she would spend…

    • 419 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    There are several purposes Willa Cather has in her short story, "A Wagner Matinee." The two main purposes of this story are to entertain the reader and to reveal a theme. Before discussing theses purposes, back ground on Cather will be given so as to gain as better understanding and appreciation for her writing. Willa Sibert Cather was born December 7th, 1873 on a small farm in Back Creek Valley near Winchester, Virginia. Her mother and father, Mary and Charles Cather, had seven children, Willa…

    • 1301 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Vicki Glenn ENG 232 Mr. O September 26, 2011 “A Wagner Matinee” It has been said that, "Sacrificing your happiness for the happiness of the one you love is by far, the truest type of love.” However, walking away from everything that makes you happy in life, in order for another to be happy should not be required of love. Relationships should be built on mutual respect and consideration for one another. Although compromise in a relationship is a necessary component for its success, denying the core…

    • 1687 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Homestead Act. Many individuals and families went west to seek their fortune and a home on what was once called the great American desert. Moving westward was a difficult process, and many were forced to leave their old lives behind completely. In "A Wagner Matinee," written by Willa Cather, the characterization of Aunt Georgiana, a woman who leaves Boston to elope with a young man going west, is used to illustrate the theme; that sometimes decisions need to be made, and although one might regret it, one…

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    are as follows. 1. The dominant impression of to build a fire is the naturalistic Point of view both man and beast, even though their own two hands of the spectrum they share in a naturalistic Point of view 2. The dominant impression of a Wagner matinee is and Georgina's sacrifice through her Exile from art and beauty 3. The dominant impression of the jilting of granny Weatherall is denial. Granny is in denial that she is dying, she is I denial that her illness is causing her confusion. She…

    • 355 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Authors like Willa Cather, Kate Chopin, and Sarah Orne Jewett were able to portray the struggles a woman would have in the time in a way nobody else had dared to. Willa Cather was an author who wrote about the woman’s place in society in “A Wagner Matinee.” Cather criticized the way women were forced to give up their passions for their husband and family.…

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Comprehensive Analysis of “A Wagner Matinee” and “The Story of an Hour” On the surface, “A Wagner Matinee” and “The Story of an Hour” seem like completely different stories, with a dissimilar plot and unlike settings. “A Wagner Matinee” is a story about the effects and hardships of living on the Great Plains, and the sustaining power of music on the human spirit, while “The Story of an Hour” expresses the constraints of marriage in the 19th century. However, after thoroughly reading both stories…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ty Decker Period 2 “A Pair of Silk Stockings” and “A Wagner Matinee” These two novels have a lot in common. Each of them has its own storyline but each seems to discuss the same topic and have the same meaning. Woman in that time were greatly underappreciated ad were unable to do a lot of things that they wanted to do in their life. They were expected to be nothing more than mothers and wives. Each of these novels portrays something more, and how they were able to enjoy themselves outside of family…

    • 305 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    and duties that women play in society. Women are expected to make unconditional sacrifices and fulfill the happiness of their family. The only responsibilities they have are cooking, cleaning, and caring for their loved ones. The short story “Wagner Matinee” by Willa Cather and “A pair of Silk Stockings” by Kate Chopin specify the significant sacrifices women are expected to accomplish during that era. Both women in the short stories live similar lifestyles but have different aspects about themselves…

    • 1496 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays