A Sorrowful Woman
Precious J Head
COM 1102
Professor Smithson
July 15 2012
Critical Analysis of “A Sorrowful Woman” I have chosen to do my critical analysis about Gail Goodwin’s short story of “A Sorrowful Woman”. Throughout this paper I will attempt to breakdown and explain the plot of this story, how the story unfolds from the point of view of Goodwin’s unnamed wife, and the development of the husband’s character as the story is told. From what I can gather from the story as I read through it; the plot is about the gradual progression of the unnamed spouse and mother’s deteriorating emotional well-being. In the story the wife’s life generally revolves around her family and eventually becomes over-whelmed. Gail Goodman’s wife then starts to withdraw from her family until they are completely shut out of her life. Although the wife in the story does have a child it is highly unlikely that the wife would be suffering from any post-partum stress associated with child birth; as the child in the story during the events is already a toddler. Gail Goodman’s wife is unhappy with her current role as a housewife and seeks to explore different roles, but has a hard time coping when faced with making more engaging decisions when they are presented to her. In the story the wife is the protagonist, and the antagonist in some ways can be described as her family, because they are the source of her frustrations. As the story develops rather than recovering, the wife tends to progressively get worse; regardless of any efforts by her husband to help her. With all the events that unfold in the story it becomes easy to see that the wife’s actions is a clear dissatisfaction of her role and a willingness to fulfill her duties. Towards the end of the story it
Head 2 would appear that the wife has recovered from her illness, but instead the opposite remains true; as she prefers to have no interaction with anyone in her family. Just as important as the plot to understanding the story of “A Sorrowful Woman” is the point of view of the wife. The wife’s point of view in the story is instrumental, because it is through the wife that the author is trying to reach and influence the emotions of the audience. In the opening paragraphs of the story Gail Goodman’s portrayal of the family is that of an ideal family in the time of which the story takes place. Once the author finishes setting the story the reader is then allowed to enter the story through the point of view of the wife. Through the wife view the reader sees a woman who loves, cares, and provides for her family in the role of a traditional house wife. In the story the wife life is very structured and basically repeats itself day after day. One night while washing the dishing; while the husband is asleep watching t.v. in the living room after dinner; as usual the wife loses it. Through the wife point of view the audience is initially led to feel sorry her, because it is obvious that she has become over- whelmed with her responsibilities; evidenced by her uncontrollable weeping and irritability to her son. Eventually the husband has to hire help to take care of his son while his mother recovers from her illness. I believe that the wife feels threatened by the nanny and has her relieved. Although Gail Goodman’s wife is unable to be the mother she needs to, she does not want anyone else taking that role either. The wife point of view of the world is a difficult has she has trouble to even express her freedom in writing a poem that has no restrictions or rules; this is a clear indication of how trapped the wife had felt with her previous duties. The point of view of the wife is ideal to understanding not only herself, but the development of the husband’s character as the story progresses. The development of the husband in Gail Goodman’s” A Sorrowful Woman” is a very interesting one. In the opening sentences in the book it appears that the husband is as any other husband in the in
Head 3 which this story was wrote. The husband is the sole provider for the family as his wife is a stay at home wife. When the wife first loses her sanity, or becomes over- whelmed with her life it would appear that the husband is a key contributor; It can be said that the husband was antagonizes to his wife unknowingly. Upon first reading of the sequence of events one would think that the husband was insensitive to his wife’s needs. The events that occurred after the wife’s meltdown easily shows how much the husband actually acres for his wife. The husband takes care of the remaining dishes, puts her to sleep, and takes care of their son for the remainder of the night. I believe that this passage was essential into the building of the husband’s character, because it throws out any notion of his insensitiveness and immediately recognizes him as a loving husband; thus changing the way the reader perceives him. Throughout the remainder of the remainder of the story the thoughtful and selfless acts of the husband clearly builds and paints a vivid picture of the character that he is in the story. The development of the husband in Gail Goodman’s “A sorrowful Woman” is one of great interest; the husband goes from being the potential cause for his wife’s ailment, but through the development of his character the opposite becomes apparent. In the critical analysis we have looked at the plot of the story; which is about a woman who becomes over-whelmed with the pressures of her life and slides into a deep depression. The point of view observed was that of the wife; it is through her point of view that certain key aspects are revealed about herself and the world around her. The final aspect of the analysis was the development of the husband in the story.
Head 4
Works cited
Meyer, Michael. (2010) The Compact Bedford Introduction to Literature: Reading, Thinking, Writing (9th Ed.).
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Karen Van Der Zee’s “A Secret Sorrow” is a novel that definitely knows how to play with words. Its writing is dramatic and intensely emotional, moving quickly from soft words to shouts of anger. This might be an intense and gripping moment for some, but I was put off by its generic, soap style plot. Faye does not want to tell Kai that she cannot have children, but after refusing to marry, Kai is persistent to get at the truth. The style and content of the novel’s writing definitely caught my attention. It has a great use of loud tones and catchy lines. Some will enjoy Kai telling Faye that she is “’Not a damaged piece of merchandise, you hear? You’re a living, breathing human being, a warm-blooded female, and I love you’.”(135) It’s when I'm sucked in that this novel falls apart. The plot is overly simplistic. The characters are bland and lifeless. Faye lacks female leadership, confidence, and anything else of interest, which leads to groans whenever she talks of how she “can’t live all [her] life with [Kais] regret and disappointment’” “‘every time [they’re] with somebody else’s children She’ll feel She’s failed [Kai]!” It was a good ride, but in the end, I feel unsatisfied. A Secret Sorrow will please those who don’t mind the intense soap style drama, but if a person doesn’t like romance, this won’t change her mind.…
- 256 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The one element that Godwin really hits on in the short story to strengthen the overall theme is the use of fairy tale aspect. At the beginning of the narrative, Godwin inserts a line before the actual story starts that reads, “Once upon a time there was a wife and mother one too many times” (Meyer 36). In this line, she is trying to put the point across to the reader that this short story will challenge the notion of what women desire. Godwin tries to portray that the wife in her story is not the normal wife and mother, like in most fairy tales. The wife in A Sorrowful Woman resembles the exact opposite of what women in fairy tales were portrayed as. In most fairy tales, the woman usually finds prince charming, gets married, has children and lives happily ever after. She desires to different and hopes for a changed role in society. The reader doesn’t know about the wife and husband’s life before their child’s birth, however some passages presume that she had a…
- 1253 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
The husband also does not take his wife’s condition seriously she states this in several different places throughout the story. “You see, he does not believe I am sick” (64). She also says “If a physician of high standing, and one’s own husband, assures friends and relatives that there is really nothing the matter with one but temporary nervous depression—a slight hysterical tendency—what is one to do” (64). These statements make the narrator feel like nothing is wrong with her and that it is all in her…
- 583 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
She seemed to be very dependent on the man that she could not make up her mind. She always has to ask before she decides from ordering her drinks to what to do with her pregnancy. However, she seems as if she had made up her own mind in the end that she’ll be moving forward with her life with him or without him.…
- 466 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
There are many differences between "A Secret Sorrow" and "A Sorrowful Woman". One difference is the problems that the two women face. In "A Secret Sorrow" Faye deals with a physical problem, the inability to produce children. In "A Sorrowful Woman" on the other hand the unnamed wife deals with a psychological problem, making it more complex and difficult to fix. Another difference is the role the men play in the stories. Kai, from "A Secret Sorrow" has a forceful role, he plays the role of the average formula fiction man, he's masculine, strong and tries to save Faye from herself. For instance when Faye told him that he didn't have to be a gentlemen and that it was okay for him to leave her it was interesting when Kai responds with the line "Shut up and stop playing the martyr". He refused to allow herself to give into her insecurities and wallow in self pity. Instead readers constantly see Kai picking Faye up and trying to snap her out of this funk she has slipped into. He spends the entire story trying to force Faye to believe that she is worthy of being loved. The unnamed husband in "A Sorrowful Woman" is the exact opposite of Kai. The unnamed husband is an enabler, always understanding he does not do anything to help his wife get over her problems. Instead he in a way avoids the issue and allows the woman to succumb to her issue eventually resulting in her downfall. It's interesting that Godwin constantly repeats that the husband always understands. It shows that he realizes his wife is having trouble and he wants to help however the way he attempts to help just perpetuates the issue instead of resolving it. He complies with his obviously unhinged wife's demands and behaviors, just understanding not fixing. He allows her to get away with things such as hitting the child, firing the nanny and not doing her household responsibilities. The battle is lost when the husband allows his wife to isolate herself from her family and move into a separate…
- 754 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In the short story “From a Secret Sorrow” by Karen Van Der Zee a woman who struggles to tell her fiancé a truth that is killing her inside. The story focuses on two main characters, Faye and Kai. Faye is a woman who thought that the world was over for her after finding out she was infertile. Faye had no idea on how to communicate such horrendous news to Kai, her fiancé. She was afraid that her Kai was going to leave her and find someone else. She then started acting weird, nervous, and distanced herself from him. Her fiancé questioned her about a note he found, Faye immediately recognized that it was the note the doctor gave her and with a terrified voice asked “How did you get that?” (31). Finding out that she was infertile made her felt sorrow and like she was the only one who had the right to be upset. She thought that Kai was not going to love her anymore but it was the other way around. Kai seemed like he was really in love with her and cared about her. He wanted to let her know that whatever the problem was she was not alone, that it was not only her problem and that they will work together, then eventually get married. But Faye would not listen, she also loved him so much that she would have rather let him go instead of ruining his life with her knowing she is infertile. She knew he would be extremely disappointed and she told Kai that he had the choice to leave her and marry someone else.…
- 2456 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
portrays young, unmarried widow as being at risk. The author draws on the common notion that…
- 1370 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In the short story. "The Yellow Wallpaper" written by Charlotte Perkins Gilman, we are introduced to a woman, the narrator, who suffers from postpartum depression, a disorder in women that results from childbirth. This disorder can have serious effects on the individual and may result in extreme behaviors such as suicide. (Mahoney 1) The narrator of the story is symbolic of Gilman, as she had experienced this illness after the birth of her daughter. (Gilman 181) Postpartum depression is a serious issue that must be dealt with in order to help its victums carry on with everyday life. In order for society to effictively help those affected with postpartum depression, they must know what it is, what its symptoms are, and effective ways to treat the disorder.…
- 711 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
- her husband is totally oblivious to her suffering and interprets life in the suburbs entirely differently…
- 3127 Words
- 13 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Throughout "Death of a Salesman", Arthur Miller presents a very bleak view of women. From the male opinion, to their place in the play, women were subjugated. Some may think this was just a role set out by Arthur Miller for this play. I find this difficult to believe given the ubiquity, leaving me to think that Mr. Miller is an unrelenting misogynist. This is not only demonstrated by the superficial factors such as, dialogue, events, but also the subtle nuances. Factors like setting and relationships. Through this essay I will make clear Arthur Millers true opinion on women evident via events, characters, setting, relationships and dialogue; the much concealed misogyny of Arthur Miller, and Death of a Salesman.…
- 988 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
As such, her storytelling serves as both the representation of the alienated, unlovable woman’s voice as well as the expression of her own emotions. In addition to being silenced due to her race and gender, the female narrator of ‘A Woman Like Me’ is further marginalized and stigmatized due to her occupation as a mortuary cosmetician in a social environment that fears death and associations with it. It is interesting, however, that she is not entirely unique in her situation, for the title itself suggests that she is in fact part of a community that includes other women like her who are ‘unsuitable for any man’s love’(Xi, 1998: 303). Yet, the lack of a voice and representation for this unique group of alienated, unlovable woman is clear - without the female narrator’s telling of Aunt Yifen’s story, her stories would never have been heard – even before Aunt Yifen had become ‘so uncommunicative’, the only audience for her stories besides the narrator were ‘the cadavers who lay in front of her’ (Xi, 1998:308). As with the case of ‘Skeletons of Men’, while there is communication at a personal level with those who understand and identify with the stories ‘hearing’ the voices of the oppressed women, it is the female narrator in ‘A Woman Like Me’ who provides the platform for the stories of the subaltern to reach the readers from a different time and…
- 1164 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Mrs. Bhave is a widowed mother of two who lost her sons and husband to a plane crash. She is viewed as the strongest of the group who lost someone because she has taking everything calmly and wasn’t hysterical or depressed. Judith Templeton, an appointee of the provincial government, came to Mrs. Bhave to ask for her help with talking to some of the other people who had lost someone. Judith is pushing he and everyone else to move on with their lives and to accept help and start over, but the older generation of her nationality had different view on how to deal with the loss of a loved one.…
- 465 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The women in this story is more than a mystery to figure out. The author doesn't give you a real reason as to why she acts the way she does. Its for the reader to figure out themselves. The women in this story is more like dependent and to herself. She doesn't pay attention to her son, and she almost has a hate relationship towards the little boy. She works when she wants too, and she has the ability to love her family. Even though she does, she keeps it all to herself. Her husband deeply loves her and he does all the work a wife should do or at least take part in. But in the end of the story she shows the love she has for her family and sort of makes up for what she has lost right before she dies. Being dependent can sometimes be a bad thing. Her relying on her husband for everything to get done and to just sit there and do nothing but complain about a new issue almost every day can mess up ones relationship. But the father still stood by her side and tried to make her the happiest female in her life.…
- 734 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
the wife felt that she wasn't excepted as a woman in the society and that's why she felt unhappy…
- 1059 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The wife’s character is much different than her laid back husband’s. She is involved with everything and seems to be very sociable; furthermore, she sets a goal to help the cat although it is pouring rain outside. Throughout the story she is looking for comfort and support for her actions from her husband. She needs his support to give her confidence to carry through with her plans. The wife is a good example of striving to reach one’s goal…
- 478 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays