Electronic Physician ISSN: 2008-5842
Research Article Crass commercialization and corruption of the Indian medical education system and the resultant decay of the Indian Health Education in the last two decades. A case for urgent international review and monitoring. Deshpande Srinivas Ramachandra1, Deshpande-Naik Gayathree Srinivas2 Melmarvathur Adiparashakti Institute of Medical Sciences, Melmarvathur. Tamilnadu, India, Pin 603319 2 1
Hassan Institute of Medical Sciences, Hassan, Karnataka, India, Pin 573201
Corresponding author: Dr Srinivas R Deshpande MD Associate Professor in Biochemistry, Melmarvathur Adiparashakti Institute of Medical Sciences, Melmarvathur. Tamilnadu, India, Pin 603319 E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org Bibliographic information of this paper for citing: Deshpande Srinivas Ramachandra & Deshpande-Naik Gayathree Srinivas. Crass commercialization and corruption of the Indian medical education system and the resultant decay of the Indian Health Education in the last two decades. A case for urgent international review and monitoring. Electron. Pysicician 2009, 1:9-16, Available at: http://www.ephysician.ir/2009/916.pdf Received: 16 July 2009 Accepted: 25 September 2009 Published: 30 October 2009 © 2009 Electron. Physician Indian medical education system has seen rapid growth in the last two decades. Private medical colleges now account for more than half of the 270 medical colleges in 2009. This unregulated unequal growth brings two issues to focus: the failing quality of medical education and implementing effective solutions to address an artificial faculty shortage due to faculty mal-distribution. The menace posed by the unfettered merchandisation of medical education has to be controlled and efforts should be made by the Government to ensure maintenance of standards and check the unplanned growth of substandard medical colleges and substandard education norms in universities or their constituent
[Electron. Physician 2009; 1: 9‐16]
medical colleges. Since Indian Independence, MCI nor the University Grants Commission nor the constituent universities including the health sciences universities have never attempted to grade medical colleges as per their quality standards hence in the absence of health education quality standards, the student output from recent, hurriedly established recent science institutions is definitely substandard. There is a strong case for a review of the entire system of medical education and examinations in the country. Some solutions like increasing retirement ages of MD faculty to 70 years, sharing of faculty, increasing the total number of MD seats, allowing standard institutions like IIT’s to take over substandard colleges, allowing clinical MDs to teach para-clinical and pre-clinical subjects or temporary merger of specialties may address the widely publicized faculty shortage instead of relying on inadequately qualified MSc. nonmedical faculty.
Electronic Physician 2009; Vol 1, Pages 9-16
Keywords: Qualified Medical teacher, India, medical colleges, faculty shortage, Medical Council of India (MCI).Abbreviations DCI=Dental Council of India. MSc=Master of Science, IIT’s=Indian Institutes of Technology, DNB=Diplomate National Board, RGUHS=Rajiv Gandhi University of Health sciences INTRODUCTION Establishing a medical college requires a huge number of qualified, competent, medical council compliant manpower to produce quality doctors (1, 4, and 7). Having established a Medical College, maintaining the high standards of education to world acceptable levels with a vision to eradicate health scourges has been a concern of the Indian planning committees. Also, the good name a health care institution attains is due to the all-round accomplishments of its faculty and alumni. In that regard, proper emphasis on the quality of medical education ,in spite of the recent rapid proliferation of private medical colleges, has rightly been the working domain of...
References: 1. Madhok P.Medical tuitions .Issues in Medical Ethics 1997; 5: 23 2. Chinoy R. F: Medical ethics: relationships between doctors.Ind J Med Ethics 3. Qadeer I: The real crisis in medical education. Ind J Med Ethics 4. Chattopadhyay S: Black money in white coats: whither medical ethics? Ind J Med Ethics ;Jan-Mar 2008(1) 5. Bansal P, Supe A. Training of medical teachers in India: Need for change. Indian J Med Sci [serial online] 2007 [cited 2008 Oct 1]; 61:478-84. Available from: http://www.indianjmedsci.org/text.asp?2007 /61/8/478/32930 6. Nair KR :Medical college teachers and some ethical issues in Kerala .Ind J Med Ethics 7. Ananthakrishnan N: Acute shortage of teachers in medical colleges: Existing problems and possible solutions.NMJI Jan/Feb 2007: Vol 20, No 1:1-8. 8. Aggarwal A. Strengthening the health care system in India: Is privatization the only answer? Editorial. Indian J Community Med: April 2008; Vol 33; Isuue 2; 69-70. 9. Dutta R. Rash of medical colleges spawns corruption and mediocrity. Express Healthcare Management, August 2002 10. Richards T. Impressions of Medicine in India; Medical education in India-in poor health. British Medical Journal Volume 290; 13 April 1985;1132-34. 11. Sood R & Adkoli BV. Medical Education in India – Problems and Prospects. Journal of Indian Academy of Clinical Medicine Vol. 1, No. 3; OctoberDecember 2000; 210-12. 12. Mahapatra D .Ramadoss nod to medical college despite SC no-Times of India National edition;29 Sep 2008, 0054 hrs IST, TNN. [Electron. Physician 2009; 1: 9‐16]
19). 13. India to recognize foreign medical degrees :an article published in India Chronicle a monthly e-newsletter@ Issue No 002;March 2008 http://indianembassy.ru 14. Rajeev D & Mahapatra D .Did Ramadoss flout dental council norms? Times of India National edition;30 Sep 2008, 0449 hrs IST, TNN 15. Sood R. Medical education in India ;Medical Teacher, Volume 30, Issue 6 2008 , pages 585 - 591 16. Yashpal wants a super regulator; death to deemed universities http://www.academicsindia.com/yashpal_report.htm Accessed on10.7.2009 (On Prof Yashpal Committee to Advise on Renovation and Rejuvenation of Higher Education in India; released on June 24, 2009). 17. Ramachandran R.University Business: Systemic flaws and corrupt practices result in the mushrooming of deemed and private universities, many of them with dubious credentials. Cover story in Frontline July 17, 2009:www.Frontline.in.Pages 4-30. 18. Dilip Thakore, Gaver C, Autar N, Hemalatha R & Vidya P Shame & scandals in academia: Corruption cancer destroying Indian academia :Cover Story http://www.educationworldonline.net/index. php/page-article-choice-more-id875.Accessed 10.7.2009 19. Andrzej W& M. Roy Schwarz: Minimum Essential Requirements and Standards in Medical Education http://www.iime.org/documents/vs.htm Accessed 10.07.2009
Please join StudyMode to read the full document