Cost Issues in Medical Ethics

Topics: Health care, Health economics, Medicine Pages: 7 (2241 words) Published: December 11, 2005
Understanding the Price: Cost Issues in Medical Ethics
By: S. Michael Robinson
PHL 310

Understanding the Price: Cost Issues in Medical Ethics
Medical ethicists contend with scores of contentious and controversial issues, yet no issue affects such a broad sector of the population as issues of medical cost and cost responsibility. Beyond mere policy debate, an ethical analysis of medical costs must consider all aspects of health, from research, practice methodology, and public health policy, but also legal, social and economic factors that impact health. This document will revue these issues and focus on three core questions: Does society or the individual bear the ethical burden of cost issues, is there an ethical argument to limit liberties or privileges in the interest of reducing health costs and to what extent should cost efficiency be a factor applied when determining care?

As we enter the 21st century, experts foresee a looming crisis in providing healthcare within the United States. Government entitlements, such as Medicare and Medicaid, face impending insolvency, private employers seek to remove medical expenses to reduce costs and insurers raise premiums and co-pays, preventing many citizens from obtaining adequate healthcare. Establishing an effective and ethical response to the issues of health care remains a top priority of planners, policymakers and politicians in the coming years.

Health care carries the burden of cost. Who carries the burden of this cost faces constant debate in the fields of philosophy, economics and medicine. On one hand, the individual, who is the primary beneficiary of health care benefits, holds a responsibility to repay the costs incurred by the benefits in question. The opposite perspective views the individual as a societal component, insured to good health as a benefit of membership to the larger whole. As the individual benefits society, so society holds an obligation to provide health services to insure his or her continued productivity. Examining both extremes in detail clarifies the issues involved in health care costs.

The perspective of total individual responsibility reflects a strong belief in the autonomy of the individual from society. As a result, the individual alone must bear the burdens of his actions and choices. From a strictly individualist viewpoint, all decisions carry consequences, and to some degree the individual is liable for any outcomes experienced as a result of these choice. From this perspective, while the individual has the right to seek medical care, there is no obligation to provide care if the practitioner is unwilling. Individualism carries strong connections to natural law theory, and views society and government as artificial creations with limited rights, powers and obligations. Needless to say, from an individualist perspective, providing, managing or limiting healthcare is not among government powers or responsibilities .

A strictly individualistic generally encourages personal responsibility and places costs based on who directly receives the benefit, rather than speculating on who instigated the problem. However, this perspective carries with it implications that cause substantial problems. Because cost responsibility defaults to the primary beneficiary, it becomes difficult to transfer obligation to an injurious party in circumstances where evidence warrants redress. The individualist perspective requires a tort system to handle such disputes. This creates additional costs both for the individual (i.e. legal fees) and the medical provider. These additional costs do not provide additional health benefit, and largely inflate the cost of care. Secondly, the individualist perspective strongly emphasizes personal wealth as the determiner for access to health care. This leads to a problem in instances where misfortunes, rather than poor choices, result in health problems....

Bibliography: Andre, Claire et all. System Overload: Pondering the Ethics of America 's Health Care System Issues in Ethics - Vol. 3, Issue. 3 summer 1990 p. 3
Anonymous,, Dec 1, 2005
Anonymous,, Nov 20, 2005
Emmet B. Keeler, Journal of Medical Practice Management, Vol. 8, Summer 1992, pp: 317-321
Milstead, Jeri A., Health Policy and Politics: A Nurses Guide, 1999. Aspen Publishers, Gaithersberg
Munson, Ronald, Intervention and Reflection:Basic Issues in Medical Ethics. 2004, Thompson Belmont, Belmont
Rudrick, William, Encyclopedia of Ethics. Lawrence and Charlotte Becker, eds. 2nd edition. Garland 1998
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • ethics Essay
  • Ethic Issues Essay
  • Summary of 1847 Medical Code of Ethics Essay
  • Medical Ethics Essay
  • Indifference Curves
  • Medical Ethics Essay
  • Medical Ethics Essay
  • Medical Ethics Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free