top-rated free essay

Controversy About Jose Rizal

By yhatzki Mar 10, 2011 557 Words
Controversy about Jose Rizal

There are many controversies that are still being debated by scholars whether they are true and valid:

1. One of the major controversies regarding Rizal is about the Retraction Document. This document is one of the proofs regarding the friars' claim that Rizal retracted a few days before his execution. Retraction means that he is taking back what he said against the catholic church in the Philippines and the friars. If this were true, it would mean that Rizal went back to become a Catholic again after being a mason in Europe. Some say he did this in order to marry his Irish partner, Josephine Bracken, which leads us to the next controversy...

2. Another controversy with Rizal is whether or not he actually married Josephine Bracken after being a Catholic again. Scholars say that there were no written accounts of the marriage between Rizal and Josephine, but Josephine claims that Rizal actually married him a day before his execution.

3. Another controversy that questions the authenticity of being a national hero of Rizal is whether Rizal was actually in favor of the revolution during that time. Was he a Revolutionist or a Reformist. Did he really wish to free the Philippines from the colonization of Spain, or did he just want to make Philippines a province of Spain?

There are many more minor controversies of Rizal during his time: 1. Rizal was a ladies' man or he is a womanizer.
2. Rizal did not take a bath for 3 months during his stay in Spain. 3. Rizal was gay(?)
4. Rizal was stingy
5. Rizal went to casinos and was a drunkard.
6. Rizal as the "Brown Messiah" (there is a group of people called Rizalistas that worship him and claim he was a reincarnate of Jesus Christ and that he would someday live again in this world...)

There are also some controversies about the true personality of Josephine Bracken: 1. Her mother was a prostitute.
2. She was a spy of the Spanish government.
3. She was abused by her step father and that the baby she was carrying was not Rizal's but her step father's


Was Rizal a Gay

Filipino historians, particularly those who take pride in their machismo, would perhap cringe. Jose Rizal is, after all, the pride of the Malay race. His writings against colonial rule sparked the revolution against the spaniards and galvanized the imagination of an otherwise fragmented nation. Was he gay? The article by Ambeth Ocampo does not really make such a conclusion, but it raises questions on Rizal’s sexuality. Conservative Filipinos would rather de-sexualize the image of Rizal, but would not refuse to grin everytime they talk about Rizal the womanizer. But gay? Never.

One of his controversy also is about his height.

There were also unresolved or unclear issues:

1. he was a freemason
2. he had several love affairs and fathered a child
3. he admitted to the charges against him and begged for clemency 4. he was not for independence but only for reforms and more liberties. 5. he was chosen by US as phil. natl hero because he didnt advocate armed struggle as against andres bonifacio who did. Source:

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Jose Rizal Film Review

    ...Republic of the Philippines UNIVERSITY OF RIZAL SYSTEM Antipolo Campus NAME: Aileen J. Villacruz DATE: April 28, 2015 COURSE & YEAR: BEEd III PROFESSOR: Mr. Hernan E. Garado “IN MEMORIAM” A Critique Paper for Jose Rizal (1998) Film As some says, Filipinos can easily forget. If this is true, it’s certainly hard ...

    Read More
  • Dr. Jose Rizal

    ...Life, Works & Writings of Rizal Every Filipino should know the national hero’s life, his youth, his brilliant works, as well as his love life, and the role he played in the Philippine Revolution. Every Filipino should know his dreams and aspiration for his country and for his fellowmen and the magnitude and intensity of his love for th...

    Read More
  • Jose Rizal

    ...forming illegal societies, the prosecution arguing that he was responsible for the deeds of those who read his writings. During his imprisonment Rizal began to formulate in his mind his greatest poem who others later entitle, “My Last Farewell.” (later concealed in an alcohol cooking lamp) December 12 --- Rizal appears in a courtroom w...

    Read More
  • An Essay About Jose Rizal

    ...AN ESSAY ABOUT JOSE RIZAL Who is Jose Rizal to common people? What is the impact of his life, woks and writings? When we ask most average persons today these questions, they might answer something like, he is our national hero, he died in Bagumbayan, and he wrote two great novels. Beyond that nothing more is explicitly said about Jose Rizal...

    Read More
  • Controversies of Rizal

    ...Dr. Jose Rizal Controversies Dr. Jose Rizal, the well-loved Philippine national hero, and the brave known genius was famous and will remain famous worldwide. I don’t know if you’ve heard bout him, but of course if you’re a Filipino, you surely know him well because he’s a big part of the Philippine history. Jose Rizal is a star and like...

    Read More
  • Jose Rizal

    ...JOSE P . RIZAL IN SUNNY SPAIN (1882-1885) IN SUNNY SPAIN (1882-1885) After finishing the 4th year of the medical course in the University of Santo Tomas (being disgusted) decided to complete his studies in Spain. At that time the government of Spain was a constitutional monarchy under a written constitution which granted human rights to the...

    Read More
  • Jose Rizal

    ...Jose Rizal is the national hero of the Philippines, one of the Southeast Asian countries. His full name was Jose Protacio Mercado Rizal y Alonzo Realonda. He was born on June 19, 1861 as the 7th child of the eleven children in the family of Francisco Mercado Rizal and Teodora Alonzo Realonda. He was internationally known for his two novels that ...

    Read More
  • Jose Rizal

    ...from and cultures/values 2. Sight 1 poem where Rizal's nationalism is expressed and why? Rizal wrote the poem entitled “Sa aking mga Kababata” or in english “To my Fellow Youth” when he was eight years old. This poem had a strong sense of nationalism expressing Rizal’s love for our own language. He emphasized the significance and ...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.