top-rated free essay

Consciousness, the Self, and Personality Theory: a Critical Survey of

Oct 08, 1999 618 Words
Consciousness, the Self, and Personality Theory: A Critical Survey of Theories of Philosophical Arguments and Modern Psychological Personality Theories.

This paper will concern itself with some main philosophical arguments and dilemmas and how they correlate with modern psychological personality theories. This survey will include dilemmas about the mind and body, the concept of the self, and inner and outer reality. Also, it will discuss six personality theorists and their scientific and philosophical developments.

Psychology, science, and philosophy are interconnected and rooted within each other. In the book Metapsychology, the author, Sam Rakover, states that "Scientific knowledge grows and changes with time, and all three of the subsystems of science-the philosophical, the theoretical, and the experimental- are constantly developing" (Rakover 7). These developments are systematic processes. Psychology must engage in pursuit of explanation and causality. As well as how the mind interacts with the body. Gathering information, drawing conclusions and finding valid theories; as well as understanding biological and social problems, constitute psychology's philosophical background.

The concept of the self is a large factor in the study of personality as well as philosophy. The self, generally speaking, includes subjective experience and conscious awareness. In the book Philosophy of Mind the author speaks about self-consciousness, "...the possession of the concept of the self and the ability to use this concept in thinking about oneself" (Guttenplan, 213). This unique quality of human beings allows for the question of thoughts, beliefs, desires, emotions, intentions, memories; along with the responsibility of these qualities, makes us truly unique. The problem with this way of thinking is that it leads to us thinking we are more than our bodies. That a person is something more that just the physical body. Another problem with our supposed uniqueness is that we 'seem' to have a will, drive, and intention. Samuel Guttenplan continues by saying "persons are self-motivated beings with a considerable degree of autonomy over and above a material body" (Guttenplan 214). This led Renee Descartes to postulate that the only thing he couldn't doubt was his thinking existence, that there is a soul a non-material part of human beings that couldn't be denied. Since our bodies don't make decisions the self must have more than a human body. The pure ego.

David Hume had a different idea about the self in relation to experience. In a book of readings called Self and World, Hume is quoted as saying "The idea of the self as an entity that owns experiences should be replaced with the idea of the sum of those experiences themselves" (Olgilvy. 107). One can not know about oneself without experience to show it. He believed that nothing about the self could be concluded without experiential content. The identity of a person is successive perceptions. The self is not any one impression. He is quoted in the book of readings as saying "memory does not so much produce as discover personal identity, to give reason why we can thus extend our identity beyond our memory" (Olgilvy 108). He, however held the Cartesian way of thinking that mental items are the objects of thought in an interior realm. This view invites the inner observer to witness these.

Immanuel Kant, in the same book of readings expanded on Hume's ideas, he wanted a differentiation between objectivity and subjectivity attempting to prove that "...there are certain concepts whose application within experience is presupposed by the very possibility of experience" (Olgilvy 144). It is the judgments that must conform to self-consciousness. There is room within experience for the thought of experience.

John Locke's view includes a more temporal idea. The idea that "the sameness of a rational beening

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Personality Theory Analysis

    ... Personality Theory Analysis Yenisley Gonzalez PSY / 405 July 13, 2015 David Brueshoff Personality Theory Analysis Personality is what defines and makes an individual different from those around them. Personalities may vary from situation to situation, behaviors depend on the environment, and also what one finds acceptable socially in t...

    Read More
  • The Self-Consciousness

    ...Vincent DAo Prof. david ENC 1102 31 July 2014 The Self-Consciousness In the three poems “Dreams,” “Latin Women Pray,” and Mother to Son,” the authors show that all people in the world have their own struggles, and the struggles symbolize the different culture and setting. Firstly, in the poem “Latin Women Pray,” Judith Ort...

    Read More
  • Critical Analysis of Freud's Theory of Personality

    ...SUMMARY Personality is the enduring and unique cluster of characteristics that may change in response to different situations. It can be asses via different approaches such as Self-report or objective inventories, projective techniques, clinical interviews, behavioural assessment procedures and thought and experience-sampling procedures. In the...

    Read More
  • A Critical Review of Kelly’s Personality Theory in Personality Development

    ...1. Introduction Personality is a pattern of relatively permanent traits and unique characteristics that gives both consistency and individuality to a person’s behavior (Feist & Feist, 2008). For centuries, philosophers, personality theorists and other thinkers have been trying to answer: what personalities are like, how personalities are de...

    Read More
  • Cognitive Theory Of Personality

    ... Cognitive Theory of Personality George A. Kelly’s Cognitive Theory of Personality is phenomenological and focuses on the internal frame of reference of an individual. His theory is both cognitive and existential because it studies mental events and it emphasizes the future and individual’s freedom to choose. It is also humani...

    Read More
  • Six Major Tenants of Personality Theory

    ...Tenants of Personality Theory Karissa Stuart Liberty University Abstract This paper will review the six major tenants of personality theory. The first discussed are the foundations of psychology, which are: nature versus nurture, the unconscious, and view of self. Each of these foundations are important to the development of a psycho...

    Read More
  • Personality

    ...Personality Instructions: Be sure to read each question carefully and answer each part of each question completely. 1. What does it mean to say that a perspective on personality is inherently deterministic? Give an example of a perspective we discussed in class that has, at its core, a deterministic worldview. Support your assertion b...

    Read More
  • Personality Theories

    ...to review theories that have been linked and discussed in regards to personality. It aims to define personality, summarize the main ideas across different articles, pointing out the strengths and weaknesses that are in the articles. It also links my personal experience of personality traits to the theory of personality. The essay begins by defin...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.