Preview

Comparison of Willy Loman in Miller's "Death of A Salesman" and Troy Maxon in Wilson's "Fences" Compares the 2 main characters and questions whether they were good fathers.

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
630 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparison of Willy Loman in Miller's "Death of A Salesman" and Troy Maxon in Wilson's "Fences" Compares the 2 main characters and questions whether they were good fathers.
In the books Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller, and Fences by August Wilson, there are common themes that run throughout the book. Among these are two, hard working men that can be a bit disillusioned by life. The main character of each book, Willy Loman and Troy Maxson are similar in many ways. They both try hard to be good men and fathers, but unfortunately, they are imperfect in both aspects. Troy distances his self from his youngest son, and many could say that he is too hard and cold towards him. Willy in a way believes that his grown sons could not have done any wrong when they were younger and do no wrong now. But these two fathers are not totally bad. There are many good personal traits that they both display in these books. But as stated as before, they weren't perfect at all.

In many ways, both Willy and Troy were in fact good fathers. They worked hard to provide for their families and tried to set an example for their sons by their own actions. Willy was extremely supportive of Biff's high school football success and went to all the games. Troy tries to instill certain values such as responsibility into his son Cory and explains to him that he shouldn't go through life worrying if people like him or not. He tells him he takes care of him not because he likes him, but because it is his duty.

Troy seems to be a bad father more visibly. He does not encourage Cory's high school football career in anyway, in fact he tells him to tell the scout he is not interested and thinks having a job is more important. His attitude toward Cory the majority of the time is cold and harsh, as if he regards his son as someone he must deal with and take care of.

Willy had a few problems of his own. First he let himself get caught with his mistress by his son, which devastated him. He also acted like his sons were perfect, which they weren't. He should have made sure his son passed math so he could have graduated, but he put that into the hands of their next-door

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Troy does not want to accept the changes in the world because that would cause him to accept the death of his own dreams.…

    • 978 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The film Death of a Salesman and the play Fences both contain similar themes and plot. Even though both are very similar, there are glaring different in their stories. The film Death of a salesman is about a man name Willy Loman who is struggling in making a living with his current job as a salesman. He has a loving a wife name Linda and two adult sons, Biff and Happy. Willy share and unstable relationship both his son (primary Happy) as he believe they are not making the most out of themselves. In the play Fences, tell the story of a garbage man name Troy Maxson. Like Willy, Troy as a loving wife (Rose) and two sons (Cory and Lyon). In both story, father figure is shown to have cheated on their wives and argued with one of their sons to the…

    • 405 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    At the end of A Death of A Salesmen Biff has basically lost all connection to his father just as Cory had with Troy. Both Willy and Troy also have affairs with other women, which eventually distances them from the rest of the family. We see how both characters essentially treat their family members as though they are servants, Willy tells his wife not to speak when he is multiple times throughout the play. Similarly, Troy aims to dictate every decision that his children make. Both characters wives have basically given up on their marriage and husband, in Fences Roses even states that “you [Troy] a womanless man.” At the end of the story the two characters Troy and Willy are dead and have lost all connect to their family. This lack of connect is even present in both characters’ funerals. At Willy’s funeral Biff continues to be insensitive towards his father stating that, “he never knew who he was.” Similarly, Cory is insensitive towards his father saying that he doesn’t even want to go to the…

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Troy is one of the main character in the play Fences by August Wilson. He is the provider for the family, a fatherly figure, a husband, and a hard worker among other things. However he is also a cheat, a womanizer, a strict man, an unloving father and an unreasonable man. The question is despite the characters pros and cons, how is he a hero, especially a tragic one. The play is sad in a sense that there is a sad past, sad present and perhaps a sad future. Troy was unable to play for major leagues because at first he was not allowed to play because of his color and then his age became an issue. Troy’s inability to play baseball because his lifelong regret which he imposed on his son Cory and did not allow him to play college football. He was harsh on his son, however he had good intentions. Troy had a loving wife and he loved her but then again he cheated on her with is affair with Alberta. Troy plays an unsympathetic role for much of the play because of the emotional boundary he builds to keep his family from interacting with his softer side, and we see this as the metaphoric sense, The Fence. We can see this when Cory asks Troy “why don’t you like me?” and Troy’s response is rather unorthodox because instead of reassuring his son, he informs Cory, that he is just doing what a father is supposed to do. That Troy is just fulfilling his duties as a parent and nothing more. Troy is a prime example of a tragic hero. He starts the play where is he is admired and loved and he successfully gets away with his secret affair, however eventually, Troy dies and leaves many negative attributes which in return are inherited by his family. So the question remains, is Troy really a hero after all?…

    • 1312 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fences Research Paper

    • 1268 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the play "Fences" by August Wilson, Troy Maxson can be characterized as a responsible, fearless, unfaithful husband and a controlling father. Troy has acted insensitive and uncaring to his wife, Rose, his brother, Gabriel and his son, Cory. Troy can be seen as a man with both positive qualities and flaws. Even though Troy definitely has some good qualities but a lot of what he does is bad.…

    • 1268 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This inability to change diversely affects Troy's relationship with his second son, Cory, who is a promising athlete. Sports provide the arena for the continuing conflict and foreshadows the characteristic that will eventually lead to Troy's downfall. There is a constant struggle between Troy and Cory because Troy will not allow his son to pursue his athletic dreams, telling him instead to keep his after-school job. This comes from Troy's past, when he was a promising baseball player who was prevented from playing because he was black. Troy's fears carry into the new generation when he prevents his son from pursuing a football scholarship because of his past, even though the world was changing at this time, and colored people were expanding into new areas. Troy admits to Rose that his decision regarding Cory's future comes from his past…

    • 1968 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many people go through life without a purpose or doing a job they hate. In Arthur Miller’s, Death of a Salesman, Willy Loman thinks this isn’t the case for him. He is working the best job in the world, being a salesman, like his hero Dave Singleman. Dave Singleman still sells from his bed and Willy admirably thinks this is because he loves it. The real reason is because Dave never made enough to retire. However, Willy doesn’t know he is gravely mistaken and has failed to realize who he really is. This has caused him to instill these mistaken qualities in his sons, Biff and Happy. Willy’s lack of a father figure plays into his flaws such as obsession with money and hubris. He has had some virtues as well like putting his family first and working…

    • 1407 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In most of his flashbacks, Willy describes them both as “liked, but not well liked”, inferring to his sons that they will not make it far due to the lack of popularity. Present day, Willy relies on Charley for his money every week. This samples Willy’s pride. During a game of cards, Willy is offered a job working for Charley. He is immediately offended, with a sense of jealousy for his success. Changing the subject, Willy gloats about putting up his own ceiling, which he claims every man should know how to do, even though he knows Charley does not. He tries to gain his lost pride back by finding a weakness of his friend. Like his father, Bernard’s success makes Willy’s dignity falter. When Bernard is asked for advice and the reasoning to why Biff never attended summer school, it shows how desperate he is for guidance. However, when he asks Bernard if it was him who caused this dismay, Willy is irritated at Bernard putting blame on him. He sees it as though his pride is deteriorating by the…

    • 661 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Willy started out as a lower middle-class workingman, and in the end, he ended up that same way. He believed wholeheartedly in the American dream of success and wealth, but he never achieved it. Neither one of his sons fulfilled his hope and dream that they would succeed where he had failed miserably. When his illusions of himself began to fail under the pressing reality of his actual conditions, Willy's mental health began to fall apart. The mental struggle with himself proved to be too much and…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Willy Tragic Hero

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Many would argue with this claim, saying, “ Willy is not a good father… and… is unable to admit his faults because he has too much pride.” This quote is trying to saying that willy shouldn’t be considered a tragic hero since he is not a good father which is due to his excessive pride but, excessive pride is the very definition of Hubris, which is a very important trait required of a tragic hero. Furthermore,in the play, Willy has flashbacks of the past. This is shown in the following quote, “ Willy:You mean to say Bernard wouldn’t give you the answers? Biff: ...but i only got you a sixty one... Willy:And they won’t give you four points? Biff:... would you talk to him… Willy:... your on. We’ll drive right back.” This flashback to this specific point means that willy regrets telling his son to cheat and only wants the best for his son. This goes back to Miller's essay, we should judge Willy’s intentions and not what he did, which proves that he is a tragic hero.…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    |Willy Loman from Death of A Salesman and Joe Keller from All My Sons, have similarities in their courses of action which prove detrimental to |…

    • 399 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The characterisation of Willy is but one of Miller’s strengths in the play, for he cleverly uses time to show how Willy’s mind has been manipulated by the stress of his failings. Willy experiences flashbacks which his mind perhaps uses in order to protect him from the harsh truth of his present life. Willy’s two sons, Biff and Happy are fully grown, with Biff having turned sour towards his father and rejected the vision his father had for him. Still, Willy in his vulnerable state transports himself back to the time when Biff was a young, promising high school athlete who idolised his father and his ideals. Instead of encouraging academic achievement, Willy ensures his sons that if they are ‘liked’ they will ‘never want’. Sadly for both Willy and Biff, this was a delusion which saw Biff become the very…

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Willy Loman is the main character in Miller’s, Death of Salesman. Throughout the play, he struggles with his work ethic and well-being. In the story, Willy Loman is a sales man that is unable to accept him and society. In his older years gets fired from his job. His son is unable to receive a loan from the bank to start his own business. Willy affected by guilt kills himself, that way his son Biff is then able to collect his insurance money and become an entrepreneur. Willy does have flaws in his character that make him partially responsible for his own misfortune. Willy’s ultimate down fall is a result of social pressure, family and friend influences, and his psychological and emotional state of mind.…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Obiturary

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Willy wasn't a great father but he tried to do what he can but that didn't help because his sons and him weren't successful in life.Willy's was suffering from fear of abandonment which has a huge impact in his adult life.Willy was getting flash backs about his older brother Ben and he didn't want him to leave.Ben was the successful one and Willy needed to ask about how was his father like he needed advice about how to be a father.Willy committed suicide by crashing himself.Linda Willy's wife couldn't understand why all of Willy’s friends and…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    A person’s outcome in life is often a reflection of their childhood, or how they grew up. The different ways a child is treated by their parents may later affect the amount of grit he or she has, therefore affecting their later success in life. In the book Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller, Biff, Happy and Bernard each grew up in different ways. Although Biff and Happy grew up in the same home, their father, Willy Loman, treated the boys differently, and therefore their views on life as adults turned out slightly dissimilar. Willy and Charley’s relationships with their sons contradict each other and therefore affected their son’s future successes in different ways.…

    • 1296 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays