top-rated free essay

Comparison of Siddhartha to What the Buddha Taught

By akira_renamae Apr 03, 2014 741 Words

Sound in Siddhartha Compared to Absence in “What the Buddha Taught” It seems that important motifs in several works of literature consist of something very tangible. The repeated symbol has to be very potent, something one can see or touch—or even a very strong, particular smell. The idea or thing that is so important is made obvious in an especially physical way. This is what makes pieces of literature about how to obtain the good life from an Eastern perspective so fascinating. Repeated ideas in these tales are far more subtle. Though Siddhartha and the Buddha reach Enlightenment through different journeys (since wisdom must be discovered within), Siddhartha and “What the Buddha Taught” are more easily compared than contrasted because they possess less obvious ideas and motifs. “What the Buddha Taught” may considered as transcending tangibility and physicality in its ideas due to its overarching focus on absence. Buddha’s teachings enforce that allowing oneself to experience extremes throughout life is to allow suffering and the avoidance of Nirvana. Both hedonism (or “the indulgence in the sense pleasures”) and self mortification are considered “painful and unprofitable”, though in different ways. Thus, the Buddha teaches the middle path, the Cessation of Suffering. The importance of absence from worldly attachments, from extremes, from tangibility is underlined by its reward: Nirvana, a sweet, peaceful emptiness. This text, over and over, associates the absence, the cessation, the lack, and the emptiness with desirability. Meanwhile, attachment, ordinariness, greed and hedonism are to be avoided. This is all to achieve, again, a lack of existence, to refrain from “re-becoming” in the cycle of reincarnation. In the journey of Siddhartha, another subtle idea repeats itself frequently: the importance of sound. Though more tangible than the teaching of abstaining from sense pleasure, sound is overlooked since its significance is more difficult to suggest over silent text. Different sounds help to categorize the separate phases of his life. We first see this in play during Siddhartha’s expedition and education with the samanas. In the context of sound, he primarily learns silence through his physical exercises. In an effort to acquire how to eliminate desire, Siddhartha does everything with an absence of sound: “Siddhartha stood silent in the vertical blaze of the sun…He stood silent in the rainy season…Silently he crouched…” However, the use of silence does not help him eliminate his desire for knowledge, and, dissatisfied, he moves on. His encounter with the Buddha also highly emphasizes silence, as the Illuminated One walks silently, possesses a “silent face…a calm, silent, hidden smile…silently lowered gaze…” and more. Referring back to “What the Buddha Taught”, here we may perceive that in the context of his teachings, the absence of sound is associated with his unbreakable inner peace. Once again Siddhartha finds that someone else’s teachings could not bring him to Enlightenment, so he moves in the complete direction: toward hedonism. His attempt at the lifestyle of common people may again be represented by sound. Upon entering a village a residing here, the emphasis on silence is lost and instead there is noise, including “loud laughter”, yelling (usually from Kamaswami), and “scolding and insulting”. This change in sound represents the extreme change from one phase of his life to the next: he gives up his life of refrain to experience worldly matters. He trades silence for noise. Living in such a shallow eventually rots his soul and, with desperation, he moves on to the next phase of his life: living as a simple ferryman with Vasudeva. This final phase of his life also possesses sound, but not the convoluted noises of the city; rather, he learns to listen to the pure wisdom of the river. His Enlightenment is facilitated by learning to listen fully and completely to the all voices of the river, which all fuse to form the final, most important sound of Siddhartha’s tale: the om. These texts are similar in that finding the good life involves abstaining from the extremes of worldly matters. However, while Buddha’s teachings suggest that finding Enlightenment can be done through absence and living a particular way, Siddhartha finds Enlightenment by listening to this grand, wise river. Perhaps this demonstrates that we may all achieve Enlightenment through different methods.

Works Cited
Hesse, Hermann. Siddhartha. New York. Penguin Classics. Print. 1920. Wahula, Rapola. “What the Buddha Taught: Setting in Motion the Wheel of Truth.” New York.
Grove Press. Print. 1974.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Siddhartha And Historical Buddha Comparison

    ...The author, Hermann Hesse, narrates the book Siddhartha about a son of a Brahmin who struggles to find the void missing in his life, enlightenment, which is the belief in one’s own power or knowledge for human reasoning through religion, politics, and education. This is important to Siddhartha because he wants to gain happiness, peace, and sat...

    Read More
  • Buddha & Siddhartha

    ...Buddhism: Major global "religion" with complex system of beliefs. -The Four Noble Truths -The Noble Eightfold Path -Karma- if you live a good life, good things will happen to you and vise versa. -Cycle of Rebirth Siddhartha Gautama: -Founder of Buddhism - Lived 566 (?) - 480 (?) B.C.E. - Son of Indian warrior/king -Privileged b...

    Read More
  • Siddhartha and The Alchemist comparison essay

    ...of life one becomes wiser. In the novel, Siddhartha and The Alchemist the protagonist Siddhartha and Santiago both go through man different stages in life which made them grow, learn and transform into wiser people. Both protagonists go on a journey which is eventually the same but the purpose of journey is different. Similarly, both protagon...

    Read More
  • Siddhartha

    ...experiences, and through their memories. In the novel, Siddhartha by Hermann Hesse, Siddhartha goes through a number of different experiences as well as searching high and low to find the meaning of his existence, the meaning of life, and the meaning of communication. Throughout the novel, Siddhartha encounters a lot of trials and tempt...

    Read More
  • Gautama Buddha and Siddhartha Study Guide

    ... Siddhartha Study Guide Questions 1. Why is Siddhartha unhappy? Why is his spirit like a “waiting vessel”? A- Because he needs to find an answer to his questions. And the waiting vessel is because it just sits there not doing anything. 2. Why is Govinda willing to follow him? A- Because...

    Read More
  • Buddha: Buddhism and Siddhartha

    ...Buddha The word Buddha means "enlightened one." It is used today as a title to the one who has given us more religious beliefs than almost any other human who lived in this world. However, he was not given this name at birth; he had to earn it for himself by undergoing long, hard hours of meditation and contemplation. Buddha has changed th...

    Read More
  • In Siddhartha

    ...Lana Walker David Gillette English 18 April 2014m Finding Enlightenment In Siddhartha, by Herman Hesse, a young boy named Siddhartha leaves home in order to pursue Nirvana. Siddhartha’s understanding of Nirvana is that it is the highest enlightenment, when one frees oneself from the cycle of Samsara. Siddhartha searches for teachers that wi...

    Read More
  • Comparing Buddha And Siddhartha Gautama

    ...The depictions of Buddha/Siddhartha Gautama have various depictions, postures and gestures in the regions of India and Southeastern Asia due to the different cultural and architectural influences of other civilizations over time. With every posture depicted of Buddah each contains a different hand gestures which are known as the Mudras. The seat...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.