Two stories written by two different writers can share similar but very different aspects of life. Sherman alexie wrote the story What It Means To Say Phoenix, Arizona which was about two natives on a road trip to retrieve one of their fathers ashes and bonded during the trip. Louse Erdrich also wrote a story about two natives who took a road trip to bond named The Red Convertible.
In both stories two natives lived on a preservation as kids. A key difference in stories was that Victor who was the main character from This Is What It Means To Say Phoenix, Arizona was broke along with most individuals on his reservation. So when the time came for him to have to retrieve his father he was unable to do so alone. The two characters from The Red Convertible Were not tied down as much due to financial instability. They shared a red Oldsmobile together and took trips for fun instead of turmoil induced reasons.
Now in both stories the boys took trips and bonded through experiences. Victor and Thomas are sort of forced to bond due to the situation. Thomas lent Victor the money to head to Arizona only if he was able to go. When they were kids they used to hang out a lot until Thomas and Victor got into a fist fight and drifted from there. Throughout the trip the boy share stories and open up to one and other they become friends. In the other story The Red Convertible two siblings also take a road trip not out for turmoil based reasons but because they enjoyed each other’s company. In both stories the boys bonded but both had two very different endings.
The Red Convertible ended with one of the brothers drowning in a way that makes the reader think to whether or not it was suicide because his life sucked and he didn’t have the balls to shoot up a school or an accident because the character was struggling with past events that he couldn’t overcome. In What It Means To Say Phoenix, Arizona the story ended with Victor telling Thomas that he did enjoy his company but things were going to go back to the way they were before and they wouldn’t Speak.
These stories were very similar in the way that both writers took individuals off a reservation and bonded them through a road trip. Two distinct differences in these stories were in one a main character dies at the end and another is simply let go due to pettiness of not wanting to be associated with. Though these authors might not have known each other there stories were quite close and showed different aspects of life on a preservation.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Another example that both stories are similar is that in the story, "Emancipation A Life Fable" is the animal in the story want to escape the cage to see what is beyond he closed door. Every time he tries to exit the door he…
- 494 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The setting in both short stories compare in the time era. In the story "Love in L.A." the era was not mentioned, but Jake was driving a 1958 Buick. That being the only clue to what the time period this is taking place, one can only assume. In the "Red Convertible" Henry was drafted into Vietnam. This means the time period was 1970. Both stories are close to being the same time. The differences in the setting are in location. "The Red Convertible" takes place on an Indian reservation in the Idaho/…
- 548 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
It is also structured in a way that shows where these experiences differed and how those differences affected them differently. The book is broken up into three parts: Fathers and Angles, Choices and Second Chances, and Paths Taken and Expectations Fulfilled. Each part focuses on a different time in the men’s lives. The first part, Fathers and Angles, focuses on their childhood and the challenges that they had to overcome. Both men had similar childhoods, yet they were taught how to process them differently. As Wes said, “I was taught to remember, but never question. Wes was taught to forget, and never ask why” (4). The second part, Choices and Second Chances, is about a time period after childhood, but before either of them really became a man. They were too young to realize the outcome of some mistakes, but too old to go without punishment for them. Finally, the book focuses on where the two men ended up. This happens in the third part,, Paths Taken and Expectations…
- 589 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In The Red Convertible Louise Erdrich uses the foreshadowing and the symbolism of boots and water to show the death of Stephan and the car as a symbol of the loss of a lifelong brotherhood in the last 40 lines.…
- 667 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
When they arrive Victor learns that his dad didn’t want to leave and that he did it for the family. Victor takes this to heart but is still mad at his dad and feels pain and wants other people to feel the same. On their way back to the reservation, Victor and Thomas have a wreck with cars that had already crashed. There is a girl that is hurt badly and a drunk man is yelling. She is going to die but Victor has flash backs and rises to the occasion. He runs Twenty miles to the nearest hospital and as he is running he blacks out. This conflict is…
- 453 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In both short stories the main characters are of the opposite sex, which changes the viewpoint of both stories. Connie, at fifteen years old, is sexually active and…
- 1242 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
In my life there was this man who tried to be my father but never succeeded and this man is my actual father but I do admire him for not giving up hope in being my father to this day even though I've all but given up on him. The first reason of contrast between the stories…
- 1398 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
The Blue Hotel had a relationship with a father and a son, even though this relationship had some flaws the relationship between a father and a son is like no other. In Tennessee's Partner, there was a strong relationship between the two friends that lasted even when the other half was on his deathbed. Both stories have huge plot lines, a very important part of a story. The main plot point of Tennessee's Partner was when his friend was not able to bail his friend out with the money that he had brought as a bribe since this did not work shortly after his friend was sentenced to death. The main plot point in The Blue Hotel was when the first fight happened then following the second fight.…
- 682 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In two stories “Young Man’s Folly”, written by Susan Michalicka and “Flight”, written by Doris Lessing, there are a lot of similarities. In “Young Man’s Folly”, the author tells a story about a boy and his mother, that by boy’s foolishness of his father are left alone. The boy is not very happy, so he blames his mom that he doesn’t have his father anymore. However, at the end the boy realizes that his mom’s the one that truly loves him. One the other hand, in the story “Flight”, the writer is telling a story about and old man who’s not able to let go to his granddaughter, as in the past he had a similar situation with his daughter. At the end he’d understood what love is all about. The main idea of these two stories is change in main characters, and how as the time passes they realize what’s right.…
- 442 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The story ends with a tragedy, when Corrigan drives back from the court with Jazzlyn, they have an accident. Jazzlyn is killed instantly, while Corrigan dies on the way to the hospital, leaving Carian, Adelita and the readers to grieve.…
- 945 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
There’s death in both of them also. Not essentially the same as the main character is the people that had died had importance in the stories. In “A Horseman in the Sky” Carter had shot the spy on the top of the cliff which happened to be his father. As for the “Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge” the main character was killed, although he had imagine of a great escape it was futile and ending up dying without seeing his family again. The death in the stories corresponds with the next similarity which is war destroys. War destroys families and tears them apart where Carter told his father that we was going to fight for the other side and his father told him “Well, go, sir, and whatever may occur do what you conceive to be your duty” (2). Although the similarities are enjoyable to hear there is one story out of the two that has stronger feelings. Which is “A Horseman in the Sky”, needless to say “Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge” doesn’t, but “A Horseman in the Sky seems to stand out…
- 676 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The stories “Tommy” and “The Night of Oranges” are about love and relationships. However, in both stories the characters have a different relationship. In “Tommy” the relationship between the characters are a boy and a girl love. When Tommy was eight years old, he expresses his feelings toward Winter by tapping his shoes to make the sound “I love you” (Winter 27). In “The Night of Oranges” the relationship between the characters are fraternal. Stan shows his love for his brother by buying oranges for him as a gift for Christmas. When Stan hears that there were oranges that are selling at the market he thought he wanted to do something important and give his brother a big surprise (Stan 31). The characters in both stories are very loving towards their loved ones and would do anything to make them…
- 258 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Epilogue – Write an epilogue (a concluding part added to a literary work) in which you explain – using whatever tense and tone the author did – what happened to the character(s) next.…
- 568 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Both narratives used relationships to play a great part, relationships such as friendships, family and love.…
- 1418 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
For example, one strength of the conclusion was that even though Joey almost dies from sickness, Morpurgo lets him live in the end. The author lets Albert ride Joey back home and then there is a happy ending after the war. So the ending of the story is about hope and love by the characters.…
- 268 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays