Comparing Two Poems

Topics: Poetry, Aesthetics, Human physical appearance Pages: 3 (1065 words) Published: April 12, 2006
For this assignment I have decided to work on two poems. The first one being ‘There is a garden in her face by Thomas Campion and the second ‘She walks in beauty' by George Gordon and Lord Byron. I will be deconstructing both poems and commenting on them with reference to the techniques used by the author when writing them.

The first poem by Campion has a Sesta Rima form, meaning a six line stanza composed of a quatrain and a couplet and rhymed a-b-a-b-c-c. It is clearly a love poem. One, where the author writes about a woman and convinces us that the woman is perfect. The author describes the woman's beautiful features, which according to him is full of perfection. However despite the fact that the poems revolves around physical, outward appearance, it focuses more specifically on the woman's facial beauty.

It is probable that the author is in love with the woman which he describes in the poem. However, it is important to note that if he thinks he loves the woman then his love is artificial because from the poem it seems that he is only in love with the woman's outward appearance and not really what she is inside or as a person.

The author describes the woman's beauty with reference to elements of nature like flowers, fruits and pearl. So basically what he is doing is comparing her beauty to nature. Since nature is pure then the woman's beauty is also natural and pure.

This poem uses metaphor to bring the combination between the woman's beauty and nature. The title of the poems and the first verse in the poem illustrates how this is done. ‘There is a garden in her face'

Similes like ‘her brows like bended bows do stand' are also used in the poem to show us how the author makes a comparison between two clearly different things, in that case the woman's brows and bended bows. To him the two looks similar.

The second poem by George Gordon and Lord Byron ‘she walks in beauty' is a lyric poem written in iambic tetrameter form and similar to the...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Essay Comparing Two Poems

    ...H/W Monday, 27 September 2010 Compare the similarities and differences between two Ballads, Charlotte Dymond and John Lomas. Charlotte Dymond and John Lomas, are two poems which share several techniques. They also, however are different in many ways. This essay will explore their similarities and their differences and explain reasons why the two ballads are different or similar. For example, both poems have a theme of murder. Ballads normally have a sad or shocking story, so this is very common. In both poems the murderer is always hanged after murdering another person. In Charlotte Dymond, the murderer is her lover. In John Lomas, the murderer is John Lomas. The murder controls the ballads and there is no point in the ballads which are happy, this means that the ballads can be quite depressing because they are so sad. John Lomas is quite sad because the murderer John Lomas is telling the story with a great amount of regret. In both poems a razor is used to kill the victim. Razors come out of a small wooden holder, so it would be easy to hide at your wrist, or like in Charlotte Dymond, Matthew had the razor ‘waiting at his wrist’. A difference between the two poems would be; in Charlotte Dymond the writer uses a range of different languages. For example, similes are used a lot, like in stanza fourteen there are two...

    Read More
    1123 Words 5 Pages
  • Comparing two poems Research Paper

    ...To write a comparative poem between two poems Limbo and Caged Bird are two very similar poems. They are mainly about one matter-freedom of captivity. Freedom is what the poems characters desire and hope to have. Freedom is their need and wants to be joyful and happy. I have picked these two poems, which link in many different ways, because they have interesting descriptions of the scene and tell us what the atmosphere is like. Furthermore, the authors, Braithwaite and Maya Angelou have used different techniques to portray feelings and show the events occurring. Limbo has a main character who is explaining her thoughts throughout the poem. ‘Silence in front of me’ creates a picture of her standing with the simplicity of the surroundings. In addition, it is suggesting how dreadful it is to be alone on the ‘long dark deck’. These three words create the setting in a sorrowful way, which also has impact on the reader, suggesting that she has no company and the days are tirelessly long. As a result, her surroundings are dark and dreary. Caged Bird relates to limbo in having a main character that is described throughout. ‘The caged bird sings’ shows us what the bird loves and longs to do all the time. In addition, Maya Angelou explains how the caged bird is alone and has nothing apart from singing and keeping itself entertained whilst going through the...

    Read More
    1326 Words 6 Pages
  • Comparing Poems Essay

    ...Todd Taravella 11/2/11 Mr. Olson Eng D29: Craft of Language Love is Vast It is amazing how poems can be so different yet so similar. When talking about a thing like love, it becomes less difficult to understand knowing how complicated the subject is. “Love” by Eavan Boland talks about how Eavan and her husband had been through some turbulent times. They veered apart in their love that used to be so intense and Eavan about how much she misses that. How much that man, her husband, meant to Eavan. In the song “Photograph” by the band Nickelback it is also a sense of longing. The main character in the song (singer Chad Kroeger) reminisces about the good old days in his hometown in Canada. As Kroeger sings you feel the raw emotion towards the town and everything within it. The love is so intense and he longs for it so badly. By analyzing “Love” by Eavan Boland and “Photograph” by Nickelback it becomes easier to realize that… [While the 2 poems can be quite different in tone, rhyme scheme, style, and other poetic devices, the author’s raw emotion is so similar despite this.] The rhyme schemes are not very similar when talking about “Love” and “Photograph”. Boland uses about 10 syllables per line but there is really no structured rhyme scheme. There is definitely a flow when Boland says something like “I am your wife. It was years ago. Our child was healed. We love each other still” (Boland 210). If someone had to classify it...

    Read More
    1083 Words 3 Pages
  • Poetry Essay Comparing Two Love Poems

    ...becomes really interesting to see their true meanings. Love poems are challenging to figure out if they truly are love poems, and once I figured out how they were, it was neat to see the true meaning of that poem. The poems “My Mistress’ Eyes Are Nothing Like the Sun” and “Shall I Compare thee to a summer’s day?” by William Shakespeare have a common theme but are very different in their approaches. The first thing that I noticed with these two poems was that they are both sonnets, they both have fourteen lines and a strict rhyming pattern. Also, they are both love stories talking about their love for someone, and both are referring to the beauty of the ones whom they love. Another thing that both of these poems do is refer to the “beauty” of the women that they love although they do it in two different ways. I also noticed they were both written by William Shakespeare and that he created these love poems in two very different ways. The differences in these poems is that “Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day?” is more about beauty and not so much his love, although I know he loves her because of what he says. He professes his love for her in this sonnet by making her beauty timeless, and it’s a more “traditional” love poem. Also it’s more about time and making her beauty “immortal” whereas “My...

    Read More
    525 Words 3 Pages
  • Comparing poems Essay

    ...www.engishbiz.co.uk  2003 Steve Campsall How to Read a Poem Poems can sometimes be difficult to get to grips with. But remember that the poet has tried hard to say much using few words. Part of the enjoyment of a poem is the work needed to engage with it and find out what the poet is saying. Don’t always expect to be able to ‘translate’ a poem – many poems have ‘meanings’ that are hard to define precisely, but which still seem to strike a powerful chord in our consciousness. Remember that poets try hard to “make it new” – to allow their reader to appreciate in a different way some aspect of life that might have previously been taken for granted. Certainly, poems are unique in their ability to say much more than is printed on the page. Here is a list of questions that could be applied to any poem. Answer them for your poem(s). Your answers will help you build up an idea of how and why the poem works. 1. Look up any unfamiliar words and work out what the poem is about Write this down in a couple of sentences. 2. Work out the correct “voice” with which to read the poem. Work out and describe the kind of person who is ‘telling’ the poem. 3. What is this speaker’s tone of voice? Does it change? What tells you this? 4. Which words have indirect, associated, unusual or...

    Read More
    372 Words 2 Pages
  • Essay about Comparing Poems

    ...Time” are two very similar poems that demand comparison, as Davis’ poem is in reply to Thomas’. From a reader’s point of view, these two poems seem to have a great deal of comparison than being dissimilar. Through an in depth analysis of these particular poems, “Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night” and “After a Time” have been proven to have high similarity points in the many different aspects of poetry, such as theme, thought process and structure. At first glance, both poems seem to be read as a death related piece of writing. Though, this is where the contrast part comes in. In Thomas’ poem, he tells the reader about resisting death as best as you can and sees death as something we can overcome or try to avoid with all of our might and strength. He says if we can “Rage, rage against the dying of the light (Thomas 3),” then we can lead ourselves away from death. He then goes saying that death is the worst thing that could happen to anyone and if we can shy away from it as much as possible, it’ll be for the best. In Davis’ poem “After a Time,” she explains to the reader, if death is upon you, you should accept it and let it take you away. She explains in her poem that “we go stripped at last the way we came (Davis 3),” as in, we leave this world the same as we came into it. Though Davis has different views on how we should deal...

    Read More
    991 Words 4 Pages
  • Comparing Poems Essay

    ...“Comparing Poems & Short Story’s” Comparing short stories with poems can be an interesting way to learn literature. Things to look for are similarities in themes, the events that take place, the meaning of the poetry, and similar emotions or outcomes from what was read. The three pieces of literary work that will be discussed and compared are Kate Chopin’s “The Story of an Hour”, Sherman Alexie’s “Grief Calls us to the Things of This World”, and Alfred Lord Tennyson “In Memoriam”. The point of this paper is to compare three literary works from our reading, after reading this essay you will have a clear understanding of three different literary works and how they are similar. The first literary work that will be discussed is Kate Chopin’s “The Story of an Hour” is a short yet multifaceted piece describing the thoughts of Mrs. Mallard. The Story is abundant with symbolism and imagery. The theme of this piece was difficult to find at first, the reader could have thought it was about love, grief, or a yearning for freedom. The most well-known theme here is the yearning for freedom. Chopin focuses on unfolding the emotional state of Mrs. Mallard, which can be separated into three stages; grief, a sense of newfound, and finally into despair of the loss of that freedom. The Story of an Hour was written in the nineteenth Century. During this particular time highly restrictive gender roles forbade women to live as...

    Read More
    1652 Words 5 Pages
  • Poem Comparing Essay

    ...Good evening Mr. Georges and fellow classmates, I have researched about 2 poems and made a comparison between the two. I’m here today to talk to you about them and see what you think at the end of the speech. The two poems I researched were (on the sea, author John Keats) and (sea fever, author John Masefield). as you can see from the title of the poems that they are bot about the sea but don’t be confused, they’re both completely different stories. Both of these poems talk about the sea, they are both referring to the sea as a human and identifying it in a human characteristic kind of way. As we can see along the sonnet (on the sea), the author uses terms as uproar rude, mighty swell, caverns, and vexed, desolate shores. He also mentions The Greco-Roman goddess Hecate associated with magic and the wild. This is referring to the sea and how ruthless it can be. This poem deals with nature, focusing on its wild and violent side. This poem also reflects on human actions. The poem is comparing the nature with the human being, because we can also get wild and violent. It seems a criticism of the alienation of the human being -above all when living and working in big cities. So the author may be calling our attention – the speaker of the poem addresses to us (Oh ye!) -And giving us a piece of advice- not to underestimate...

    Read More
    853 Words 4 Pages

Popular Essays

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free