Preview

Comparing The Interaction Between The Mentally Ill And The Criminal Justice System

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
813 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparing The Interaction Between The Mentally Ill And The Criminal Justice System
Perhaps the most complicated consequence of the interaction between the mentally ill and the criminal justice system is the reality of incarceration. Unfortunately, it is too often the case where a person with schizophrenia is convicted of a crime and incarcerated, but as a result of their mental illness negatively impacting their trial. This was the case of Theodore Kaczynski, a man diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia and accused of sending bombs through the mail. Kaczynski “continued to tell the judge and his lawyers that he did not want to be labeled mentally ill” and thus his lawyer could not use a defense of mental illness (Reisner et al, 87). Subsequently, Kaczynski was sentenced to life without parole. This case exemplifies how the …show more content…
In this respect, the rights of those dealing with mental illnesses, specifically schizophrenia, can be under major scrutiny. The balance between protecting the civil liberties of individuals while maintaining the wellbeing of society as a whole becomes distorted when the issue of schizophrenia is factored into the equation. A large part of this lack of clarity can be attributed to the ignorance surrounding the disease itself. In society, “schizophrenia is one of the most serious and frightening of all mental illnesses. No other disorder arouses as much anxiety in the general public, the media, and doctors” (Picchioni & Murray, 91). The struggle for schizophrenic patients does not stop at their symptoms, but expands to the entire community because they are misunderstood and underrepresented. Schizophrenia remains one of the most difficult diseases to diagnose and treat. As a result, those left undiagnosed or left without treatment may be arrested simply for behaviors due to the illness itself. This occurrence is extremely detrimental to schizophrenics, as jail is not a proper place for treatment. Perhaps if the public were more informed of the treatments available to the mentally ill as well as the myths encompassing these individuals, then the stigma of schizophrenia might disappear. Accomplishing this feat would not be easy, as the relatively little known about schizophrenia is under contention. However, the mass of society does not need to know the role of genetics and environment in causing the disease, but rather its treatments, manifestations, and outlooks. Only with combination of understanding and knowledge can humanity begin to bridge this gap between the rights of schizophrenic patients and the safety of the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In this article, the incarceration of the mentally ill is encouraged because it is safer than keeping them in mental institutions. It claims that mental institutions are extremely dangerous by their very nature and the nurses there are trained to treat the mentally ill, not to keep them from hurting themselves or other people. In prisons however, the guards are equipped with the experience of a 16 week training program and are able to handle any commotion that might be made without endangering the lives of the prisoners or the public. This viewpoint is contrary to that in Pete Earley’s book because it endorses the imprisonment of the mentally ill, while in contrast Earley strongly believes the mentally ill need treatment, not imprisonment.…

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    Sentencing Persons with a Mental Condition. (2013, July 12). Retrieved May 4, 2013 from http://njca.anu.edu.au/Projects/Cth%20Sen%20DB/Principles%20and%20Practice%20component/mental_illness_sentencing_factors.htm…

    • 3560 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mental Health, Crime and Criminal Justice (Winstone, 2016) is a refreshingly candid look at the challenges related to persons with mental illness(es). Through multiple perspectives, the book sheds light on the often overlooked and behind the scene issues that arise when mentally ill individuals commit crime. The book goes beyond the obvious problems individuals with mental illness face by delving into more obscure but important issues, thus giving the reader a deeper understanding of the material covered in each chapter. Every chapter contributes unique insight to the underlying theme of the book in such a way to indirectly prompt the reader to critically think about the relationship between mental health, crime and criminal justice.…

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Shannon, B. D., & Bensen, D. H. (2008). Texas Criminal Procedure, and The Offender With Mental Illness. Austin: National Alliance on Mental Illness.…

    • 3278 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Corrections Final Paper

    • 4805 Words
    • 20 Pages

    Severe, persistent and untreated mental illness is running rampant in prison populations in the United States. Mental Health is defined as psychological wellbeing and satisfactory adjustment to society and to the ordinary demands of life” (Dictionary. Com, N.D). In contrast, a “mental illness” is a disorder of psychological well-being which impairs one’s ability to function satisfactorily in society and “often results in a diminished capacity for coping with the ordinary demands of life” (National Alliance on Mental Illness, N.D.). A 2002 study found that severe and persistent mental illness is present in prison populations in the U.S. at a rate twice that of all U.S. mental hospitals combined (Danesh & Fazel, 1989); with antisocial personality disorder at a “ten-fold excess” (Danesh and Fazel, 1989. p.548). If Antisocial Personality disorder is, as Dr. Sherry Whatley a veteran therapist at the Giddings State School, a juvenile corrections institution for capital offenders in central Texas suggests, the hallmark of criminality (Hubner, 2005. p.58), then there is a correlation between the experience of incarceration and the prevalence of mental illness (Danesh & Fazel, 1989; Brandt, 2012. p. 552-553).…

    • 4805 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    While it is important to understand the differences in today’s institution compared to their predecessors; it is also critical to take heed of lessons learned. Throughout history mankind has been challenged by how to treat members of society who are different whether these differences are based on physical or mental attributes. As for mental illness, we have entered into an age of new beginnings where the negative aspects of these places are being forgotten and images of safety and happiness for these patients are being…

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Insanity Defense

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Despite public notions about the use of the insanity defense in criminal trials by defendants as a method of reducing their punishments, the reality is that the defense is rarely invoked, difficult to feign, and when proven, often leads to longer incarcerations than if the defendant was criminally convicted. Due to the fair nature of the insanity plea, it remains a valid form of defense for mentally handicapped people charged with crimes. Not only is it a valid form of defense, but it is a necessary one. It was set in place…

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Lamber HR, Weinberger LE: Persons with Several Mental Illnesses in Jail and Prison :a review.…

    • 1389 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Recidivism In Prisons

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The documentary, The Released, described the challenges those with mental illness face when they are released from prison. In most cases, the inmates were unable to break the cycle of recidivism. The high rate of recidivism within the mentally ill prison population is caused by different factors. One factor that contributes to the high rate is a lack of support, which as a result, may lead to an increased chance of a relapse. Also, the challenge of reintegrating back into the world can be even more difficult due to the person’s mental illness. Once the offenders are released, they face extra obstacles of trying to find a place to leave and a job. All of these factors, together, cause the high recidivism rate for mentally ill offenders.…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Mr X is a seventy year old man who has spent most of his adult life in and out of various mental health wards in a number of local hospitals. Diagnosed with schizophrenia at the age of 27, an illness he maintains he has never had, Mr X blames his family, in particular his father and brother, for his many stays in hospital including numerous detentions under Sections 2 and 3 of the Mental Health Act (1983).…

    • 2381 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Rehabilitation In Prison

    • 1389 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Incarceration of the mentally ill is a social problem because studies have shown that a significantly high percentage of individuals incarcerated in the United States have been diagnosed with a mental illness. A Stanford Law school study has shown that prisons and jails have become the new mental health care facilities. In their study, they highlighted the findings of the National Sheriff’s Association and Treatment Advocacy center, that ten times the amount of mental ill individuals are incarcerated rather than being treated in mental health facilities. The Stanford Law school…

    • 1389 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagine it is sentencing day at the court house, the jury has already found you guilty and now the judge orders you to serve 15 to life with no possibility of parole. How would you feel? I would be petrified at the thought of not being able to see my family, to continue my education, and quite frankly for my safety. Now imagine, someone who suffers with schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, anxiety disorders or depression. In 2015 it was reported that “about 2.4 million people live with schizophrenia and that 1 million people live with bipolar disorder” (DeMoss, 2015). More so, the number of those living with major depression was a staggering 14.8 million people. With mental illness comes heightened emotions especially when it comes to the struggle…

    • 1091 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Separation In Prisons

    • 935 Words
    • 4 Pages

    A prison’s intended use was for holding cells prior to trial (October 22, film), and in present day, we have seen a tremendous shift, as we are currently in a mass incarceration era (Petersilia, 2003). Due to a shift in policies during the 70’s with the end of the Progressive era, we have currently over two million persons incarcerated (Cullen & Johnson, 2012). The problem with this change is that harshness is now acceptable (October 22, class) and we now imprison anyone deemed a threat (October 22, class). What is often overlooked is that some of these “threats” are not what they appear. As Jessica alluded to in her presentation, there is a grave problem with mental illness in the prison system, with on a federal level, 45% of surveyed inmates having a preexisting mental illness (December 8, presentations), and having a mental illness while incarcerated can put one in more vulnerable situations (October 1, presentations). Ryan also noted that 40% of addicts are currently incarcerated (December 8, presentations). Those are examples of society spending time and money to imprison individuals who would otherwise require treatment, which is neither an effective, nor efficient use of resources (September 15,…

    • 935 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Criminal justice issues among individuals with mental health and substance use conditions is a growing problem. This paper examines mental health issues as it relates to the criminal justice system and specifically how mental health and the mentally ill can play a role in the crime. Different factors can become a problem with mental health illness and the criminal justice system. Mental health illness can contribute to jail and prison overcrowding, high crime rates, drug addiction, and many other problems. After the wide deinstitutionalization of state hospitals, jails and prisons have seen an increase in the number and percentage of individuals with mental health and substance use. Today, the largest U.S. jails and prisons hold more people…

    • 3605 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The article Effects of Serious Mental Illness and Substance Abuse on Criminal Offenses was a very interesting article and it also brought up some interesting facts. It talks about people who have a mental illness are overrepresented in jails and prisons. In the article it says that these people with these mental illnesses need treatment and not punishment and I think that is so true (4). I work in a prison and most of the prison population is mentally ill. I feel that if they would have given these guys some treatment when they were out on the streets, they wouldn’t be in prison. There was a study done to determine the effects of serious mental illness and substance abuse on the criminal offenses of a group of community residents with serious mental illness and co-occurring substance abuse disorders. The researchers used community residents that had already been part of a research done in the Hawaii Jail Diversion Project. That research compared the functional outcomes of persons diverted out of jail and into mental health and substance abuse services with the outcomes of a control group of persons arrested and jailed (7). For their research they got their information “by asking participants three or four probe questions during the project’s intake interview, which occurred within seven days of their arrest: Why did you [offense]? Is there anything else you can tell me about [offense]? Do I know everything I need to know to understand why you [offense]? If not, what else do I need to know” (psychiatryonline)? The conclusions from the research didn’t shoe that mental illness was the cause of their criminal acts but substance abuse was responsible for most of their criminal acts or other risk factors such as unemployment, poverty, homelessness, and substance abuse…

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays