Preview

Comparing Perralt's Cinderell D Aulnoy And Grimm

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
560 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparing Perralt's Cinderell D Aulnoy And Grimm
1. The elements of Cinderella are all different in every way. All have either the presence, or absence of a fairy godmother, different levels of violence, and the ending. But the most common elements consist of, sibling rivalry between the sisters, her innocence. The rule that Cinderella must return from the ball by midnight, and the characterization of the prince.
2. Folktales back in the eighteenth and nineteenth were told by the elders mostly for teachings for the little ones in the group. Fairytales that are told today are much more “disneyfied” and have happier ending and are for the reader's enjoyment
3. The Grimm brothers argued for preserving the tales exactly as heard from the oral sources, scholars have determined that they sought to improve the tales by making them more readable.
4. Perrault and D'Aulnoy and Grimm have two very different
…show more content…
Perralt’s version of Cinderella was a one of a kind folktale. It is the original story and the first one ever wrote. That is why it be considered canonical over all other Cinderella stories.
1. Of the versions of Cinderella presented in this chapter, Perrault's version of the story is what a lot of people would consider most familiar to them. Many people have heard Walt Disney's version of this story, and Perrault's version is almost exactly similar to that.
2. Cullen's "Interesting to Note" may suggest to some that the release of Walt Disney's version of Cinderella may be him trying to promote feminism in some way. During the time he released his version, which was in the 1950's, women were seen as ideal housewives and mothers and were not needed in the workforce. But, Disney's version suggests that women did not have to put up with that. They are just as capable as anyone else to do the things that they want. Women should be able to go out and have fun and not have to stay home, clean and take care of everything. They should be able to do what they want, and in Disney's version, that is what Cinderella

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The movie is still keeping the gender stereotype alive and thriving even in people’s homes. In today’s America, where women are in the vanguard of dignified treatment, respect and equality for women, the gender role in fairy tales especially Cinderella is still the same. As Silima Nanda points out, “Ambitious women in fairy tales are always portrayed as evil from within, ugly and scheming, wielding over other women and men” (Portrayal of Women 246-250). While there has been efforts to rewrite fairy tale like Sleeping Beauty for the screen, Cinderella remains the passive girl with an evil stepfamily. The stepmother is typecast as wicked, cannibalistic and self-conceited because she wants a better life for…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cinderella, the main character of the world’s most famous children’s tale, exhibits traits that, if looked at carefully, show she is a morally compromised character with sadistic tendencies. This is what Elisabeth Panttaja, an ex-professor at Tufts University, argues in “Cinderella: Not So Morally Superior”. Panttaja uses the role of Cinderella’s mother to highlight the heroine's unsavory actions. Cinderella and her mother constantly employ treacherous tactics to manipulate people in the name of riches and power instead of love, as readers have been led to believe. Panttaja’s article, “Cinderella: Not…

    • 252 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    To begin with Cinderella has always been that girl mistreated very poorly but has never give up. Her stepmother begins to show her true colors after her and her father got married. “She employed her in the meanest work of the house” (Perraultt). Cinderella step mother was very mean and only cared about her real daughters in the French story. But in the Chinese story Yeh-Shen real mother died. And her father married someone else and her stepmother did not like Yeh-Shen so she mistreated her and killed Yeh-Shen’s fish which was her only friend she had. “She would also scoured the dishes, tables, etc.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In The essay Cinderella: Not So Morally Superior by Elisabeth Panttaja, the author analyzes the classic fairy tale that most of us have grown up knowing of Cinderella. The author’s analysis is a bit abrupt and right to the point, but also cleverly stated. The authors essay is about Cinderella being crafty, and not the normal perception of Cinderella being a princess who is virtuous and patient. It is also described in the essay that Cinderella may not be as motherless as it seems in the classic fairy tale. We think to assume that because she has magical powers looking over her that she is also of hierarchy morally. It is an example of the complexity in what is portrayed as a simple story. A story about good Vs. Evil, and good always overcomes.…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Edith Hamilton comparing Perseus’ story to the well known Disney story, Cinderella is undoubtedly a genius idea because more readers will understand the moral of the story and what he is trying to convey. Using this method to engage readers make them more intrigued and understandable especially when mythology relationships and stories may be a bit intricate to comprehend.…

    • 382 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In cinderella this young teenage girl wants to live up to her dream, but never get's because of her stepmom and stepsisters. Always in the end she ends up achieving what she was trying to work so hard for in the beginning. In all conclusion the story of cinderella shows the theme in literature to be sometimes predictable and other times unrecognizable.…

    • 535 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Growing up I can remember how I felt after watching the Cinderella story. Inspired by the rags-to-riches fairy tale, I can remember hoping that maybe someday I could be like Cinderella. I never imagined the story I knew all-too-well would have been dramatically altered from its original version. Though the lesson remains the same, comparisons reveal numerous differences between Walt Disney’s Cinderella to the earlier Charles Perrault’s “Cinderella: Or the Glass Slipper”. Variations are noticed in characters, events, and outcomes of this world-famous…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    While Cinderella’s mother and the Fairy Godmother are not named, her stepmother and stepsisters are and hold many conversation with Cinderella and each other that revolve around numerous things like clothing, chores, nature and kindness. But, people still tend to have a problem with the story, thinking it feminist. In the film, the stepmother and step sisters obsess over their own looks and constantly put down Cinderella, even her name is a mockery. Then there is also the fact that the Prince ‘saves’ her from her life of misfortune and misery. But I don’t think that this is the case. Kenneth Branagh, the director of the film, balances the old with the new. He keeps aspects of the original Walt Disney film while modernising the character of Cinderella. The film focuses on the message that you should be kind to others, even if they are not kind themselves instead of beauty. Cinderella is also shown to be kind, courageous and brave with a unique personality which the Prince fall in love with. Yes, she is beautiful, but the Prince does not fall for her beauty but rather is charm. Also, though the Prince does ’save’ her in a sense, she didn’t really ‘need’ saving and Cinderella does a lot of the ‘saving’…

    • 1090 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Denise Bates Cinderella

    • 825 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Cinderella is a 1950 classical musical produced by Walt Disney. Cinderella was a young modest forgiving young lady who had a servant’s heart. At a young age her mother died and it was just her and her father. Cinderella father wanted her to have a mother’s care and marries her step mother. Cinderella is abused and mistreated by her step family who basically took over everything when her father passed. They took over the estate and made her become a maid in her own home. Overlooking all the negative things Cinderella grows into a kind young woman, friending the animals in the barn and the mice and birds that lived around the estate. The cast in Cinderella consist of 8 main characters. Cinderella, Jaq and Gus, Lady Tremaine, , Prince Charming, Anastasia Tremaine, Drizella Tremaine, Lucifer, and the Fairy Godmother. Cinderella is 19 years old with hair to her shoulders with blue eyed. After her father passes she is forced into being a servant in her own home. In spite of that she maintains hope through her dreams and remains the sweet person she is. She has faith that one day all her dreams of being happy will come true and her kind-heartedness will pay off. With the help of her animal friends they fix up an old dress that belonged to her mother so she could attend a royal ball. Jaq and Gus are two mice who are Cinderella sidekicks. They perform many favors for Cinderella. Jaq was the leader of the mice, planning all the strategies on how to avoid the cat Lady Tremaine the evil…

    • 825 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The fairy tales that we grew up with are not the originals. Disney and the brothers Grimm had two very different versions. While many of us grew up watching cute birds and mice following the woe begotten princess, the original stories were forgotten by most. These stories were far darker, ending in cruel justice for a stepsister or worse. The difference between aspects of the two tales discussed, in some instances, is the difference between night and day. Grimm fairy tales contain more violence, harsher villains, and swifter justice.…

    • 730 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Everyone knows the story of Cinderella, the girl who finds her prince with the help of a magical fairy god-mother, transforming her previously horrible life to a fabulous depiction of every little girls dream. Generations of children around the world have heard the story Cinderella countless times, however most people are unaware of the multiple versions of this legend. The European version of Cinderella ,“Aschenputtel” written by the Grimm Brothers consists of the female protagonist being treated as a servant, yet somehow manages to leave her cruel family behind for her Prince whom she lives happily ever after with. Another version of Cinderella is the Native American tale “The Algonquin Cinderella”, where the female protagonist is also mistreated by her family, however she is fortunate enough to “find” her own prince in her village. Although both stories present similar morals, both vary in details such as characters, settings,and use of magic.…

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Cinderella Research Paper

    • 2634 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Throughout the years, there have been several retellings of Cinderella. Some of the retellings are based on culture, the society at that particular moment and what would grab the audience attention. One of the most common retelling of Cinderella is: The Complete Grimm’s Fairy Tale. There’s also the: Radio Plays for Children. One of the most recent retelling would have to be: A Cinderella Story. All three of the retellings leave the audience with a different interpretation of Cinderella. Never the less you will get the same moral of the story from all three.…

    • 2634 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are many versions to the famous fairy tale Cinderella. Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm’s German version of Cinderella, “Aschenputtel,” is a household story of a young girl named Cinderella who eventually marries a prince. This specific version of Cinderella gave birth to the Walt Disney version of Cinderella that most Americans know today. However the stories are very different. The Grimm brothers’ version is much darker and gory then the classic American version. Small differences like this shed a different light on Cinderella and her journey to a “happy” ending.…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The story of Cinderella is an interesting one as it perfectly depicts the example we’ve been given in class of the “hero’s journey”. Throughout the plot, it begins with her family struggles. Her mother has perished and her father marries a woman who is not fold of Cinderella in the slightest. In addition to this, the woman has two daughters who are spoiled…

    • 363 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Grimm Fairy Tales

    • 4080 Words
    • 17 Pages

    The Grimm Brothers were German professors who grew famous for publishing classic fairy tales and through their work in linguistics. Linguistics relates to how the sound in words shift over time through translations, specifically relating to how translations of tales were changed because of the switching between languages (Grimm Fairy Tales). Before being professors and taking an interest in linguistics, it was a tragedy that originally brought them to discovering the fairytales. Without the tragedy, who knows if the fairy tales would be around today? The Grimm Brothers grew interested in the fairy tales after their father died unexpectedly and the family grew very poor (Brothers Grimm). The Brothers later met a wise man that brought them to a library filled with old books containing a couple tales (Brothers Grimm). The flame continued as they read the tales and grew more of an interest. They started to listen to people’s favorite stories in order to hear vocal patterns and while doing this; it helped them to record the tales that would be later published (Grimm’s Fairy Tales). By understanding the linguistics behind story telling they were able to understand how the pieces of the tale fit together as best as possible. The Grimm…

    • 4080 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Powerful Essays