Preview

Comparing Joan Of Arc And The Nuremberg Trials

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1028 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparing Joan Of Arc And The Nuremberg Trials
There have been many examples throughout history of people imposing their beliefs on one another. Some of the more prominent, were even persecuted for spreading their ideas to others. A few of the well-known cases for this “crime” are that of Jesus Christ, Joan of Arc and the Nuremberg Trials. However, one strange thing about these cases is that they did not always have the same outcome for the “criminal”. In Jesus and Joan’s situation they are both considered heroes, and are sacred for the work they did spreading their beliefs. However, in the case of the Nuremberg Trials, the German soldiers are accused of horrendous war crimes committed during World War II. Yet these actions were, just like that of Jesus and Joan, all in the name of their personal beliefs. So why is it that Jesus and Joan are viewed differently than the German soldiers? I …show more content…
In fact, she was even made a saint by the Roman Catholic Church. Yet she too did not have the cleanest record. During the Hundred Years War, the French were being beaten back by the English, primarily during the Lancastrian Phase. It was around this same time that Joan had visions from several different angels and saints, telling her to fight alongside the French in the war. King Charles, desperate to sway the course of the war, accepted. With her, the tide of the war turned in favor of the French. This did not sit well with the English who believed her to be a sign rom the Devil. So, when they eventually captured her they made sure she paid for it. They tried her before a court of only English citizens, accused of heresy. For both claiming she heard spiritual voices and wearing male clothing during battle. She was then convicted and burned at the stake for her crimes. Once again, even with such actions she was canonized for preaching her beliefs in the catholic church and fighting for them. However, this sort of behavior has not always worked out well for

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    She was also charged with crossdressing as she refused to change the way she dressed unless God commanded. On these charges, Joan was sentenced to death by burning at the stake. Joan was burned on May 30, 1431, in Rouen, France before an estimated crowd of 10,000 French citizens. This enraged the French people, causing them to fight back harder than ever before. The French defeated the English in 1450. Joan, though deceased, had another trial, and the French courts cleared her of all charges. In 1920, Joan was canonized by the Catholic Church as the patron saint of soldiers and France. (Joan of…

    • 857 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    It is hard to imagine the sheer amount of faith necessary for the willingness to sacrifice one’s own safety for the sake of someone else. Various Christian witnesses have demonstrated this faith all throughout the millennia, including – probably most obviously – St. Joan of Arc or Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. However, one man who perhaps best exemplifies absolute Christian faith and martyrdom in recent decades is Dietrich Bonhoeffer. His life is the story of a man who essentially sacrificed an opportunity for a peaceful and quiet life as a pastor for the sake of the oppressed, despite having no reason to do so, other than his own conscience. His life, as it will soon be explained, was an incredibly remarkable one, and one that closely demonstrated him to be among the noblest of Christian witnesses.…

    • 1717 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    She believed God charged her with driving the English from France. So no peace. She also was not a war leader in the traditional sense. She was more an icon for the French. So saying she 'led' the French to victory, you might say 'inspired' instead. Perhaps even shamed (all those martial men not fighting while this young lady did) the French military. She motivated a very demoralized French military and helped to give them the resolve to fight on. Coming at it from the 'feminist' angle is good. She became too powerful, in that many believed she was in communion with God, so that it worried the French leaders a lot - all men. So when she was captured, instead of ransoming her (a VERY common practice for captured nobles or the one of a kind Joan) from the English they let her be executed. The English certainly didn't like her!! It wasn't REALLY heresy and witchcraft that condemned her, mainly politics. Those were just handy…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Salem Witchcraft Trials and The Nuremberg Trials are two alike yet very different trials. The Salem Witchcraft Trials is about the trials of people who were accused to be witches. The Nuremberg Trials is about the trials of the men charge of the Nazi Germany army and the killing of inconcent men, women and children. The two trials are alike because they both have to do protecting the public and doing good for the public. They are diffrent because Salem Witchcraft Trials Trials is about witches that were nonexistent in reality, but the Nuremberg Trials were about leaders that did affect the death are actual people. These trials are both very inportant in there own reasons.…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The head organizer for Hitler’s “solutions to the Jewish problem,” Eichmann was being held personally responsible for the deaths of many Jews. During the trial, it was made clear that during the time, he did not so much worry that what he was doing was wrong, but rather about obeying the laws set forth by the Reich. He claims to have been a “Pontius Pilate” character, one with his hands tied by law, regardless of moral comprehension (134 Arendt). Although it is evident that he sometimes approached his assignments with disdain and apprehension (135 Arendt), Eichmann was so obsessed with his success in the Nazi party that his moral beliefs were never displayed. As described in Kant’s moral principal, Eichmann was displaying obvious blind obedience (Arendt 136). During the time in the German occupied territories, Eichmann would have been committing a crime not to follow his orders. Regardless of the truth behind his claim to have only been following his every order, Eichmann still was obeying what even he himself knew to be unjust laws. (235…

    • 1029 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The English then held Joan prisoner and put her on trial for a multitude of charges, the most notable being cross-dressing, which Joan often did while in armor or traveling through dangerous territory. The trial was incredibly unjust and ignored or twisted laws, such as those that stated when cross-dressing was allowed, and she was found guilty and sentenced to die by burning at the stake. So, at the age of nineteen, Joan of Arc was burned at the stake on May 30th, 1431, in Rouen, Normandy. By her own request, Joan was burned while clutching a crucifix to her chest. Posthumously, Joan was cleared of all charges, declared a martyr, and then canonized, becoming one of the nine secondary saints of France. Jeanne d’Arc was an intelligent, strong-willed, and possible divine woman, who was more a Girl on Fire than Katniss Everdeen could ever be. Vive la…

    • 716 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The ability to rally the troops, however, did not stay with her, as was evident on September 8th. Joan attempted an attack on the English, but the French captains hadn’t given it their all, as many of the men weren’t as willing to follow Joan into battle, and this caused the army to suffer greatly, including Joan getting an arrow in her thigh. This started Joan’s downward slide as she lost favor with Charles, whom she had crowned, and lost the ability to give her men enough courage to jump into battle when the odds were against them, which it very nearly always…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Early twentieth century events including the Armenian genocide during World War I and the Holocaust during World War II provided a historical basis and plenty of positive evidence for those who, like the Dali Llama, argued the need for an internationally identifiable definition of human rights. The systematic extermination of over 200,000 Armenians at the hands of the Young Turks during World War I and over 6 million Jews by the Nazis during World War II undoubtedly catalyzed an international coalition for addressing crimes against humanity. Yet, in order to define crimes against humanity, the international community faced both cultural barriers and the universally accepted rights to state sovereignty. Even still, the need to set a strong international precedent for condemning crimes against humanity that was undertaken during the Nuremberg trials after World War II was not successfully carried out. The shortcomings of the Nuremberg trials, in terms of defending against crimes against humanity, failed to separate the atrocities of the Holocaust from the acts of war perpetrated by the Nazis. In doing so, the trials inadvertently downplayed the historical and cultural significance of the Holocaust. Those who deserved justice the most and those who were guilty of injustices within the realm of crimes against humanity were not always held accountable. Thus, questions regarding the Nuremberg trial’s failure to set a precedent for condemning future crimes against humanity, the positive and negative affects of defining accountability during…

    • 4284 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Inquisitor argued against Joan by using pathos in a well organized statement that appealed to the court's emotions and religious beliefs. Joan of Arc was being tried for heresy, disagreeing with church doctrines, and the Inquisitor took this information as a way to directly state that Joan was to be punished for upsetting the church.…

    • 316 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Why Did Genocide Happen

    • 1373 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Following the conclusion of World War II in Nazi Germany, the world witnessed the Nuremburg War Criminal Trials, a set of trials against the onlookers of the Holocaust, or Germany’s mass extermination of European Jews. In most of the cases in the trials, the accused often used obedience to plead their cases, claiming that their actions had all come from higher in the Nazi’s hierarchy of government. Researcher Stanley Milgram “devised [an] experiment to answer the question ‘Could it be that Eichmann and his million accomplices in the Holocaust were just following orders? Could we call them accomplices?’ … The study revealed that two-thirds of the time, the participant was willing to deliver potentially life-threatening shocks to the ‘learner’ simply because they were receiving orders from an authority figure” (Document A and Documentary). Historians baffled the thought that Americans were not capable of killing their own peers, simply because the population was thought of as “superior” and it was claimed to be “impossible for an American to kill a fellow American.” However, Milgram’s experiments confirmed the truth that humans are willing to commit unethical or inhumane acts against other humans if given orders from an authority figure, confirming his suspicions during the Nuremberg Trials, and more specifically, Adolf Eichmann’s claim that he was only following…

    • 1373 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Nuremberg trials were led by over eight judges; four permanent and four alternate members of the panel. Each of the four Allies sent two judges to Nuremberg. Many Nazis were punished in various forms such as; Four were sentenced to various prison terms. Three received life imprisonment. The rest were sentenced to death by hanging and these executions were carried out on the night of October 15-16. The second group of trials of lesser war criminals was carried out later, including special trials dealing with the crimes of judges, lawyers, and doctors. The trials lasted for more than nine months and ended on August 31, 1946. During this time, the prosecution used many captured German documents to describe details of the Nazis' crimes. There…

    • 183 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Joan of Arc

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages

    To the French, Joan of Arc is known as Jeanne D’Arc. Of her many names, she referred to herself as “La Pucelle” or the Maid. Joan led a fascinating life and is one of the most heroic women in all of history: in her early years she struggled with being different, in her mid-life she was a military leader, and in the time of her death she was wrongly accused of something she had no part in.…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Nuremberg Trials were a critical point in the history of international law because it established the fact that humanity has the need of an international shield to shelter and protect. This event was responsible for contributing in the ongoing process of developing rules that are binding between states and nations also known as international laws. The judgment of the trials may be one of the most important events in the history of international law due to the fact that it assisted in establishing laws against war crimes. One of the biggest questions raised was whether causing a war was an international crime that would be punishable or not. Many believed there was no guilt to be proven, rather the settlement for the punishment of those who perpetrated inhuman acts against millions of innocent people. International intervention was needed to avoid mere vengeance and satisfy some type of justice. But the people were still grieving from the after effects of the war and wanted justice that would repay those responsible with the same dosage of their acts.…

    • 3879 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Nuremberg trials were descried as “the best trials I history” by Norman Birkett a…

    • 1181 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On St. Joan Of Arc

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Two soldiers escorted her there. While there, she met with Charles VII and gained his trust. From there, she gained armor (included a donated horse, sword, banner, armor, and more) and an army to help back her up. She fought hard in battle and was wounded two times (an arrow to the shoulder and a crossbow bolt). Later on, she was captured. She tried many times to escape. She failed. She was tried by the English, found guilty, and was burned at the stake. The English burned and raked her over and over again, then they threw her remnants into the Seine River to make sure that no one got any piece of her.…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays