Preview

Comparing Homosexuality In Hamlet's Relationship With Ophelia

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
669 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparing Homosexuality In Hamlet's Relationship With Ophelia
“To be [gay], or not to be [gay] – that is the question” (3.1.56). Throughout Hamlet,
Hamlet’s constant questioning of heteronormativity overall stems from his unhealthy and misandristic relationships with women. Hamlet’s foundational opinion of female relationships is with his narcissistic mother, Gertrude. Building off of Gertrude’s selfish parenting style is Hamlet’s relationship with Ophelia. Although Ophelia’s relationship with Hamlet is romantic as opposed to maternal, Ophelia’s disloyalty towards Hamlet is yet another driving point of Hamlet seeking homosexual attraction from his best friend, Horatio. Hamlet’s same sex attraction to Horatio stems from his shattered view of heterosexual relationships caused by deceitful interactions with women.
The first triggering point of Hamlet’s homosexual desires is the death of his father and the effects of his mother’s actions. Although this sudden poignant event made a profoundly depressing impact on Hamlet, making the situation even more emotionally detrimental is Gertrude’s marriage to Hamlet’s uncle, Claudius, just days after his father’s funeral. Gertrude takes no interest in Hamlet’s desires or opinion of Claudius ultimately driving Hamlet further away from
…show more content…
In order for Hamlet and Horatio to find romantic affection for each other, Hamlet’s first destroys his heterosexual relationships. Foundationally beginning with Gertrude’s narcissistic parenting, Hamlet is first introduced to the idea of untrustworthy female interactions on a maternal level. Ophelia’s betrayal of affection is the breaking point for Hamlet’s attempt at heterosexual relationships. Hamlet demolishes his opinion of all women and he is emotionally forced to remove all women from his life. Without looking towards women for companionship, Hamlet is only left with Horatio. Horatio’s trustworthiness and tenderness for Hamlet is what allows him to prevail as Hamlet’s nostalgic and homosexually romantic

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Hamlet

    • 1435 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Hamlet is one of the most complex characters and stories in western literature. Shakespeare has loaded this play to the brim with philosophy and ideas far beyond his years. Hamlet himself can be dissected and interpreted in thousands of different ways; but most notably he is dramatic. Dramatic in every sense of the word, he enjoys acting and plays and he is extremely animated in all of his interactions. The same drama that impassions him, tortures him; so much so that he often contemplates suicide. Possibly the most significant drama in the play and in Hamlet surrounds the sanctity of the, and specifically, Hamlet’s mind. Hamlet doesn’t allow anyone to intrude his mind for many reason none more important then the other. The reasons that seem the most profound all surround the validity of his own sexuality and the judgments of the gender relationships he is apart of. Hamlet seemingly blames his mother for parts of his fathers death. He knows she didn’t actually kill him but he blames her for her lack of grief and also her marriage to the swine that is Claudius. He even goes as far as to say to her “aye madam, it is common” right after Gertrude told him about how all life ends he basically calls her a hooker. (I, ii, 13) It is peculiar that he has such a reaction to a mother trying to comfort her grieving son. Throughout the play Hamlet comes up against many trials but none greater then the challenge of accepting who he is versus what he is trying to be. All of Hamlet’s greatness and all of his flaws come from the same source his extreme aversion to the gender relationships posed in his world. In order for us to truly understand hamlet we have to penetrate what he so actively tries to protect; which in Hamlet’s case is his mind and his understanding of love, and his own sexuality.…

    • 1435 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    This monograph chapter argues that Hamlet “redefines the son’s position between two fathers by relocating it in relation to an indiscriminately sexual maternal body that threatens to annihilate the distinction between the fathers and hence problematizes the son’s paternal identification” (14-15). Hamlet “rewrites the story of Cain and Abel as the story of Adam and Eve, relocating masculine identity in the presence of the adulterating female” (30). Gertrude “plays out the role of the missing Eve: her body is the garden in which her husband dies, her sexuality the poisonous weeds that kill him, and poison the world—and the self—for her son” (30). The absence of the father combined with the presence of the “engulfing mother” awakens “all the fears incident to the primary mother-child bond” (30). The solution is for Hamlet to remake his mother “in the image of Virgin Mother who could guarantee his father’s purity, and his own, repairing the boundaries of his selfhood” (31). In the closet scene, Hamlet attempts “to remake his mother pure by divorcing her from her sexuality” (32-33). Although Gertrude “remains relatively opaque, more a screen for Hamlet’s fantasies about her than a fully developed character in her own right,” the son “at least believes that she has returned to him as the mother he can call ‘good lady’ (3.4.182)” (34). As a result, Hamlet achieves “a new calm and self-possession” but at a high price: “for the parents lost to him at the beginning of the play can be restored only insofar as they are entirely separated from their sexual bodies. This is a pyrrhic solution to the problems of embodiedness and familial identity . . .” (35).…

    • 921 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    While Ophelia demonstrates a kind and sweet character, Queen Gertrude is depicted in a much different light. Shakespeare had made a developed character that has far more than one-dimensional. Aside from her role attached to the male characters in Hamlet, Queen Gertrude is an intelligent, respectable woman. Unfortunately, Gertrude is not always painted in the best light as her lack of awareness of her husband’s murder. Gertrude “doesn’t seem to know what’s going on around her and doesn’t know why Hamlet is moody” (Tom Stoppard 23). Acknowledging her oblivious behavior that Shakespeare has given her, Gertrude is often depicted as an unaware woman. Nonetheless, she is greater than the stereotypes surrounding the Renaissance time for women. However,…

    • 1547 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Female Power in Hamlet

    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages

    William Shakespeare’s Hamlet is characterized by its tragic conclusion and its memorable cast. As a reflection of the time period in which Hamlet was written, the predominately male cast views the female characters as inferior. What the men do not realize is that the women have more control than what is initially predicted. Throughout the play, Gertrude uses her influence over Claudius to gain political ground while Ophelia uses her sexuality to have control over her relationship with Hamlet. This sense of female power also has a lasting effect on the theme of sexuality and corruption in the play.…

    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The love a man has for his mother and the love he has for his girlfriend/fiancé/wife are two different kinds of love that always seems to conflict one another. The mother and the female companion usually really like each other or they hate each other. In Shakespeare’s Hamlet, Gertrude and Ophelia has a steady relationship with each other. But Gertrude’s relationship Hamlet starts off as unhappy and ends with death. Throughout the play Hamlet is questioning Gertrude’s love for him and his father which cause their once steady relationship to shaken. For Ophelia and Hamlet, both were so in love, but later in the play shows Ophelia worrying about Hamlet and her love for him slowly diminishing. Gertrude and Ophelia have their own important role in the play with how they affect Hamlet’s decisions all through the play.…

    • 626 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hamlet notoriously asserts, “Frailty, thy name is woman!” (I.II.150) after being disgruntled and disappointed by his mother’s short mourning period for his father. To a modern audience, this phrase is immensely appalling, but for the Elizabethan era, this is perfectly acceptable. Elizabethan social order was built upon a temple where its foundations was the patriarchal domination and it was decorated with misogynistic ornaments. Hamlet’s tumultuous relationship with Ophelia is due to his distrust and dissatisfaction with his own mother, Gertrude. Shakespeare’s Elsinore is pulsing with testosterone throughout its palace walls. King Claudius, King of Denmark, is the chief of state and Gertrude remains loyal and dependent on him. On a lower level, Polonius, is the chief advisor, who is the head of his family and Ophelia remains dependent on him. Hamlet views that both Ophelia and Gertrude are dependent on the men in their lives because they are incapable of fending, thinking and supporting themselves, which prompts to Hamlet’s misogynistic feelings.…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hamlet's Paranoia

    • 2158 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Hamlet once saw his mother as the epitome of virtue. This image is dashed against the rocks when he finds her married, incestuously, to his uncle less than two months following his father’s death. Having only seen his mother with his father, Hamlet perceives that he has lost her after she marries Claudius. Hamlet has, “All his life he has believed in her, we may be sure, as such a son would” (Bradley, 98). Hamlet looks down upon his mother’s second marriage as disrespect to the memory of his father. Hamlet cries out “O, most wicked speed to post with such dexterity to incestuous sheets!” (I. 2. 161-62). Now alone save for Horatio, Hamlet’s madness is left to grow unchecked.…

    • 2158 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although Gertrude and Ophelia are not well developed through out the play, their actions, language and influence on the play portray them as the obedient passive type of women. Gertrude is Hamlet 's mother, a queen who betrayed her husband and got seduced by the prince 's uncle Claudius. She remarried with him and thereafter obeyed every order from Claudius. Gertrude is objectified by Claudius, as he said: "my crown, mine own ambition and my Queen." To him the queen is one of his possessions and not even listed as the first. This suggested Gertrude is used by Claudius to get to the throne. The hasty marriage only a few weeks after her husband 's death shows her great dependence on men. Hamlet 's proclamation that he will "speak daggers to her, but use none" illustrate that he perceives her to be inferior, weak enough to fall foul to his words. Overall, Gertrude is the type of women that cannot survive without a man in her life, with such a weak soul she betrays her own husband and son.…

    • 546 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hamlet is about Prince Hamlet’s misperceptions that women are morally Corrupt. Hamlet’s misperceptions originate from Gertrude’s inappropriate behavior and ignorance and Ophelia’s malleable behavior, and throughout the play Hamlet is rude and cynical to the two main female characters. Hamlet makes a sweeping generalization based on his Mother Gertrude and Ophelia that all women are morally corrupt, and in doing so he demonstrates a lack of trust in Gertrude that contributes to his madness and leads him to more trouble.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This incident develops the character because by Hamlet not feeling the way she does towards him, it gives the audience an insight on how Hamlet feels about women. In this case, the audience can see that Hamlet’s disgust of his mother’s sudden marriage makes him become an antagonist towards women. He thinks they’re all alike, easy to persuade like his mother was persuaded by his uncle and in haste too.…

    • 339 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The crux of Ernest Jones’ article “ Tragedy and the Mind of the Infant” is Hamlet’s incestrous love for his mother. Jones roots Hamlet's misogyny in Gertrude and Ophelia rejecting him sexually; “When sexual repression is highly pronounced, as with Hamlet, then both types of women are felt to be hostile: the pure one out of resentment at her repulse, the sensual one out of the temptation she offers to plunge into guiltiness”(Jones 204). Hamlet obviously demonstrates misogynistic beliefs from his interaction with both Gertrude and Ophelia, however Jones’ reasoning behind his hatred is not accurate representation of the cause of Hamlet’s misogyny. Hamlet’s hatred of women does not derive from “sexual repression”, but rather the lack of love and tenderness from women. He does not have any female relationships which are healthy or fulfill the love that Hamlet needed after the death of his father. The only women in his life continuously disappoint him and do not truly love…

    • 1781 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Women of Shakespeare’s time were regarded to be possessions of men and as such were conditioned to be submissive. This would have influenced, in my judgment, how Shakespeare created the female characters in Hamlet. Furthermore, in the essay “The Warrant of Womanhood, Shakespeare and Feminist Criticism”, Ann Thompson points out that male characters in Hamlet have a limited perception of the females. Shakespeare, according to Ann Thompson, goes as far as to let the audience know that he intended for the male character to misunderstand the female, therefore the male characters are often very wrong about the females in the play. The men completely misread the women and in Ophelia and Gertrude’s situation, the consequences are very tragic. In order to address this issue, it is necessary to explore the characters of Gertrude and Ophelia in Hamlet and the characters of Hero and Beatrice in Much Ado about Nothing, and in addition, how they are treated by other characters. This will then enable me to pass my own judgement, as to how the women are represented in the two plays Hamlet and Much Ado about Nothing.…

    • 3648 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many of the things he says about her, or in reference to her could easily be seen as misogynistic. He refers to her actions as if they are typical of all women. Hamlet is impatient with the introduction of the play. Ophelia assures him that it will be brief, to which Hamlet replies, “As woman’s love.” Although Ophelia has done nothing to betray Hamlet in any way and is still very much in love with him, Hamlet assumes that her love won’t last simply because Gertrude’s love for Hamlet’s father did not last after his death. In a soliloquy early into the play, Hamlet mentions what he considers to be his mother’s betrayal to him and his father and utters, “Frailty, thy name is woman!” ‘Frailty is referring to his mother’s ‘moral weakness’ which in Gertrude’s case, could very well be true, but it his reference to all women having moral weaknesses and being distrustful. Similarly, when Hamlet finds out the truth regarding his father’s death from the Ghost, he includes the line, “O most pernicious woman!” in his soliloquy. This is to reiterate that women are evil. It is shown in many cases that Hamlet feels betrayed by his mother and seems to use these feelings against all…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hamlet 's Feminity

    • 4368 Words
    • 18 Pages

    Canadian Social Science ISSN 1712-8056 Canadian Academy of Oriental and Occidental Culture Http://www.cscanada.org Http://www.cscanada.net E-mail: css@cscanada.org; caooc@hotmail.com…

    • 4368 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gender Roles In Hamlet

    • 1271 Words
    • 6 Pages

    William Shakespeare’s Hamlet is an intricate literary masterpiece, made up of a conglomeration of different techniques that add dimension, color, and texture to the story. There are countless uses of characterization, dark humor, and many other literary components in Hamlet, all of which are used to give the reader a more emotional and thought provoking reading or listening experience, and insight into the twisted storyline. One of the most interesting of Shakespeare’s techniques is the characterization of each gender as a separate entity. He seems to give the main characters traits that will lead them to follow certain trends for their gender. In Hamlet, Shakespeare characterizes the main male characters as men with power who tend to exercise…

    • 1271 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays