Preview

Comparing Frankenstein And Scott's Blade Runner

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1282 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparing Frankenstein And Scott's Blade Runner
'Man is in truth a miracle'. Man is believed to be born pure, through societal influence an individual may be shaped and their characteristics moulded, this theme is explored in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein and Ridley Scott's Blade Runner. Another important and recurring concept covered in both Shelley's Frankenstein and Scott's Blade Runner is the creation of life. This creation is physically superior and intellectually equal of its creator. Through either a desire 'to live' or to want more out of life, this creation rebels and rises against its creator. Due to their differing social, historical and personal contexts, the similar thematic concerns and issues, examined in both are representative of changes in the values and perspectives of society. …show more content…
Frankenstein appears to take on the form of an instructive tale, warning against the forces of science. Shelley utilises the element of horror as part of the Gothic genre Frankenstein is written in, this is most evident when describing some of Victor Frankenstein's scientific procedures, through imagery, metaphor and personification. Ridley Scott's context of globalization has resulted in a different vision of the future. Technological advancements saw a gradual transition from the industrial age to the informative era. Environmental issues have formed a film in which the cost of commerce has been the death of nature. The opening aerial shot is of an industrialized, polluted city. Throughout the film towers, flames and dirty polluted streets are contrasted against the repeated metaphor of the unicorn, the only natural animal in the film accessible only in a dream. The world is dark, damp and dirty with rain falling continuously. It is a planet hostile to human beings, full of smoke and …show more content…
Scott has been witness to many of the environmental and social disasters, contributing to a growing pessimistic view of the future, and the change in perspective of society, to viewing the environment as fragile. In Shelley's time, Nature was perceived as unalterable. It played a significant role in her novel, as part of both the Gothic setting, and as Romantic ideology for Victor. However, there is no role for the natural in Scott's dystopian 2019. The film's opening wide angle shots create a dark, polluted and decaying city, accompanied by non-diegetic music. This establishes a setting where the environment has been eliminated by science in the pursuit of technological advance. Each composer's respective background influencing their works through Shelley's idea of nature, romantic/gothic tradition, the sublime, against Scott's world where nature does not exist and the replicants are the end result of mans determination to create a better world through

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Nature and its interaction with human emotions are central concerns for both “Frankenstein” and “Blade Runner”. Romantics’ nature is depicted as a healing power and a source of subject and image; in blade runner, the natural worlds pleasing qualities are seen to be abused, e.g. of this is in the opening, where a dark, decayed and dystopian Neo noir world is shown. The detrimental consequences due to carelessness when dealing with the natural world, resulted in the disappearance of its beauty which was an idea constantly feared and warned of by Shelley in Frankenstein.…

    • 3115 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Humanity’s rejection of the natural world in favour of the unnatural pursuit of technology to prolong life is a major concern in both Shelley’s Frankenstein and Scott’s Blade Runner. In the world of Frankenstein, nature is an important aspect of a person’s life and beliefs. Shelley conveys Victor’s desire to conquer nature through the use of his narration such as “new species would bless me as its creator…many happy and excellent natures would owe their being to me.” The monster is then used as a metaphor for the inevitable consequences of the exploitations of nature. She therefore uses Frankenstein as a warning against the rising industrial revolution. Similarly Scott uses Blade Runner to warn society against the exploitation or nature through the rise of consumerism in the 1980s. The long shot of a dark dystopian Los Angeles after the opening credits juxtaposed with jets of fire from oil refinery towers warns the viewer of the consequences of consumerism through the exploitation of nature. There is also a lack of natural imagery such as plants and animals seen in Blade Runner and the use of chiaroscuro lighting gives the world a very…

    • 362 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Shelly and Scott reflect, nature and the natural world in the texts they create, Frankenstein and Blade Runner using literary devices and societal context. In Blade Runner, Scott uses the aspects of the 20th century tradition of dystopias and film noir as literary devices. Throughout Shelly's work of Frankenstein, the romantic and sublime themes of the era are examined as literary devices. The appreciation for the natural wonder of the world is evident throughout Frankenstein when Shelly emphasises to the reader, the sweeping landscapes that are stark, barren and majestic, nature therefore is used as a literary device to simulate the readers sense of emotions, an example of this is when Victor walks through the Alps to relieve himself from…

    • 362 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Frankenstein a major context of the time was Romanticism, a view that saw nature as a force to be in awe of as it had the power to both heal and destroy. it is obvious that Mary Shelly was heavily influenced by the romantics of her time from her book, when it come to the way that she describes the landscape in her world with great detail and the affect it has on victor “These sublime and magnificent scenes afforded me the greatest consolation that I was capable of receiving” (referring to the natural environment around him, the mountains.)…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although perspectives and values change with time, ideas and concepts can transcend. The gothic novel Frankenstein by Mary Shelley and the science fiction film Blade Runner directed by Ridley Scott although composed over one hundred years apart contain the same perennial concepts on the nature of humanity. This is portrayed through notions of dehumanization, monstrosity and redemption, of the “indistinguishable” creator and creature relationship. The romanticist Shelly wrote her gothic novel the enlightenment era which posed questions concerning the mystery of life and nature of humanity. Scott on the other hand composed in the post-industrial age, where technology and morality played a dominant role in society. The composers explore their contextual values while upholding transcendent concepts of humanity incorporating morality and creation though unique techniques in accordance…

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Morals such as what it means to be human and what it means to be monstrous, personal responsibility and the role of the creator are questioned within both texts. Both composers are skilful in how they bring these ideas to the fore in their use of differing forms and styles. Shelley uses narrative structure, characterisation, vivid imagery and symbolism and elements of Gothic and Romantic literature while Scott’s re-imagining of film noir and cyberpunk is filled with potent imagery and symbolism, thoughtful use of lighting, colour and film techniques like camera angles to evoke his futuristic world.…

    • 1645 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The movie Blade Runner and the novel Frankenstein have multiple common themes. One of the easiest connections is the use of science and intelligence to act as a God and create a new type of life. In both Blade Runner and Frankenstein, intelligence and science were used to the eventual detriment of the creators.…

    • 339 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mary Shelley’s seminal novel Frankenstein and Ridley Scott’s cult classic film Blade Runner express the contextual concerns of the post-industrial and post modern eras respectively. Where Shelley’s novel operates as a Gothic expression of the conflicting paradigms of Romantic idealism and Enlightenment rationalism, Scott’s film functions as a response to a postmodern period predicated upon the dissolution of boundaries, in which logocentric truths are fractured and blurred. Both composers, however, imaginatively portray individuals who challenge…

    • 1139 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Frankenstein by Mary Shelley and Blade Runner directed by Ridley Scott are two texts that explore the conflicts between science and nature. Though they touch upon similar themes in different times, it is debateable as to whether they share universal concerns. Both Tyrell and Victor are blinded by their achievements, their unethical actions becoming the harbingers of not only their doom, but the world and people around them. The creator’s Promethean hubris ultimately leads to their downfall. The texts contain similar themes as they were both written in paradigm shifts with a focus on science and nature. However, their contexts are very different and do not suggest that these concerns are universal.…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Frankenstein and Blade Runner Faced with similar challenges against long held values both Frankenstein and Blade Runner express similar concerns and developed concepts that were almost the same as they tried to stop science and technology from eroding fundamental values. However, given the almost 200 year difference it is inevitable that they express their concerns differently. Both Frankenstein and Blade Runner examine the consequences of Man usurping God’s role as creator and the distancing of humanity from a once harmonious relationship with Nature. Romanticism was a reaction against the scientific values of the Enlightenment which spanned from 1650 to the 1800s. It became a movement seeking to end the rationalisation of the Enlightenment and sought a return to a communion with fellow Man and Nature. Frankenstein was written by Mary Shelley in the wake of the Industrial Revolution and it espouses the values of Romanticism; emotion, spirituality and harmony. It serves as a warning against the unchecked scientific progress that was taking place around Shelley. Shelley develops the concept of Man usurping God’s role as creator through her characterisation of Victor. The heavenly imagery “It was the secrets of heaven and earth that I desired to learn” characterises Victor as disrespectful of God’s Laws, his arrogant ambition a symbol of the irreverent scientists of the Enlightenment. Creation once was something biblically pure and reserved for God but Victor ignores this and his work becomes a mockery of purity “I kept my workshop of filthy creation,” the oxymoron undermining the implied sanctity expressing the depravity of Victor’s ambition. The pervasive use of irony is evident in the juxta positioning of Victor denying his creation friendship and the companionship he seeks with Clerval “nothing could equal my delight on seeing Clerval,” he hypocritically denies the Monster the very thing he recognises as vital, friendship. This irony…

    • 1253 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Similarly, Scott’s depiction of 2019, L.A as is an indictment of humanities environmental degradation. In the opening panning shot of the city scape, a lifeless city bereft of nature is depicted. Its decaying humanistic foundations are seen to be falling beneath the destructive nature of unrestrained technological advancements.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mary Shelley’s 19th century gothic novel Frankenstein and Ridley Scott’s 1982 film Blade Runner both explore the fears relevant to their contexts. While these texts were composed in different time periods, a parallel that exists between these texts involves man’s testing the established moral and ideals of the time. Both texts deal with the possible ramifications of scientific advancement and the outcomes for society as a whole; this idea has proven to be a timeless concept. These texts convey cautionary messages regarding the moral consideration of the responsibilities of scientific endeavour, which are still relevant today. Each composer considers the implications of scientific progress in their contexts; Mary Shelley was strongly influenced by the ideals of Romanticism while also being exposed to the new theories of galvanism. Scott composed Blade Runner in a time of commercial enterprise and controversial experimentation, namely in-vitro fertilisation and cloning. The themes explored in these texts reflect the concerns of the time in which they were composed. Although both texts share concerns about the impact of science on morality, their representation of the possibilities of the inevitable societal change differ, emphasising that texts are shaped by context.…

    • 910 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    If society rejects the individual, the individual rejects society. This dichotomous relationship has an overarching impression that plays throughout both Blade Runner and Frankenstein in similar perspectives on how guardian/social responsibility, science and religion are thought of in society as well as how they impact individuals. The ways are shaped and moulded to their respective contexts to suit the contrasting opinions of the time is what creates different perspectives. Mary Shelley’s rejection of the Enlightenment period – scientific rationalism, and reliance on romantic ideals of God in nature highlight the social belief of religion and the natural human condition being held in higher regard than science. Though this contrasts to Ridley Scott’s commerce centred society which has a reliance on science to the point of complacency, the negative social results of unnatural – or scientific – human nature greatly impacts both human and robotic individuals. Although the perspectives on these values differ due to context, the overall theme of individual suffering and negative consequences from society by overreaching their human condition is the same.…

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Blade Runner and Frankenstein were composed at a time when society was questioning its humanity, or lack thereof, due to the technological advances of the time. Nature was soon realized to be fragile and vulnerable rather than resilient when natural rhythms were destroyed by ever increasing technology. In Shelley’s time science was working to improve on nature while some societies were fighting to hold onto the personal and emotional attributes which makes us truly human. These issues are clearly depicted within Frankenstein. ‘Learn from me, if not by my precepts, at least by my example, how dangerous is the acquirement of knowledge, and how much happier that man is who believes his native town to be the world, than he who aspires to become greater than his nature will allow.’ (Page 101)…

    • 915 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Nature plays an important role in Frankenstein, although to the reader familiar with romantic poetry, it may seem that nature is somewhat less important or less central than the role it plays, but from the novel’s opening, the importance of the reader getting a sense of physical place is established by situating the text within a particular environment, the qualities of which will both mirror and contradict the inner states of the main characters. Even from the very beginning of the novel, theme of nature is incorporated into Shelley’s work. “The icy wilderness in which the novel begins and ends is the barren land of isolation from human warmth and companionship, into which Walton foolishly sails and into which Frankenstein is inexorably led by the monster, whose inescapable destiny is it”. Later, on the morning after Victor gives life to his creation, he says, “Morning, dismal and wet . . . as if I sought to avoid the wretch whom I feared every turning of the street would present to my view”. When Victor is scared or upset the weather is nasty to complement the way that he is feeling in certain situations. And also Victor notes that the landscape of the Orkneys and that of his native country are quite distinct. His description of the Orkneys is cold, barren, gray, and rough. In contrast, he recalls Switzerland as colorful and lively and the landscape as teeming with blue lakes that reflect the…

    • 1122 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays