Preview

Comparing Count Dietrichstein's Argument With The Standards Of Music

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
276 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparing Count Dietrichstein's Argument With The Standards Of Music
The Eroica movie describes Beethoven as an easily riled person who considers himself equal to the nobility of Austria and Hungary. It gives no hints of mental disorders or long periods of internal emotional conflict, beyond his amorous designs for the Countess. Solomon’s account provides more detail. At the Lobkowitz’s palace, the movie presents Count Dietrichstein as a reactionary naysayer, a pompous noble, who lacks an appreciation for Beethoven’s genius . However, Dietrichstein’s view is consistent with the standards of music that were widely held at the time. Looking back, it’s easy to judge someone for not recognizing a musical genius; however, no modern analyst spent their life inside the musical ecosystem of the eighteenth century.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Mus 100 Study Guide

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages

    - Mozart: Invested much of his music with a degree of emotion expression unusual for his time. Never allowed emotion to dominate his art.…

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although his music thrived during the Classical Age: he made great mistakes during his career that would leave several people in disbelief. His music was composed and performed so gracefully that it is almost impossible to mention the words “mistake” and “Beethoven” in the same sentence. As a result of acquiring fame at a young age Beethoven became so egotistic that he began to believe himself to be incapable of making mistakes, along with the rest of the world. Before he became exceptionally great he had mentors who were older that him who tried to teach him ways to become even more successful, but Beethoven ignored them. His arrogance and assumed superiority left Beethoven making the very mistake he thought he was incapable of. After ignoring the advice of his elders Beethoven continued to composed a series of unrevised string quartets that he played and was talked about for being “scandalous and incomprehensible” (Bergamini 48). This was a setback for him because it lowered his self-esteem and it took him a while to compose string quartets again. His downfall demonstrated that being a genius in certain areas does not make you a genius in all areas. He later revised the pieces and they became successful works of art. But, Beethoven had to learn from his mistakes to realize that he was capable of making…

    • 1282 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the year of 1803 Beethoven composed his Third Symphony considered to be his first Romantic song named Eroica. It is said he dedicated his song to a person he admired named Napoleon, but when he found out Napoleon crowned himself emperor, he re-titled his work in anger. The beginning of Symphony Number Three, Eroica starts off with an allegro tempo which has a dramatic entrance that states, “I am here.” As the song continues I hear the beautiful…

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Out of the various approaches to analysing music have emerged throughout history I have chosen to review Immanuel Kant’s and Heinrich Schenker’s forms of analysis. The historical origin of a form of analysis is significant as the method and theory of these analytical approaches materialise from political and social circumstances of society of the time. For example, the discourse of period will manipulate the way a piece of music is discussed, and the understanding of discourse associated with a form of analysis will affect the way in which that approach is performed.…

    • 1983 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The classical era brought about a plethora of changes which drove western music into a brand new direction. Whereas the Renaissance period brought about enlightenment and the breaking away of traditional religious music, and the Baroque period exploding the provisions of artistic expression, the Classical period came back to square one and established systemized order. Although we no longer have the same verbosity of the Baroque era, the Classical period combined the elements of order and grace to achieve a more widespread method of entertainment and culture. Among these elements is the classical symphony, which was established by Joseph Haydn. Though many other genres existed at the time, it was the symphony that stood out and clearly represented the substance of the Classical period.…

    • 1679 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    These two composers had an element of their personal emotions in their music that served as creative inspiration. Haydn was said to have been a very pleasant and humorous, yet emotionally expressive person which was reflective in his upbeat and humorous compositions. Beethoven was said to have been very arrogant and had shown his mentor Haydn very little respect. Beethoven gradually became deaf and deeply depressed. In 1819, Beethoven’s deafness was total, yet he continued composing brilliant pieces of music. His scores have large amounts of corrections and changes; unfortunately his deafness forced him to rely on his memory of sound. As stated by Greenberg (2011): “We hear Haydn’s personality in his music: his joie de vivre, his emotional balance, and especially his marvelous sense of humor” (p 133). Ludwig Van Beethoven “an unhappy man of genius whose investment in the status quo-in the classical style-was minimal at best. Beethoven’s volcanic personal issues required an outlet, and that outlet was his music”…

    • 362 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Yet again, rain had come to shower on Beethoven’s life. Having a spiritual awakening and getting more involved with his successful writings, his past had agin creeped upon him. His nephew had tried to commit suicide and when people found out about the story, the boy was taken to his mother, not Beethoven, his legal guardian,but his mother. So this certainly raised some red flags for Beethoven.…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ludwig Van Beethoven was a German composer during the late 18th century to the early 19th century that through his rebellion, he opened a door to a new perspective in music. He has been regarded as one of the greatest composers of his time; but this couldn’t have been done if he hadn’t disobeyed the musical…

    • 508 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    * Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart – is silly, giggly, immature man. His extraordinary ability in music made Antonio Salieri jealous of him.…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The music has presented ever-changing throughout history. A variety of musicians has passed through each century leaving a lasting impression on the world. Each musician gave you a piece of him or her and how he or she saw the world of music and life through his or her eyes (Kamien, 2011). The write will elaborate on two well-known musicians of the 20th century, and then contrast and compare a 20th century musician song and a modern day song which both had aspects of controversial issues within each work.…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Being blind and unaware of where he is at and of their intentions there’s a great amount of tension and anticipation in finding out thier purpose. Motifs are musical phrases who are constantly repeated, and the constant repetition as well as the connotation of them music being dramatic is representation of the conflict the narrator feels as he is contrained to whims of the doctors. Its constant pounding is seen to depict a person’s struggle. Though classical music shouldn’t be seen as expressive as the blues to a race’s voice, it leads new imagery of tension and the roots of music, with internal struggle, for example the Fifth being inspired by the pain of loosing hearing and trying to escape the devil’s bearing. The cadences of Beethoven’s Fifth is long encumbered, associated and charged with force and energy! There the history of the music is naturally represented in his head playing at moments where he is at fear for how and why…

    • 1724 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    One of Wagner’s main arguments against Jewish artists and their music were that the musicians could only produce inferior derivations of pure European art they could never fully express themselves. Wagner seemingly held the belief that Jewish musicians were not able to fully comprehend modern European languages because they were “merely learnt” by Jewish artists and therefore “have remained…a foreign tongue” (Wagner, 7). Wagner’s impression was that Jewish artists works’ expressivity was limited due to the fact that, from Wagner’s perspective, Jewish artists didn’t have the capacity to fully understand the complexities of modern European languages and therefore lacked the ability to properly use these languages to convey profundity,…

    • 1599 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Vienna, being a cultural hub known for art and music, influenced many talented composers, performers, and artists of that time. To this day, the world carries on an appreciation for all of the talented people and their wonderful works that came from the “Great Age of…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Made in 1984, Amadeus the film focuses on Mozart’s life while representing the 18th century European Enlightenment through social class, politics and social history. Firstly, through the life of Mozart, we saw how difficult it was to survive in society. There was a complex hierarchical structure, which did not allow individuals to upgrade their social class. Therefor, even though Mozart was a brilliant and well-known artist, he lived a mediocre life and his life ended with a below average funeral. Secondly, throughout the movie, we saw how not only the Emperor Joseph II was influenced by Mozart’s music and his new cultural ideas but he also played a big role in the entertainment business. Joseph II, himself, played music and had intellect in different aspects, which can be explained by the cultural movement in Europe, Enlightenment. Mozart to compose an opera to portray the banned Marriage of Figaro play, the Emperor changed his mind about this forbidden play and allowed it in his national theater, in Vienna, because he simply wanted to depict his political empire as a culturally rich environment. Lastly, Amadeus was an excellent portrayal of the 18th century in Europe. It showed us visual aspects such as the clothing of members of different social classes or how people lived and interacted with each other. For example, Constanza was well aware of Mozart’s financial situation, which was a new ideology that women were implicated in economic matters. Also, the way Mozart acted around the King was very different from the way he was around his friends due to the fact that his musical intellect was greater then the King but out of respect he humbled himself. To conclude, Amadeus was a great depiction of the 18th century European Enlightenment in relation to cultural, political and social…

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Within any great musical composition there lies many instances of musical emotion that stirs the soul and creates within an individual, a sense of strong connections with both the piece and the composer. In this great masterpiece, Beethoven has penned such a work that offers an individual senses of both the darkness and lightness of musical emotion contained within several musical passages while maintaining the softness and power of light, melodic runs. Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony truly captures his musical style and features four movements, each with their own individual musical message. The emotional impact of this masterpiece can be felt in various ways as the listener releases the tensions of the world and embraces the genius of Beethoven’s…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays