top-rated free essay

Comparing and Contrasting two pieces of music.

By hashthedealer Sep 30, 2003 584 Words
In the essay I will compare and contrast "Gavotte" from the Classical Symphony by Prokofiev and the "Fantasy on Japanese Woodblocks" by Alan Hovhannes. I felt different about both pieces, but I did see a couple similarities. And that's what I'm going to explain about in this essay: both the differences and the similarities of the two pieces.

I'll start by explaining how I felt about both pieces. The "Gavotte" had a very calming affect on me. For a minute I felt as if I was in the wonderful jungle sitting and listening to a peaceful waterfall and finding peace to my soul. But it also made me tap my fingers and feet.

The second piece by the Hovhannes had awoken a totally different emotion in me, instead of feeling happy and peaceful I felt scared, uncertain, and had a feeling that something bad was about to happen. After a while I started to get annoyed of all the repeated high notes. But I still tapped my fingers according to the Marimba. Unfortunately I didn't have any intellectual or spiritual responses for both the pieces.

I will now explain the elements of Music to show how both the pieces where played differently and how they were played the same.

The beat of the "Gavotte" was not too fast or too slow, more or less in the middle. Although it did have a "jump" once in a while. The rhythm was pretty lazy and simple because it had quite a bit of repetition. But it isn't as obvious as the very repetitive rhythm of the second piece by Alan Hovhannes. The "Gavotte" had a skip and step melody , which means that it notes would jump back and forth on the scale. The harmony was thick and had a rich sound to it. It had a block harmony. The timbre would have a occasional jump once in a while. During most of the piece it had a relatively low level of dynamic contrast.

The "Fantasy on Japanese Woodblocks" was the strangest piece I've ever heard because it sounded like a mess, but at the same time it was very interesting. What made this piece so annoying was the continuous jump of pitches and the repetitive rhythm accompanied by a fast jumpy beat. This piece also had a skip and step melody. The harmony had a counter melody, which helped make the repetition of the piece slightly less obvious. The timbre was hard and rough. The notes were hard and disjointed most of the time, it never really came down softly.

After listening to both pieces, I can without doubt say that I liked the piece by Prokofiev better than the one by the Hovhannes, because I would rather be happy than scared, and I believe that I speak for everyone in my class when I say that. But nevertheless, both the pieces were excellent in their own way. Both pieces were thick and repetitive, although the piece by Hovhannes was a lot more repetitive than the piece by Prokofiev. But then again, the 'repetitioness' is what that created the theme for that piece.

It's no doubt that music from different parts of the world will be different, The "Gavotte" and the "Fantasy on Japanese Woodblocks" are a great example of music from different parts of the world. But each and every one of them will have unique beauty, something that will make it stand out from the crowd, after all, who would like to live in a world where everything is the same!

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • comparing and contrasting

    ... Comparing and Contrasting (quoted from Jim Stover, “Writing About Literature”) One of the best methods to help us clarify our thoughts about a character, an event, a poem, a story—nearly anything—is to compare and contrast. (To compare can mean to find similarities and differences. Coupled with contrast, however, to compare means...

    Read More
  • Comparing And Contrasting

    ...Comparing and contrasting Both utilise dramatic monologues to present inner workings of the characters there by allowing the reader an opportunity to witness the loss of humanity. Shakespeare uses the monologue in act 2 scene 1 to show how Macbeth is a person who can rationalise and reason but becomes dark and deceitful. He appears to be a ma...

    Read More
  • Comparing the Contrasting

    ...Comparing the Contrasting Written two centuries apart, “Young Goodman Brown” by Nathaniel Hawthorne and “Where Are You Going; Where Have You Been” by Joyce Carol Oates are two seemingly different stories. However, if looked at closely, several elements can be tied together. Each story has a similar point of view, but the story is told ...

    Read More
  • Comparing and Contrasting Two Suburbs

    ...is a residential suburb. This report will compare and contrast the aspects of people, housing and services. The populations of these suburbs differ greatly. According to official statistics, Maroubra has a larger population than Kogarah. Maroubra has approximately 26,500 people, whereas Kogarah has about 10,900 people. The majority of the popul...

    Read More
  • Interviewing two teachers,then comparing and contrasting them.

    ...Teachers have a very important but difficult job in our society. They are educators, counselors, coaches, friends, and sometimes even a parental figure all at the same time. This is a very heavy burden to carry while trying to educate our youth. The two teachers that were interviewed for this paper were Victoria Rivera, a sixth grade teacher fro...

    Read More
  • Comparing and Contrasting Two Analyses of Indian-European Interactions

    ...religious backgrounds, and social statuses. And of course, the Americas are huge continents. The new arrivals encountered all sorts of different geographies and Native American societies, which they had to adapt to. So as they settled, the ways that everyone found to survive and cope in the new environment were just as varied as the environments...

    Read More
  • Music

    ...devised a program that will help the managers, employees, and most importantly the store. Surveyed customers said that our store wasn’t keeping up with changing fashion as well as new trends. To better construe this issue I have set training sessions for our purchasing managers giving them an insight on what to look for when contacting supp...

    Read More
  • Comparing and Contrasting Two Soccer Players

    ...was the best player in the 2006, he has to much abilities for play soccer, he is a good shooter. Cristiano Ronaldo play in a team of England that is call Manchester United, he was nominated the best player in this year and he is so fast and also a good shooter. In them personalities i can say that Lionel Messi is more friendly than Cristiano,...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.