top-rated free essay

Comparing 2 Poems Denny

By Denny666 Mar 26, 2015 811 Words
Comparing “Refugee Blues” by W.H. Auden & “Disabled” by Wilfred Owen Denny Sofroniev
25.11.2013

Wilfred Owen and W.H. Auden are war poets and each of them is writing about a different war they experienced, but the final mood in both poems is loss. The two poems are an emotional reaction to the aftermath of war. The poem “Disabled” is about a soldier who went to war, believing he is helping his country, while “Refugee Blues” portrays the terrible situation of the German Jews during World War II. Although the poems have the same theme, physical and emotional loss, yet the poems are having many contrasts between each other. “Refugee Blues” is about a refugee family who have lost everything they own and are on the run to save their lives. They feel very isolated in a big city where they do not belong, but they cannot go home either. They feel great sadness, because the Germans took their passports. They feel alienated and helpless.

In the two poems “Refugee Blues” and “Disabled” the main similarity is that both of the poems have the same theme, which is the war in 1900. Unlike the theme of the poems, the category of the poems is completely different, for example “Refugee Blues” is about a conflict in the war and the category of “Disabled” is the suffering in the war. Other similarities in the two poems are that the poets use the same key technique -contrast.

In both of the poems there is contrast but in “Disabled” it is more than in “Refugee Blues”. Both of the poets also use other similar techniques e.g. metaphor, isolation, repetition and also rhyme. An example would be, in the poem “Disabled” the poet uses isolation for showing how the war can change people and isolate them afterwards, “All of them touch him like some queer disease.” This shows that after the war he was disabled and because of that nobody liked him anymore, so that is why everyone touched him like some queer disease, because he was disgusting, he was legless and his arms were cut off to the elbow and no-one wanted to have anything to do with him. He wasn’t the same guy that he was before and this changed his live forever.

This technique is similar to that in “Refugee Blues”, because there the man and “my dear” are isolated from the rest being refugees, they don’t have a home and there is no-one to take care of them. This is similar t the situation in “Disabled”, where nobody wants to go near the disabled man. A quotation to show the isolation in Refugee Blues can be “Yet there is no place for us, my dear, yet there is no place for us.”

However, the effect of isolation in the two poems is different. In “Disabled” the isolation is affecting the man after his return from the war disabled, that’s why no-one dared to go close to him. In “Refugee Blues” the isolation is different with the people being refugees, trying to escape the Germans. It is different from the poem “Disabled”, because they are not isolated from the people around them, but they are afraid of contacts, as they are afraid to talk to people. The isolation in Refugee Blues is because they want to be isolated from the rest of the people and try to run. The effect of isolation in “Refugee Blues” is also different from “Disable”, because the man has his child or wife and the disabled man is alone and doesn’t have anyone.

A difference in the key techniques of “Refugee Blues” and “Disabled” is personification. W.H. Auden uses personification in his poem for example “Saw the fish swimming as if they were free.” Unlike Wilfred Owen who doesn’t use any personification in his poem “Disabled.” W.H. Auden uses personification in his poem, presenting “the fish swimming as they were free”, suggesting that the Jews, even though they are very close to the fish, are still isolated. W.H. Auden also makes a comparison between the human race and the free flying birds. He adds emphasis by repeating the last line, which wants to show the refugees regret that the birds are more humane than the human race. The Jews are sad that the birds seam to have more rights than they do.

In conclusion both poems makes us thing about the devastation of war and its effect on the lives of millions of people around the world. They make us question human values as both the disabled man and the refugee Jews are made outcasts by a society, which pretend to have Christian values. It was these Christians who started these wars and created propaganda, which sent the young men to the front and later rejected him and the homeless refugees shutting them out of their society.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Poem Comparing

    ...Good evening Mr. Georges and fellow classmates, I have researched about 2 poems and made a comparison between the two. I’m here today to talk to you about them and see what you think at the end of the speech. The two poems I researched were (on the sea, author John Keats) and (sea fever, author John Masefield). as you can see from the title of...

    Read More
  • Comparing Poems

    ...“Comparing Poems & Short Story’s” Comparing short stories with poems can be an interesting way to learn literature. Things to look for are similarities in themes, the events that take place, the meaning of the poetry, and similar emotions or outcomes from what was read. The three pieces of literary work that will be discussed and co...

    Read More
  • Comparing Poems

    ...Todd Taravella 11/2/11 Mr. Olson Eng D29: Craft of Language Love is Vast It is amazing how poems can be so different yet so similar. When talking about a thing like love, it becomes less difficult to understand knowing how complicated the subject is. “Love” by Eavan Boland talks about how Eavan and her husband had been throug...

    Read More
  • Comparing poems

    ...www.engishbiz.co.uk  2003 Steve Campsall How to Read a Poem Poems can sometimes be difficult to get to grips with. But remember that the poet has tried hard to say much using few words. Part of the enjoyment of a poem is the work needed to engage with it and find out what the poet is saying. Don’t always expect to be able to ‘trans...

    Read More
  • Comparing Poems

    ...are two very similar poems that demand comparison, as Davis’ poem is in reply to Thomas’. From a reader’s point of view, these two poems seem to have a great deal of comparison than being dissimilar. Through an in depth analysis of these particular poems, “Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night” and “After a Time” have been proven t...

    Read More
  • Comparing poems Analysis

    ... Comparing ‘In Paris With You’ and ‘Quickdraw’ Working in pairs, look carefully at each poem. What similarities and differences can you see in the language, style and tone of the two poems? Five points have been made for you – your task is to find quotations (evidence) from each poem and to explain the effects of each techni...

    Read More
  • Essay Comparing Two Poems

    ...H/W Monday, 27 September 2010 Compare the similarities and differences between two Ballads, Charlotte Dymond and John Lomas. Charlotte Dymond and John Lomas, are two poems which share several techniques. They also, however are different in many ways. This essay will explore their similarities and their differences and explain reasons...

    Read More
  • Comparing Two Poems

    ...decided to work on two poems. The first one being ‘There is a garden in her face by Thomas Campion and the second ‘She walks in beauty' by George Gordon and Lord Byron. I will be deconstructing both poems and commenting on them with reference to the techniques used by the author when writing them. The first poem by Campion has a Sesta Rima ...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.