Compare & Contrast Essay - "Antigone" with "Romeo and Juliet"

Satisfactory Essays
Antigone - Prompt 1

In Antigone, Ismene must decide between the will of the gods and the will of the state, life and death. On one hand, if she follows the benevolent will of the gods and buries her brother, Polyneices, she will be put to a humiliating death. On the other hand, she can follow the will of Creon's traditional political authority and be forever put to shame by her demanding sister, Antigone. She is torn between two opposing forces, and whichever one she chooses, she must sacrifice something extremely important to her. By following the will of the gods, she must surrender her own short mortal life to live an eternity in heaven. If she doesn't bury Polyneices, she will die a shameful, pointless death, and her soul will wander forever in the Asphodel Fields of the Hades' underworld. This tremendously difficult decision that Ismene faces reminds me of a similar predicament that occurred in Shakespear's Romeo and Juliet. In this tragic novel, Romeo must make the difficult decision in which he must either happily stay with Juliet in the fear of being murdered, or stay exiled on Mantua and live a miserable, secluded lifestyle without his newlywed wife, Juliet. Unfaithfully leaving Juliet would be against the will of the gods, because in sacred marriage vows, the husband and wife are supposed to be together "til death do us part." This is similar to Antigone being bounded to the burial of Polyneices, because it is a human's right to have a proper burial, and deserting him would be similar to unsacred divorce. However, by staying with Juliet and defying the laws of the state, Romeo puts himself into a precarious situation in which his life is in danger. This aspect of the situation parallels Antigone's risk of being killed if she buries Polyneices. In the end, however, Romeo decides to devotingly stay with Juliet and embrace the loving will of the gods. Romeo's decision reflects that of Ismene's in the end, for they both disregard humanity's cruel orders and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Pre-AP English April 29, 2014 Romeo & Juliet: Compare and Contrast Essay Getting to read “Romeo and Juliet” was a great experience that will never be forgotten! A tragic story of young lovers with innocent hearts who attempt to fight their “star-crossed” fate. It was very interesting to see how different directors interpreted the play compared to the original by Shakespeare. Viewing the story from different angles helps you develop a better understanding of the story. In…

    • 1037 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A film Comparsion of Romeo and Juliet Whether on screen or on stage the romantic tragedy of Romeo and Juliet has been portrayed many times by different actors, directors, and writers but the themes always hold true to William Shakespeare's original play that was wrote in the late 1500’s. The two particular movies we watched in class were perfect examples of contrast, one was more traditional (Zefferilli’s 1968 version) while the other appealed to a new generation, (Baz Luhrmann’s 1996 version)…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Romeo and Juliet compare and contrast. I think almost everyone has heard the story of Romeo and Juliet. It is a very popular book, they have made movies and plays out of the book. Each very similar in ways and very different in other ways. Below I will be explaining all the ways they are similar and different in my opinion. The three movies we are compare and contrasting are in the years of 2014,1968,1996. My personal favorite out of the three would have to be the 1996 one with Leonardo DiCaprio…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Compare and Contrast “Romeo and Juliet” is a story about two star crossed lovers who meet by fate. This great piece of literature written, by William Shakespeare will be compared with Baz Lurman’s rendition of “Romeo and Juliet”. The movie missed some details from the play it also added some extra scenes but it still contained the right mood and scenes for it to be a “Romeo and Juliet” movie. A major similarity between the movie and play occurs in mood…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Romeo and Juliet Vs. Romeo+Juliet There are many ways to compare two of the versions of Romeo and Juliet, the 1968 version, and the 1996 version starring Leonardo DiCaprio. In both movies, the characters and setting have the same names, but are portrayed differently. Even though both versions of Romeo and Juliet take place in different centuries, the whole meaning of the story is still the same. After watching both the 1968 and the Leonardo DiCaprio versions of Romeo and Juliet, I have decided…

    • 604 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Romeo and Juliet, the dramatic love story everyone knows. Many times the play by William Shakespeare is compared to the movie produced by Baz Luhrman. Most always when movies are compared to the books, the books are better, but not quite in this case. Yes, the play is very good as well as the movie, but the play has its great parts, and its not so great parts as well. Just like the movie, it also has its good parts also many things that are the same in both the movie and play, but of course they…

    • 909 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Act two, Scene two, Juliet proclaims to Romeo, “A thousand times good night!” Romeo then responds to Juliet by saying, “A thousand times the worse to want thy light.” Both Romeo and Juliet clearly want the night more than the day in order to keep their passionate love a secret. This is seen when Romeo responds to Juliet, “A thousand times the worse to want thy light.” These lines, with the light and dark contrast, heighten the elements of danger and safety because the night is what protects their…

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    from the past and appreciate them in our modern and exponential times. However, there still are possibilities to cherish some of the archaic literature today that were written so long ago. Celebrated as one of the greatest dramas of all time, Romeo and Juliet depicts a tragedy of two lovers who come from feuding families. The play was first written in the 1500s by William Shakespeare. Almost four-hundred years later, the tragic play was made into a movie in 1968 by Franco Zeffirelli. There are…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Romeo and Juliet Expository Essay William Shakespeare is known as the literary genius behind the classic play Romeo and Juliet. However, his play is not as original as many people may think it is. Thirty years prior to Romeo and Juliet, the play Romeus and Juliet was written; Pyramus and Thisbe was written even earlier. In Romeo and Juliet, Shakespeare reveals to his audience that love is a powerful force that cannot be denied, which is also shown in the films West Side Story, Gnomeo and Juliet…

    • 1924 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Antigone Romeo and Juliet

    • 324 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Allusion between Romeo and Juliet and Antigone For years there have been discussions if in fact Shakespeare re-created material found in previous literature. Though, whether or not, he did Shakespeare created an effective allusion to Sophocles’ Antigone, the Greek tragedy. In Romeo and Juliet we see the love of two people, and the ones who pull them apart, then we see their final fate. In Atigone we see a lot of the same context which brings us to the main three ideas that make up the themes…

    • 324 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays