Compare and Contrast Plessy V. Ferguson and Brown V. Board of Education

Topics: United States, Supreme Court of the United States, United States Constitution Pages: 5 (1897 words) Published: August 8, 2010
Huiliang Yang
HIS 112
Professor McLeod
Compare and Contrast Plessy v. Ferguson and Brown v. Board of Education The Supreme Court has significant impact on molding the society of the United States, so does it play an important role in the process of the realization of equal protection on the right to education. From Plessy to Brown, every case that had milestone meaning indicated the evolution on the equal protection of the right to education, and also marked the progress of American civilization. However, there are different points between Plessy and Brown. Brown v. Board of Education was educational case of black race, but Plessy v. Ferguson is not it; the result of Plessy is isolation but equal, the Brown show us that isolation and unequal. In 1892, Plessy, Louisiana citizen sat in the white man compartment, head of train crew requirements him to the black compartment according to State Of Louisiana's rules, Plessy refused. Head of train crew is called police, hands him over convicts by the court. But Plessy thought that he should enjoy the society, politics, and economical equal power similarly with the American citizens, moreover this judge to be unfair. The federal court believed that the non-white race felt he is the third-rater, their subjective imagination rather than in the legal reason. If two races in the rights of citizens and the political rights aspect are the equality, a race will not be lower than another race in the social life aspect. But if a race lowers than another race in the social life aspect, the federal constitution cannot cause them to impose the identical level. Plessy v. Ferguson document the essence is the racial segregation whether to conform to the American constitution. The federal Supreme court has made the decision which is the isolation, but equal. It had the huge influence to American afterward politics, the economy and social life. Constitution protects the equality is in the political equality, is not in society's equality, although Plessy v. Ferguson is not involves the education question. But Brown v. Board of Education is model case of racial education, Mrs and Mr Brown require local school to accept their kids to study in the whites’ school, and they are refused so that to engage in legal proceedings. The similar case also occurs in other states, basically the black minor requests the court aid and the desegregation, causes them to obtain enters its study right in the community public school. Black children's school education has been neglected; white schools have more the curriculum rational, scientific and adequate funding for schools than blacks, the wages of their teachers higher than the wages of black school teachers. In short, isolation but equal, is the equality of slogan; in fact, it is inequality, even unequal on the surface. After Brown v. Board of Education has been proposed as a vignette of campus and educational discrimination, not only blacks suffered, but the white people are shame. Justice Harlan pointed out dealing with the rights and duties should not be considered the race whether the legislature or the judiciary. The surface is not differential treatment in the Louisiana legislation, in fact the blacks as low as nationals. If you adhere to the principles and spirit of the Constitution, this superior status is not sustainable (Plessy v. Ferguson, 1896). Brown case is one of most historic in the constitutional history of the United States Supreme Court, with the emergence of its judgments, the principle of isolation but equal is denied completely. Consequence has been not only limited to public schools, but also spread to all aspects of social life. Brown case caused major changes in American society; it was African-American civil rights movement as a starting point after World War II. Many things have to conclude one point, Court; this was same feature in these cases. Alexis de Tocqueville, 19th century French scholar visited the United States and...

References: Plessy v. Ferguson: Justice Harlan Dissents (1896), U.S. 537
Richard John Neuhaus (2009). The Pro-Life Movement as the Politics of the 1960s Retrieved from
Martyn Coppack (2008). Dennis Hopper & Peter Fonda in Easy Rider:
1960 's Counter-Culture And The Birth Of New Hollywood Retrieved from
Karine Walsh (2009). Honduras, Colombia, Cuba: the United States are Sticking with the Monroe Doctrine Retrieved from
Theodore Roszak (1995). The Making of a Counter Culture. University of California Press
David Ettinger (1997). The UN of the “Four policemen”. Retrieve from
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Plessy v Ferguson vs. Brown v Board of Education of Topeka Kansas Essay
  • Brown V. Board of Education Essay
  • Brown V. Board of Education Research Paper
  • Brown V. Board of Education Essay
  • Essay about Brown V. Board of Education
  • Brown V. Board of Education Essay
  • Brown V. Board of Education Essay
  • Brown v. Board of Education Research Paper

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free