top-rated free essay

Compare and Contrast Karl Marx

Oct 08, 1999 575 Words
Compare Karl Marx and Max Weber
During the nineteenth century, Karl Marx and Max Weber were two of the most influential sociologists. Both of them tried to explain social change having place in a society at that time. Their view on this from one hand is very different, but on the other it had a lot of similarities. Weber had argued that Marx was too narrow in his views. He felt that Marx was only concerned with the economic issues and believed that that issue is a central force that changed the society. Weber, on the other hand, tried to look at the macro-sociological phenomenon in his explanation. Weber felt that there is just more than one explanation about causes of change. Marx's perspective was not based on the conflict of ideas, but rather on the conflict of classes. This conflict is the results of a new mode of production. According to Marx, history would consist of epochs of modes of production. He states that these modes of production are: primitive communism, slave society, feudalism, capitalism, and then socialism and communism. The changes accompany the transition from one epoch to another. In the late nineteenth century labor has become a commodity to the merchants, and the formation of a new mode of production has risen which gave rise to a capitalist society. There is a new class distinction between the laborer and those who owned the means of production.

Max Weber was opposed to Marx and believed that his theory was an oversimplification of history. He thought Marx's view of history was too focused on economics and was not considering the role of ideas and values as causes. Weber felt that scientific, historical, and philosophical causation was so connected with economic development that they can not be considered separately as causes of change in the society. He used the relationship between society and the individual to explain the causes of change in terms of social development. Weber also thought there was a link between capitalism and the Protestant work ethic. Specifically he looked at Calvinism. Calvinism was a simple way of life in which you were to do good for others. The way into heaven was to do the greatest good for the greatest number of people. Work was done not for one's own personal gain, but for the sake of god. Weber found that in areas where Calvinism was the highest is where capitalism rose first, and no other religion resulted in the rise of capitalism. Marx was concerned with the structure of society rather than the meaning. He thought that it is the class structure which gave power to the classes. This term of class is used differently between Marx and Weber. For Marx the causes of change was the result of conflict between the two classes. Weber, on the other hand, felt that once feudalism had been abolished so was the class system. Class in feudal era was determined by one's blood line. If one were a serf then one's son or daughter would be born into the same class status. The same would hold true for any other social status. The next in line for the throne of the king is his first born son. With change this distinct line between classes vanished. They both may have different reasons as to causes of change, but they both agree as to what society has become.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Compare and contrast Marx and Weber

    ...During the nineteenth century, Karl Marx and Max Weber were two of the most influential sociologist. Both their views on the rise of capitalism have various similarities and differences. They believe that capitalism is relatively new to the modern world. Their views differ on the rise of capitalism. Regardless of Marx and Weber's differences, bo...

    Read More
  • Compare And Contrast Hyper And Karl Marx

    ...Zach Dykstra Core 145 Dr. Mark McCarthy, Professor 29 March, 2017 Poverty in the eyes of Karl Marx and Abraham Kuyper Karl Marx and Abraham Kuyper have an issue with how society has allowed poverty and class separation to exist throughout history. Kuyper, coming from a Christian belief, believes that sin is the ultimate root of the problem and ...

    Read More
  • Karl Marx

    ...Karl Marx * NAME: Karl Marx * OCCUPATION: Historian, Economist, Journalist * BIRTH DATE: May 05, 1818 * DEATH DATE: March 14, 1883 * EDUCATION: University of Bonn, University of Berlin * PLACE OF BIRTH: Trier, Germany * PLACE OF DEATH: London, England * Full Name: Karl Heinrich Marx Best Known For Germ...

    Read More
  • Compare and Contrast Marx and Weber’s Analyses of the Development of Capitalism

    ...Compare and contrast Marx and Weber’s analyses of the development of capitalism Capitalism is defined as ‘An economic and political system in which a country's trade and industry are controlled by private owners for profit.’ It is based on the division between two classes, one of which owns the labour of the other. Not only do the upper...

    Read More
  • Karl Marx and Andrew Carnegie Compare and Contrast

    ...Expository Essay #2 Compare and Contrast Essay: During the nineteenth century, Karl Marx and Andrew Carnegie had definite opinions about the affects of industrialization on society. A greater understanding of their views on history and humanity can be gained by comparing and contrasting two written artifacts: The Communist Manifesto and “...

    Read More
  • History: Sociology and Karl Marx

    ...Sociology is the study of people within a society. Three important Modernist Thinkers; Karl Marx, Emile Durkheim, and Max Weber are the three important figures in sociology. During the time of the modernist thinkers, they played a role in sociology thinking. This paper will explore the importance on why these three figures are considered moderni...

    Read More
  • Animal Farm: a Compare and Contrast on Karl Marx Communist Manifesto

    ...Topic: Research the life of Karl Marx. What were the fundamentals of his Communist Manifesto and how do they compare to the ideas expressed by Old Major in Animal Farm. Animal Farm is a novella written by George Orwell in 1945. This particular story by George Orwell reflects on the events leading up to and during Stalin era in R...

    Read More
  • Compare and Contrast Marx and Weber's Analyses of the Develoopment of Capitalism Essay Example

    ...Both Karl Marx and Max Weber have contributed substantially in our understanding of how capitalism has flourished in some parts of the world and not in others, however “Weber sought to show that the path of causation often ran in the reverse direction” to Marx. In other words, Marx’s macro theory (focus on the world, and not individuals) ...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.