Preview

Compare And Contrast Journey's End And Strange Meeting By Susan Hill

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
446 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare And Contrast Journey's End And Strange Meeting By Susan Hill
Compare and contrast Sheriff’s and Hill’s presentations of the effect o the experiences of work in Journey’s End and Strange Meetings.

Strange Meeting by Susan Hill and Journey’s End by R.C. Sheriff both are books which recover the encounter that occurred during the time of World War one .Journey’s End much like strange meeting, goes in detail about the experiences of war and how characters from both books are affected. For example, Both Stanhope and Hilliard both have a different feeling towards home as of how the war has psychically and mentally changed them. CRiTiC During the time of World war one conditions were treacherous, within the start of Journey’s End we are given a description of the dugout, which a whole number of soldiers were expected to live in. The thought of this is very claustrophobic and probably was just left the way it was as soldiers expected to be home by Christmas 1914 which wasn’t the case of course. Even though within the dugout it was very basic and just provided for mandatory needs such as sleeping and eating, the description of the scene does include how the men “pin to the wall of girls in flimsy costumes” this shows they still had a sense
…show more content…
Before the war, almost every man would have no intention to kill another human for no utter reason but, the war teaches this and encourages it. This is also a reason why Wilfred Owen senses to lose touch in his faith Christianity which we know he was a committed member of before the war. This not as of ground beliefs but, how the vicar of a church encourages killing. The question is doesn’t Christianity teach “though shall not kill”? Additionally, many soldiers had ways of coping. Stanhope’s idea was by being constantly drunk, simply because of the fact that he didn’t want to be conscious of what is going around him. Whereas Trotter would comforts eat to keep his mind of his

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Relationships between men, and the strengthening of bonds, is incredibly important in war literature. This is because men's relationships strengthen greatly during stressful situations and war is the most stressful situation a man can be in. The First World War was a brutal war which killed millions of men and is the main theme of Journey's End and Regeneration. Journey's End is a play set wholly in an officer's dugout during the First World War, while Regeneration focuses on mental patients living in mental-asylum Craiglockhart, during the First World War.…

    • 1137 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The life in the trenches were horrible. There was all sorts of pest living in the trenches including rats, lice, and frogs. Soldiers slept in dug outs. The trenches were dirty and due to the weather they would be filled with water and they also became muddy. Soldiers would usually be covered almost up to their ankles because of the mud. There was 200,000 men dead. Over time the rats would eat the corpses. The smell was revolting. The dead bodies plus the clogging of toilets was mainly why the smell was so strong. The soldiers would get trench foot. Which was by insanitation and cold conditions that they would go through. As shown in document 4, in the image it shows the soldiers are struggling with trench…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    War turns men and soldiers into animals. Animals that hurt people and are out to kill the innocent. “They put him on a prison ship and he got sick and died in three weeks.” (Collier and Collier 166). The British put Tim’s friend, Jeremiah Sanford, on a prison ship after capturing him. Jerry was only ten years old and could not cause any harm to the British. The war made the men take an innocent young boy’s life and that is gruesome. Sam’s death, Mr. Meeker’s death, and Ned’s death were all unnecessary to the war. “Ned’s head jumped off his body and popped into the air.” (Collier and Collier 145). This text shows that this death was unnecessary since Ned did not harm or bother the British. The British did not need to decapitate Ned, they did this for no reason. The war was so gruesome and disgusted so many…

    • 758 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    It could be argued that the realistic way the horrors of life in a First World War trench are depicted in "Journey's End" leads us to feel sympathy for all the soldiers, including Hibbert, an officer in the company led by Stanhope. We see how soldiers had to deal with physical hardships like rationed food, rats, extreme discomfort and the emotional traumas of terror and almost inevitable death.…

    • 1318 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Life in a World War One trench would have been far more hellish than any other experience in previous times. In those days, little thought would have been given to the men fighting the battles; instead it went into the battle plans. In theory, these battle plans would have been successful, but with variables such as troop morale, battlefield conditions, weather, and enemy advances, in practice they had a high failure rate. No commander or general could have accurately planned an attack without taking into account the battle conditions, and allowing leeway for an enemy advance. Unfortunately, the men in commanding positions rarely (if at all) saw the actual conditions of fighting, and this resulted in the loss of many lives. An author by the name of Paul Fussell wrote a chapter in his book 'The Great War and Modern Memory' entitled 'The Troglodyte World'. This refers to the real life experiences of soldiers living and fighting in the trenches, and uses various primary sources to validate his findings.…

    • 646 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Here in the trenches condition are very terrible. Things I had seen is unbearable, these trenches are overflowed with water and things I have to do to live in these conditions. About the overflow as it rains, us standing in these large puddle. Your socks will be completely wet, which is a uncomfortable feeling. In order to survive I had to find a dead man socks to use for my own. We also went several weeks not showering because during these conditions they needed a excessive amount of soldier to fight. Having twenty guys crowded on top of you, these trenches are very narrow only enough to have bit of room for the person next to you. This made diseases to easily spread such as influenza, fever, typhoid, and malaria. One of my buddies I share a spot within the trenche just died, right in front of me.…

    • 343 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the American Revolution Soldiers weren’t the only ones who were at high risk of death. For example in the small town of Redding, Connecticut there was a variety of different opinions on war. Unlike like most happy stories and fairytales there was no good side, there might have been a good cause but no side was considered innocent. The Patriots were killing someone for a crime they did or looked like they were committing even if they were fighting for their side. The British were exaggerating situations to get a chance to execute a fellow loyalist or Patriot. In the book My Brother Sam is Dead by, James Lincoln Collier and Christopher Collier,…

    • 371 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During World War I warfare was carried out using one the most familiar elements of modern warfare and soldiers were forced to live in the extremely horrible living conditions of The Trenches. A trench warfare is a kind of fight where each side digs deep trenches down in the ground to defend themselves against the enemy. The trenches of World War 1 stretched for miles in order to enable one side to get the upper hand on the other. The trenches were dug by soldiers themselves they would make the trenches by digging directly down into the ground which speeded up the digging process , but at the same time left the soldiers exposed to be fired on by the enemy as they dug. These trenches were sometimes even formed in places where you couldn’t break…

    • 163 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Explore the ways in which the effects of war on the individual are presented in ‘Journey’s End’.…

    • 1528 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    War is a brutal and challenging place where people are forced to cause grief and devastation to others in order to look after their lifestyle. During the book, the characters face the brutal war causing them to make quick decisions. The group was forced to take action with the ride on mower incident that caused an explosion and led to the possible death of the three enemy soldiers. Killing the soldiers meant that the group would be safe. Although the group felt “guilty and ashamed” to take action and injure or possibly kill others for their own safety, they knew they had to do it in order to survive. The group harmed the soldiers to help themselves and in order to do this the group had to acknowledge that “this is war and normal rules don’t apply.” The group was confronted with the morality of this situation where they destroyed others in order to remain safe and protected.…

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Life During The Great War

    • 2708 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Soldiers “buried themselves”, and digged trenches. This will be the place where they are going to live for the rest of the war. Life in the trenches was miserable, with fleas, rats, mud, food shortages, dead soldiers and enemies. The living conditions were really bad, soldiers had nothing, they were not even able to shower or change their clothes. They were wearing the same clothes for months.…

    • 2708 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    And the trenches; oh, the trenches. We stay in the trenches for up to a week. I’ll describe what the trenches are like; it smells like dirt, urine, and sweaty men, it's loud because of all the shells that are flying everywhere and it's extremely dirty. Along with those, there are also many dangers from staying in the trenches. For example, shell shock. Shell shock is what happens when a soldier breaks down under the stress of being in war. I've seen it occur. But shell shock isn’t the only danger that the trenches bring. There’s also lice and trench…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wilfred Owen uses a varied amount of diction to describe war and its effects on people. In the first stanza he uses a good choice if diction to fully describe the condition of the soldiers, for example ‘bent double’, ‘drunk with fatigue; and ‘coughing like hags’. In the third stanza Owen chooses even stronger, more violent language, to portray the horrors of war. He uses words like ‘smothering dreams’, ‘withering’, ‘gargling’, ‘hanging’ and ‘incurable sores’.…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wilfred Owen

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Christian idea of God is ignored and a more pagan view of nature and life…

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    on the Western Front were actually kept in the trenches. Besides all the injuries, diseases were a heavy toll.…

    • 1563 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays