Preview

Compare And Contrast Durkheim And Max Weber Religion

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
643 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare And Contrast Durkheim And Max Weber Religion
One of the most deeply felt, powerful and influential forces in today’s society is Religion. Religion in many societies shapes relationships, communities and even politics. Many turn to religion and believing in a godly being when in need of direction, strength and simply needing someone to vent to. Believing in a God during a difficult time can give individuals the hope and inner strength needed to make it through whatever situation they might be enduring. Religious faith also gives some people peace of mind when contemplating death, and also believing in the existence of an afterlife. A perpetuity with one’s savior seems to be a far greater privilege than life on earth, or anything one could theorize. Both Max Weber and Emile Durkheim created studies of religion to grasp a better understanding of religion. …show more content…
He is the one that I can go to who will not judge me even if I have failed him. My God is someone who gives endless blessings even when his children are undeserving of them. Weber viewed Christianity as “a salvation religion that claims people can be “saved” when they convert to certain beliefs and moral codes. In Christianity, the idea of “sin” and its atonement by God's grace plays a fundamental role. Unlike the Eastern religions' passive approach, salvation religions like Christianity are active, demanding continuous struggles against sin and the negative aspects of society” (Cliff Notes: Sociological Theories of Religion). In my opinion, the sociological study of religion has no necessary implication from one’s religious faith because when you believe in someone so power as a God, you only view your relationship based off of your encounters and the book of the bible. Outside opinions and theories such as Emilie Durkheim and Max Weber’s have no standing or impact on my relationship or view of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    From the beginning of the novel to the very last page, religion seems to be an anchor that keeps everyone grounded. Whenever everyone hits a rough patch or are faced with obstacles that seems out of reach, religion becomes the biggest guidance and support they have. Everyone within the novel is religiously attending church and I strongly believe it’s the only place of outlet for them, whether it’s for difficult times or happy moments. Expression through worship establishes a sense of morality as everyone maintains religion as a guideline for life. It’s amazing how everyone seems to sin like no other but still, on a Sunday morning they’re in their finest dresses and suits, singing, dancing, and praising the lord. I feel the reason everyone is so devoted is because they are aware of their wrong doings but instead of asking for forgiveness, they’re turning to religion to reinforce values and morals to prevent them from committing the same sins in the future. Although it seems to be by choice to commit the sins which occurs regardless, religion seems to be used as a concealment of the sins that one has committed. The hopes or thoughts of attending church might give a gratifying feeling as one hopes that they will be forgiven for their sins even if the extent of the sin is far beyond being forgiven. With that being said, I also thing religion is prevalent within the novel because everyone attending church brings everyone…

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rel134Elements Paper

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages

    According to the linguistic roots of the term religion re-, means “again” and lig-, means “join” or “connect”. The word religion proposes the joining of the human world to the sacred world (Molloy, 2010). In my personal point of view religion is very important because it allows us to believe that there is a God who loves us and wants us to be happy. There are different types of religions and none of them are wrong if they lead people to a life of love, joy, compassion, and service. The question of why religions exist is evidently because it serves as human needs (Molloy, 2010). One of the first needs of humans is having a meaning when it comes to dealing with our mortality. It is very common that as individuals we try to look for a purpose of why different situations happen in life especially when we have no control over them. The religion we belong to can give us comfort to some level in our life. There are some elements known to involve a religion regardless of which one it is which will be discussed in this paper. Also this paper will mention the relationships with the divine, sacred time, sacred space or the natural world, and the relationship with each other.…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Week 1 Sociology Notes

    • 1548 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Summarize Max Weber’s ideas about religion, rather than economics, being the central force in social change.…

    • 1548 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As Daniel Bell states, religion is a method to deal with the fear of death. (Bell 224) The fear of death rather arises through the political conflicts; especially in terms of the Cold War since it claimed the lifes of thousands of people. Religion normally offers empathy for those suffering and palliative care supports the believer on his death-bed. During the last decade the fear of death has increased because the individual, rather than the mass, is offended by everyday disputes. The only solution political religion offers to this problem is to “emphasiz[e] the omnipotence of a movement” as Daniel Bell claims. (Bell 225) Therefore, confronting the current political conflict or movement rather than suppressing it offers a solution to deal with…

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Theories surrounding the understanding and meaning of death tend to focus on either religion or medicine. Religious attitudes to death are more abstract, while the medical world attempts to separate the living from the dead and the ill from the healthy, providing rationality in the face of demise (Seale 1998, p. 75). Seale (1998, p. 76) describes religion as a means of relieving death anxiety for the living; explaining that those who believe in an afterlife have a less dramatic relationship with death. Harding, Flannelly, Weaver and Costa (2005, p. 253) substantiate this idea with findings that show significantly less death anxiety and considerably more death acceptance amongst religious groups. Moreover Freud (cited in Koenig, 2001, p. 98) sates that “only religion can give meaning to life”. In contrast Seale (1998, p. 75) explains the medicinal outlook on death in two distinct veins, the first being the “best hope” for those who are suffering and are close to death and the second being a “reasonable account” for why all people must die. In addition Seale (1998, p. 77) places medicine and death in direct opposition stating that medicine seeks to cure the “natural death”. Contrastingly, Zola (2011, p. 487) states that the role of medicine within death is not concerned with saving lives, but instead with the controlling of terminally ill or elderly patients. This thought is ripe throughout work surrounding palliative care (see Conrad 1992), however some scholars see the implementation of medical care as simply providing support for those on the verge of passing (Zimmerman & Rodin, 2004, p. 122). In summary, both religious and medicinal approaches to understanding death by the living are still both extremely popular, however the array of works which document…

    • 1519 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In this analysis paper I will talk about incorporating God throughout everyday life, whether it be through materialistic things or one’s own self perception of how it is to live and pattern after Godly ways . In “A World Split Apart,” Alexander Solzhenitsyn infers that there is a higher power than man; a lack of spirituality can harm ones afterlife. Through a higher power all things are possible he says, “If, as claimed by humanism, man were born only to be happy, he would not be born to die. Since his body is doomed to death, his task on earth evidently must be more spiritual: not a total engrossment in everyday life, not the search for the best ways to obtain material goods and then their carefree consumption.” Whereas in “A Voice from Russia’s Past,” by Jack Fruchtman Jr. he simply argues that Solzhenitsyn is speaking from Slavophiles point of view, which stands as a group of Russian philologists and nationalists interested in the origins of the Russian language. Fruchtman also stated that Solzhenitsyn echoed this theme at Harvard when he noted that the philosophical foundation of the West has historically rested on a “rationalistic humanism,” by which he meant “the proclaimed and enforced autonomy of man from any higher force above him. (Fruchtman 44)” My last and final source will come from “Presenting Humanism” by Jende Huang. Huang speaks from a humanist view and states that our society has been so socialized to accept the idea that believing in God is something that is "good," and even for a religious liberal, there may exist, an unconscious desire to hold onto that. The realization that you don 't need a god to live your life is a difficult one and one that cannot be easily acknowledged.…

    • 1651 Words
    • 48 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Weber used comparative sociology to understand variance in society. He studied the difference in cultures that explained the different social orderings that emerged. From his work ‘A Protestant Ethic’, Weber acknowledges that religion can be a cause for societal change and a social structure imbued with religious influences and values can in turn influence the individual’s that inhabit such a society. For example Weber takes the Calvinist and Lutheran faiths and suggests that the are the mother and father of modern capitalism. With such strong beliefs in the Calvinist faith such as predestination (that those chosen for salvation were chosen before birth) Weber suggested this was a cause for uneasiness and indifference amongst the Calvinist as everyone wanted salvation. To acquire this they would strive to be worldly successful, in the belief that the successful would surely be those amongst the salvaged.Calvinists turned to labour to achieve success. Lutheranism beliefs stated that there was a calling in life and this calling was what the believer devoted their lives to, this calling for many was the life of labour. Weber suggested that these beliefs were the beginnings of a labour filled life that was the beginning of capitalism. According to Weber, religion’s strong foothold in society necessitated the search for success and salvation. The structure of society at the time with its essential features such as religion and its belief system had large affects for those individuals who occupied it such as the Calvinists and Lutherans. By using his sociological imagination Weber demonstrated the affect social structure had on the personal experiences of the…

    • 1726 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Religion defines people by giving guidelines, which they should follow, while living their lives. Within religion there are two different types of people, the pretenders and the “true” followers. Pretenders are people that call upon God only when needed, unlike those who truly follow their religion on a serious basis. A “true” believer is one who full-heartedly worships the spirit of God and puts God into their daily routines. These people influence others as their actions help to shape society into what it is to become. As times continue to change, religious views still have great affects on multiple societies.…

    • 1230 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    As mortal human beings, we all have personal ideologies that drive us to be the person we wish to be and to believe in the things of which we find to be true. A personal ideology is described as, “one’s philosophy of how life should be lived and what forces impact human living.” Oftentimes, people will turn to religion to provide their lives with hope and meaning towards morals and what happens after death. Personal ideologies such as religion have a major effect on modern day society because religion is something that effects everyone differently, and this can either bring people closer together or drive them apart.…

    • 527 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Comparative Religion

    • 899 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Religion is a common set of belief held by different individuals available within a society. Religion concerns itself with purpose, cause, and nature considered for the creation of a superhuman agency fitted with several moral codes. The codes provide guidance on how humans should conduct themselves throughout their life time. Religious beliefs are known to fall into a pattern of 8 different elements such as the belief system, community, central myths, rituals, an ethical system, experiences of the emotions, expressing religion in a material manner, and the ability of being sacred (Jacobs, 2005).…

    • 899 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Durkheim believed that religion was society and it was "God." That is, Durkheim believed that religion affected the establishment of society to such a degree that the two were inseparable. Durkheim thought society originated with religion. He also believed that religion was healthy for the society and that it helped people to become part of the society.…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to the textbook, direct observation is known as ethnography and ethnography is a qualitative research method for studying the way of life of a group of people by close observation of them over a relatively long period of time (63). Basically, ethnographic research is understanding humans and why they do what they do. We usually use ethnographic research when we want to understand people in the way they truly live. It provides a perception into human behavior. In addition, ethnographers can understand a problem from the point of view of the person by being up-close. I believe ethnographic research is an excellent research tool and should be used more on education. The majority of high school students aren’t ready for college. Ethnographic research provides a much more accurate picture than surveys (64). This could be the key for solving the problem in the education system. The future depends on…

    • 418 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A religion can be seen as a unified system of beliefs and practices which are relative to sacred things and beliefs (Giddens 1972, p.224). It can shape ones thoughts and feelings and gives people a sense of hope and something to believe in. All three main sociologist writers Karl Marx, Max Weber and Emile Durkheim offer different perspectives on religion and how important it is to society. Some of the theorists chose to have a positive view whilst others argue the unimportance of religion. This essay attempts to discover which theorist has the most accurate perspective of religion in modern times. This is done by firstly explaining the basic ideas regarding to religion put forward by Marx, Weber and Durkheim. Then both Marx's and Durkheim's thought will be compared and contrasted in order to determine the differences and similarities between their ideas. Finally, it will be explained which one of the theorists views and ideas are the most relevant to contemporary times and why.…

    • 1387 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In a society that offers no hope of happiness or release from struggle and suffering, people quite naturally begin to place their hopes elsewhere. They respond to their condition by hoping for something that lies outside the conditions and constraints they cannot control or influence. Religion becomes some kind of hope for rescue from life. Religion responds by offering either internalization to a spiritual realm or an external hope of a better world and a better life beyond the pale of death.…

    • 4035 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Emile Durkheim, famous French sociologist and philosopher, spent a lot of his years trying to identify why religion was so important to people around the world. After studying religion for many years, he published his first book on the subject which was titled The Elementary Forms of Religious Life. The book was written with the sole purpose of analyzing the concept of religion and why it is such a huge social phenomenon which affects the life of millions of people around the world every day. The fundamental reason behind why Durkheim decided to write a book was so that he could identify where religion originated from and what its functions are in the society. He was of the opinion that religion was a source of fellowship and unanimity. He also wanted to study different religions around the world which lie in different cultures. The reason why he wanted to do was because he aimed to identify how each religion differed from the other and if possible, what aspects or elements of religion had consistency with each other. His primary aim, therefore, was to establish certain empirical data over how some social aspects of religion are common throughout the world and how they even go so far as to surpass the concept of an Almighty God.…

    • 1981 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays