Compare and Contrast Cyrano de Bergerac and the Movie Roxanne

Topics: Cyrano de Bergerac, Steve Martin, Roxanne Pages: 2 (834 words) Published: March 29, 2005
Isn't it easier to accept the idea that a main character would be engaged in a fist fight, rather than a sword fight? Aren't fire fighters, as characters, more believable than a bunch of olden day French cadets? I certainly think so. To me it is just more real to have the setting of a story in modern times and in the United States. Rostand's Cyrano De Bergerac is written about a time that no one alive now has experienced. There is the same plot idea that an ugly man wants the pretty girl, but she is too busy being infatuated with the pretty boy to notice the intellect of the man she truly comes to love. Steve Martin's Roxanne and Rostand's Cyrano De Bergerac are similar in the sense that they both appeal to the people of the same time period in which each one was written and performed.

Ever been to Paris, France in the year 1640? No? Well neither have I, but I have been residing in the United States in modern times. I related more to this version of Cyrano de Bergerac because the settings are familiar. In the original version there is a sword fight at a theater. Well for one, most people nowadays have the mind set that sword fights are for the aristocrats and Romeo and Juliet. Roxanne has fist fights and many events happen in a bar. I've seen fist fights and I have been in a bar and grill which is why I can relate to Roxanne. Another modern twist to Roxanne is the occupations of the characters. The fire fighters are an amazing parallel to the cadets. In some ways the change from the cadets to the firemen is a parody. The cadets are steadfast men who are ready to fight, but the firemen are a bunch of goofy adults that really have no clue to what they are doing. Roxanne's astronomer hobby and job gives her the air of being intelligent and intellectual just like Rostand's Roxanne has. Le Bret and Raganeau morphed into the more modern character, Dixie. She takes on the role of being Charlie Bales' confident and most trusted friend. In this story, Dixie plays a...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Cyrano de Bergerac Essay

    ...Who is Cyrano in the play Cyrano de Bergerac? In Cyrano de Bergerac by Edmond Rostand, Cyrano is a man who has a big sized nose, and he is in love with a beautiful woman named Roxane, but she is in love with a handsome man named Christian. All throughout the play Cyrano tries to get Roxane to love him for his personality, not his looks. Cyrano’s personality is brave, romantic, and witty. Cyrano’s trait is brave. An example of Cyrano being brave is when he almost gets shot for sending letter to Roxane, and his friend tells him, “Don’t you think it’s going a little too far to risk your life every day to send a letter?”(4.1) This proves that Cyrano is daring for risking his life to send letters to Roxane. It also proves that he cares about Roxane to send letters to her, even though he is risking his life while doing so. Another example of Cyrano being brave is when he fights one hundred men against himself. This indicates he is heroic because he is not scared to fight the men. It shows he is courageous enough to go up against them. In conclusion, Cyrano is fearless because he is not scared to risk his life, or fight one hundred people. Cyrano’s persona is romantic. For example, Cyrano is romantic when he is talking to Roxane underneath the balcony and he says, “I could no more...

    Read More
    520 Words 3 Pages
  • Honor Is Cyrano de Bergerac Essay

    ...Honor in Cyrano de Bergerac People in today’s society have many different aspects about their character that make them who they are. Positive character traits can be found in people around the globe and in the characters that many read about in books. Edmond Rostand presents the character Cyrano in the play Cyrano de Bergerac with a many positive traits that make him a very relatable character. Cyrano lives his life based on a strict code of honor through his actions. A code of honor can be seen in the way Cyrano acts towards himself. His pride shows this many times throughout the play. One example of this is when Cyrano fights Valvert over his own nose whilst at the play in the beginning of the novel. This shows that he respects himself and does not feel as though others should be able to point out his flaws. His own integrity also reveals his honor. When Cyrano talks with de Guiche about changing his poetry so they can sell it he says, “Impossible, sir; my blood curdles at the thought of having a single comma changed” (87). This scene reveals that Cyrano cannot be so easily morally corrupted because he expresses himself through his own works. Honor is also revealed in his altruism. The fact that Cyrano does not want to date Roxane, even after Christian dies, reveals this....

    Read More
    696 Words 3 Pages
  • Cyrano de Bergerac Paper

    ...This summer reading book of Cyrano de Bergerac is about romances, war, hate, and etc. After reading this book, my favorite part of the book in the play, was in act three, Roxane's Kiss form scene V-XIV. I pick this scene because, it's how Christian love Roxane and Cyrano is in the middle of everything. For example Roxane is related to Cyrano and Cyrano know Christian by being in with the Gascon Cadets. With all that Cyrano have to find a way for Christian to talk to Roxane in the way Cyrano does in the love letter's. In the beginning of scene V Roxane come up Christian to talk to him. Christian was nervous and didn't know what to say but I love you over and over. I like this part because Christian did not know what to say to her like Cyrano do of how he express his love in sentence and in the delightful ways like Roxane would had thought like as in the letter's. Then later on in the scene Christian had know that he had made a mistake of what he said to Roxane and that she wasn't very happy about it. So when Cyrano had heard what happen from Christian he had to came up with a plan. So after coming up with a quick and smart plan they both went to Roxane's house under the balcony. I also like this scene because Cyrano talk to Roxane for Christian in the night where he can not be seen. So after talking so long...

    Read More
    709 Words 3 Pages
  • Cyrano de Bergerac Essay

    ...Robbie Bradshaw English 10 Honors Ms. Mungo June 8th, 2012 Is Cyrano de Bergerac a tragic hero? Well, does he have any of Aristotle’s six characteristics? Aristotle’s characteristics consist of having a high social status, being imperfect, that the person’s downfall is his own fault, that his misfortune isn’t wholly deserved, the fall is not pure loss, and the tragedy doesn’t leave the audience in a state of depression (English 10 Honors Class Notes). What does Cyrano de Bergerac have in common with Don Quixote? Also, what do Cyrano de Bergerac and Don Quixote have in common with the song, “The Impossible Dream”. The characteristics are clear, but do Cyrano and Don Quixote meet the requirements, and do they live their life as an impossible dream? The first requirement of being a tragic hero is having a high social status. Cyrano does in fact have a high social status. He has respect and fear among his fellow play goers. Ragueneau says, “Sir, have you seen Monsieur de Cyrano?” (Cyrano de Bergerac 15) Which infers that he is popular among his peers. His friends and also speak very high of him. As in fact, while Ragueneau is talking to Ligniere, he states highly of him: “Marry, 'twould puzzle even our grim painter Philippe de...

    Read More
    1736 Words 7 Pages
  • Cyrano de Bergerac Essay

    ...Cyrano de Bergerac The word love has many different understandings Cyrano De Bergerac is no exception taking a unusual approach to it. Coined a "tragic hero" Cyrano faces complicated twist of fate. Roxane, the main object of both Cyrano's and Christians love is the beginning of what turns out to be a difficult love triangle. Although some might feel that Cyrano is manipulative regarding his love for Roxane, it is actually Roxane who causes the most harm because she prompts heartbreak in Cyrano, Christian and herself. Cyrano's character is persuasive towards the people he loves but is much less dramatic than Roxane. Cyrano is looked at as the hero for the majority of the story. His actions and thoughts are graceful in his everyday life; he has a witty personality and a very sharp sense of humor to charm anyone. Being a gifted poet and loving at heart makes what to come later on a more complicated love story. Cyrano portrays a generous and helpful friend to Christian, which turns out to be the start of an array of trouble and hurt for all the characters involved (Besser). Cyrano, having such a big nose and believing himself to be ugly, uses Christian as a vessel in a way to project his love for Roxane. The only problem is that its Christian that is reaping all the benefits as the words Christian speaks are...

    Read More
    893 Words 4 Pages
  • Cyrano de Bergerac Essay Example

    ...Cyrano de Bergerac, the Play vs. Roxane, the Movie In an effort to attract the audience of today, the producers of the movie Roxane retold the play Cyrano de Bergerac by Edmond Rustond in a way that is appropriate and at the same time appealing. In order to give the audience of today a story that they can understand and relate to, the producers have adjusted and manipulated the play itself. As a result, several similarities and differences exist between the play Cyrano de Bergerac and its movie reproduction. The characteristics of a romantic hero in Rustond's time is not equivalent to the characteristics of a romantic hero today. In the play for example, Cyrano, a very ugly, old, yet intellectual man who loved Roxane, his cousin, with all his heart and soul was unable to profess his love for fear that she will have rejected him because of his looks. Enter Christian in the story, a young, average, yet handsome individual who also loved Roxane. The two made a pact with each other to create Roxane's image of a perfect romantic hero—one that was breath-takingly handsome and at the same token, smart in a fun and interesting way. Together they charmed Roxane and she ultimately fell in love with Cyrano's enchanting personality and Christian's captivating appearance. Cyrano is portrayed...

    Read More
    1088 Words 5 Pages
  • Cyrano de Bergerac Essay

    ...Cyrano De Bergerac Bill Beltran 021597 Every generation has its own heroes that display, what they believe to be, ideal characteristics. While each is different in their own way, many of these role models share similar qualities. Most tend to have courage, strength, compassion, or another respected trait, but this is not necessarily why they win the adoration of their followers. Cyrano De Bergerac is a perfect example of how many protagonists win our allegiance because his sensibilities will not be denied, because he lives life to the hilt, and because he is a victim of his surroundings. If there was ever a figure who would not be denied his sensibilities, it is Cyrano. When lovers admit, "I'd die for you," it is usually only a figure of speech. Cyrano actually crossed over enemy lines every day simply to mail love letters. He also confessed to her, "My mother made it clear that she didn't find me pleasant to look at. I had no sister. Later, I dreaded the thought of seeing mockery in the eyes of a mistress. Thanks to you I've at least had a woman's friendship, a gracious presence to soften the harsh loneliness of my life. " When Cyrano admits, "My heart always timidly hides its self behind my mind," the reader can instantly relate to this dilemma but it is the fact that Cyrano is able to overcome it that makes him a hero. Not...

    Read More
    609 Words 3 Pages
  • Essay about Cyrano de Bergerac

    ...the play Cyrano de Bergerac, Edmond Rostand concentrates on Cyrano’s adoration of the exquisite Roxanne, and his attempts to win her love for the less intelligent but more attractive Christian de Neuvillette. Cyrano, a large-nosed swordsman and poet, must overcome internal struggles between his passion for Roxanne and loyalty to his friend Christian. In the end of the play, when Roxanne learns the truth about the true identity of Christian, the ever-loyal Cyrano wrongly accuses himself of amounting to nothing throughout his life. After Cyrano throws Montfleury off of the stage at the Hotel Burgundy, he displays his loyalty and love for his friends when Ligniére appears with a message for him. Ligniére runs into the Hotel Burgundy to alert Cyrano of “ ‘ great danger,’ ” for “ ‘ a hundred men [are] against’ ” him “ ‘because of a song’ ” (I.V.54-55). Immediately, Cyrano tells Ligniére: “ ‘You’ll sleep at home tonight … and I’ll cover you’ ” (I.V.55). Cyrano shows his faithfulness and allegiance to Ligniére by comforting and assuring him of his safety and later defeating the many men who want to kill the poet. Saving Ligniére from one hundred men proves to be a great accomplishment of loyalty even in the eyes of the amazing Cyrano de Bergerac. When...

    Read More
    539 Words 3 Pages

Popular Essays

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free