Preview

Compare And Contrast Bell Hooks And Dobkins

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
626 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare And Contrast Bell Hooks And Dobkins
Since the movement for women’s suffrage first began there were many intersections and obstacles the women of the organization must go through to gain the achievement of obtaining citizenship and their right to vote. In both Bell Hooks and Linda Harris Dobkins articles they respectively introduce race and power within the women’s movement and how it affected the movement. First off, in the passage Revolutionary Parenting Hooks acknowledges how difficult it is to define motherhood by including how race is a big factor and the perceived notion of mothers needing to be the nurtures and primary care takers of the children. When Hooks states the difference in opinions of motherhood between race, I felt that it was extremely important to note that women of color were deeply disenfranchised where we see how the idea of being a mother was oppressing, thus alienating a big group of colored women who saw motherhood not only liberating but empowering. …show more content…
However, Hooks really makes the argument for equal parenting in this particular article. While she does mention the different viewpoints of motherhood she also focuses on the role of a mother and a father and how unequal they are. She believes that in order for motherhood to not be seen as an obstacle fathers must also play an equal role in the raising of a child. She states that in order to rip away these stereotypes that women must be in charge of the home and children it also lies on the responsibility of men standing up and taking more responsibility than they have. I believe that this part really shows that it is a collective effort where both men and women must come together to achieve

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    The Black Freedom Movement

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Starting as early as World War II, the black freedom movement was founded in the goal of destabilizing the racial system of the United States, and especially in the South. Even though various opinions were held as to how that goal should be achieved by the numerous different protest groups, the end to segregation and beginning of racial justice and true freedom were unifying in the black freedom movement. The women’s movement can be categorized in two ways: feminism and women’s liberation. Overall, the goals of the women’s movement are comparable to those of the black freedom movement. The first wave of feminism had the vote at the top of the priority list, but the second wave and women’s liberation had a broader spectrum of goals most notably personal freedom. The National Organization for Women (NOW) was modeled after the civil rights organization, demanding equality in jobs, education, and political rights. The black freedom movement and particularly the second wave of feminism and women’s liberation are similar in that the right to vote was written into law in earlier years, yet these minorities continued to feel the need to press for equal opportunity as the white male. A major reason for this can be seen in the prominent anti-civil rights and anti-feminism position of the South. These surface level similarities, however,…

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    “Woman's Suffrage (Not Universal Suffrage)” by Ann Gordon is a historical analysis of the process white women suffragists followed and how race played a more prevalent role than one has thought of before. White women's demands for suffrage date back to the mid-19th century, starting with women speaking at constitutional conventions and state legislatures. Suffragist organizations such as the National Woman Suffrage Association (NWSA) and the American Women's Suffrage Association (AWSA) were created to explore women's suffrage through two different avenues; through individual states or a constitutional amendment. The AWSA focuses its efforts on specific issues that a constituency of women would find important, such as votes for schools and…

    • 274 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Revolutionary Mothers: Women in the Struggle for America’s Independence by Carol Berkin, is based on the argument that the American Revolutionary War is a story of both men and women. According to Berkin, Women, same as men, played a vital role in freeing the American people from the British colonialists in many ways that most history books never lets out, but even if they ever care to mention, their role is often greatly romanticized. In this book, the author proves that women actually played a critical part in the Revolution by documenting a social history that lays focus on the women of the time. Native Americans, colonial white women, and the African-American women of all social classes, and regardless of the sides they took in the long struggle between the Patriots and the Loyalist have been covered in great details. To cut the long story short, Ms. Berkins has done a stellar job in presenting the…

    • 964 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Author of this book (On our own terms: race, class, and gender in the lives of African American Women) Leith Mullings seeks to explore the modern and historical lives of African American women on the issues of race, class and gender. Mullings does this in a very analytical way using a collection of essays written and collected over a twenty five year period. The author’s systematic format best explains her point of view. The book explores issues such as family, work and health comparing and contrasting between white and black women as well as between men and women of both races.…

    • 873 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It’s women like Alice Paul and Lucy Burns that had the determination and the strength to do what other women were afraid of doing, which was to voice their opinions in a society governed by men. They refused to work with the traditional system of the National American Woman Suffrage Association and calmly waited for the President, Wilson to decide that he wanted to support an amendment giving all American women the right to vote. Paul and Burns lead the National Woman's Party to picket in front of the white house from dusk ‘till dawn holding signs saying, “Mr. President how…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Author Lisa Marostica in her article, “Bloody Sunday, Women and the Collective” stresses the importance of memorializing the women, who dedicated their lives to the civil rights struggle. She does an adequate job in supporting her claim, by summarizing the lives of two incredible women, all the while illustrating the event that took place during the peak of the civil rights movement. “Bloody Sunday” on March 7, 1965, goes down in history as one of the most significant events of the civil rights movement. What was supposed to be a peaceful march from Selma to Montgomery protesting the recent shooting death of Jimmy Lee Jackson during a voter registration march in a nearby city, and the exclusion of African Americans from the voting process turned into blood and carnage. This event received media coverage from across the country. Images of women and young girls attacked for no reason could be seen across the country, on television and in written print. This day goes down in history as being one of the most significant events within the history of the civil rights movement; however, this day also portrays the impact that women made and their lifelong contributions to the civil rights movement. There were several women who worked behind the scenes, ensuring the freedom off all Americans. As emphasized by Marostica in her article, their dedication to the civil rights movement has often been overlooked. Two such women that dedicated their lives to the cause are Amelia Boynton Robinson, and Viola Liuzzo. This paper will illustrate the pivotal role that these two women played within the fight for civil rights as civil rights extended far beyond just black and white. It was more than a battle for the right to vote. It was also a battle to stop gender and racial discrimination.…

    • 1539 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    During this time of the Market Revolution and the Second Great Awakening, women began appearing as an important m­­ember of family life. Women became the leading family member because of her significance in keeping the family together and raising intellectual and idiosyncratic individuals (doc. E). However, families began growing smaller at this time with each one only having one or two children (doc. G). This was primarily due to the emerging of domestic feminism, which was the growing power of women in making decisions. These smaller families however, allowed the mother to spend more time with each individual child. This, in turn, would allow each one to grow up and be more practical, candid, and diligent citizens. Although, not all women wanted to have less kids in spite their growing power. This was especially true for African American women in slavery. These women were worst off during this time. Many slave women would often be sold separately from their child at auctions in the south. This was one of the worst products of slavery- the forced separation of a mother from her child (doc. B). During this time, most women were gaining more power and becoming the leading figure in family life.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As the 19 century ended and the 20th began, the American wave of women pushing for access to the ballot box gathered momentum. As astonishing as it was many women were against the right to vote. These women were referred to in many ways: “anti-suffragettes,” “anti-suffragists,” “remonstrates,” “governmentalists,” “antis,” and “naysayers.” Anti-suffragists leaders were not average American women but were women of the higher, privileged, class. These women were already doing well in society and had a place in the existent system, which afforded most of their class with incentives to hang on to. These women were from all parts of the United States. In the North, the women were often from urban areas who were daughters or wives of prosperous men…

    • 283 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the 19th century America, women, children and slaves had the same legal status. They were all considered the sole propriety of the “owner”, who was the husband and the father. This caused many women to feel left out, unimportant and discriminated. Not a single man would want to trade places with a woman. However, women began fighting for their rights and won. “Not for Ourselves Alone” is a good documentary film about fight for women rights and the biography of Susan B. Anthony and Elizabeth Cady Stanton, two women that were born into the world ruled by men. These two women were very different. Susan grew up wealthy, educated and sociable; she married and had a family of her own. Elizabeth, who grew up in a Quaker family, worked to support herself all her life and chose to remain single. But they both shared a belief that equality is every woman's right, and they spent half of the century making their dream a reality. By the time their life was over, they changed the lives of a majority of American families. Nothing precious is easily won, which is certainly true about women right, because it took a lot of time, patience and persistence of many women to get the same rights that men had. They caused a…

    • 750 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    She follows both a chronological style within the chapters to show growth and change, but also uses each chapter to describe different groups, events, and political ideals, that were vital to the reproductive rights movement. Nelson begins her book with an introduction to the movement as well as a history of abortion- both legal and illegal methods. Chapter one provides the reader with a background of the Redstockings and the early abortion rights movements. Chapter two focuses on the history of black women and forced sterilization as well as proposed legislation based on sterilization and welfare (a topic that will come up repeatedly throughout the book). Chapter three shifts the focus from black women, to black movements such as the Black Panthers and Black Power, and how their masculine-controlled movements led to the oppression of black women’s access to contraceptives and voluntary sterilization. Chapter four introduces readers to a minority outside of the black race, the Puerto Rican women and the Young Lord’s Party, and their struggle with reproductive rights. This chapter also looks at the oppression of women under and eventual reconstruction of Machismo. Chapter five focuses on the role of CARASA in the movement and its eventual self-destruction. Nelson concludes her text with restating her argument and discussing the evolution of reproductive rights for women of color and poor…

    • 1214 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bell Hooks Research Paper

    • 644 Words
    • 3 Pages

    We live in a world where there are numerous discriminations: race, religion, sex, age, or sexual orientation. bell hooks has eloquently explained multiple reasons why the black population is discriminated against in an educational setting, “...most white folks are rarely, if ever, in a situation where they must listen to black women lecture to them.” (hooks, 31) Daily we hear about the killings of transsexual men and women, as well as multiple examinations talking about men who receive more money then women in the workplace for the same job. Carl Grant intelligently said, “Another factor stimulating the change is the acceptance of the importance of social cultural factors in learning and the movement toward challenging traditional assumptions and envisioning multiple possibilities for change.” (Grant, 1) The discrimination I’m talking about most people don’t understand or even see,…

    • 644 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    First, the origin is limited because the text was written too soon after the events to fully understand their historical impact. Moreover, its editors were all members of the National Women Suffrage Association, white, and lived in the North, causing different perspectives, for instance the rival American Woman Suffrage Association or Southern women, to be unacknowledged. Additionally, the purpose of this book is greatly limiting; written to inspire more support for women’s suffrage, this text presents the movement’s history as a unified force accomplishing goals with little resistance; in reality, the movement had many different opinions and faced a lot of strife in accomplishing…

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Due to the unthinkable amount of hardships African Americans have had to overcome in order to receive even semi-equality throughout the 1960’s and on, it is not difficult for one to imagine the adversities one woman of color faced in trying to fight for her right to not only vote, but also be treated as an active and equal citizen of the United States.…

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Republican Motherhood

    • 327 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Putting the responsibilities of children in the hands of the women essentially put the future of America in their hands. The women were the ones filling the heads of children with knowledge, and teaching them how to better serve their…

    • 327 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    To Kill a Mockingbird

    • 920 Words
    • 4 Pages

    A world where women didn’t receive equal pay for the same work, couldn’t apply to the same colleges, or have equal job opportunities as a man, or even serve in the military (except in nursing positions) is an idea completely unthinkable to many citizens of the United States today. Although a society where these restrictions are customary is immoral and oppressive, before the 1930s, it was widely accepted. In the late 1920s and early 1930s many women began to make a strong effort to gain rights in The United States of America. Because of the efforts of these women, during the 1930s women began to receive more rights. This trend continued as women’s roles in society became greater and more important over time and up to this day. The women who stood up for their rights in the 1930s have significantly affected the rights and responsibilities that women have in modern times in the United States. The rights that women had in the 1930s are shown in Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mockingbird by the prejudices and expectations of women in Maycomb, Alabama.…

    • 920 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays