compare and contrast

Topics: First-person narrative, Narrative, Short story Pages: 9 (1189 words) Published: November 27, 2014


Comparing and Contrasting “The Story
of an Hour” and “How I Met My Husband”.
Lora Cruse
Ashford University ENG125
11/20/2014

In this essay I will be comparing and contrasting two great short stories. One being “The Story of

an Hour” written by Kate Chopin in 1854 and the other being “How I Met my Husband” written by

Alice Munro in 1974. The two short stories share the theme of gender roles/marriage. That being said,,

I will be going over plot, point of view and tone. Sometimes women feel like they are

trapped in their marriage, and sometimes women cannot wait to become married.

Kate Chopin's “The Story of an Hour represents a negative view of marriage. Every individual

takes a different approach when enduring the loss of a loved one. Whether it is bursting into tears or

being miserable. When a wife loses a husband, she typically tends to be in a state of depression. The

feeling of losing your significant other is a piercing agony going through one's heart, but in this case

the feeling of loss can turn into someone's freedom. For Louise Mallard she had an erratic reaction

when she was informed that her husband had been allegedly killed in a train accident. She locks

herself in her room and sits in front of the window in desolation. She begins to ponder how her life

will be without her husband. The sorrow that Mrs. Mallard felt in the beginning slowly turns into joy.

“Free body and soul free!” (Chopin 40). She knew that she would grieve over her husband like a wife

is supposed to, but internally her new found independence takes over. Finally she gets to live for

herself and do the things she had longed to accomplish. It is safe to say that she does not see this as a

misfortune, but as an opportunity, as if she were given another chance at life. Louise Mallard had been

so close to being finally free but as it turned out Brently Mallard had not died. Ironically, her sequence

of emotions ultimately led to her death. The fact that she dies at the end of a simple heart disease

shows that her misery stem from internally oppose to external emotions, The freedom that she nearly

could've tasted was gone. “For one climactic hour of her life, Louise does truly taste joy. For one hour

of emotion, Louise does glimpse meaning and fulfillment.” (Jamil,2009).

The story “How I Met my Husband” is about a young girl named Edie who is hired help for Dr.

Peebles and his family. One afternoon, while the family is away in town, she meets Chris Watters, a

pilot who travels from town to town giving rides in his plane for a fee. Edie falls in love with him but

soon learns that he is engaged to another woman, Alice Kelling. Alice is crazy and has been following

Chris everywhere in hopes of sex. One day while Alice, Mrs. Peebles, and the children were away on a

picnic, Edie goes to Chris's campsite to talk to him. He reveals to her his plans on leaving, but

promises to write her. They kiss and he leaves town. When the other women are told by the local

gossip, Loretta Bird that Chris has left, Alice Kelling verbally abuses Edie under the mistaken

impression that Edie and Chris had sex. Mrs. Peebles protects Edie and Alice leaves too. Edie waits

day after day at the mailbox for Chris's letter, which never comes. Eventually, Edie realizes Chris will

never write and marries the mailman, who believes that she waited by the mailbox for him everyday.

Edie never tells him that she was waiting for Chris because she likes “for people to think what pleases

them and makes them happy.” It is a perfect conclusion to Munro's story, a story that exemplifies the

old saying,”what they don't know can't hurt 'em.”

Although the plots of these two...

Bibliography: Clugston, R. Wayne. (2014). Journey into Literature 2nd Edition: United States: Bridgepoint Education, Inc.

Jamil, Selina. S. (2009). Emotions in The Story of an Hour. The Explcator, 67(3) pp 215 5p.
Sutton, B. (2005) Munro 's How I Met my Husband. The Explicator, 63(2) pp 107 4 p.
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Compare and Contrast Essay
  • Compare and Contrast Literature Essay
  • compare/contrast Essay
  • Compare and Contrast Essay
  • compare and contrast Essay
  • Literature Compare and Contrast Essay
  • Essay about Compare and Contrast
  • Compare and Contrast Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free