Preview

Compare and Contrast

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
329 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare and Contrast
John Updike's story “A & P” and James Joyce's “Araby” share many of the same literary traits. The theme of the two stories revolves around a young man who wants to decipher the difference between reality and the false fantasies of romance he dreams about. Both characters have focused upon one girl in particular that they cast all their affection on. The young man in both stories does discover the difference, which sets him off into emotional collapse.
One of the main similarities between the two stories is the fact that the main character, who is the protagonist, has built up unrealistic, yet in incredible expectations of women.. The expectation that these men hold when finally are face to face with the woman of affection, is what sends the final blow of reality. They suffer rejection by the women they have strong affection for.
Their confusion of the world is shown in the descriptions both men use when describing the town in “A&P” and the bazaar in “Araby”
Sammy speaks of the people in his town, describing the customers as sheep. In his mind the town has become so boring that the citizens have been brained washed into mindless sheep.
In “Araby” the bazaar is exaggerated in the way its building is described by the boy as “A large building which displayed a magical name” the boy is seeing the bazaar as the only place that will have the right gift to win the girls affection, and not the flea market it actually is.
The primary focal point is the young mans love for a completely unattaiable girl who unknowingly causes a boy to become confused on whether his feelings are of lust, or if his feelings are honorable.
This is shown in “A&P” when Sammy quits his job in protest over the girls being mistreated. He hopes to impress the girls by doing so. This example of self-deception is seen in both

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Many of the modern television shows and movies use similar themes and subject matter as “A&P.” Things like young girls trying to appear older than they are, an awkward young man coming to terms with his sexuality, and the idea of conventional masculinity are all commonly found in the media. The question of how an adolescent girl’s mind works is that one that cannot be easily answered, but attempts are often made. The character of Sammy is virtually clueless about females, and Updike makes this obvious, “You never know for sure how girl’ minds work (do you really think it’s a mind in there or just a little buzz like a bee in a glass jar?).” When this story was written the dynamic between young men and women was not as readily explored, but today it is a source of entertainment. High school dramas have taken over prime time television. However, this story is not one of drama, but rather ironic humor. The reader anticipates Sammy to act like a typical teenage boy, and mirror the actions of his coworker. Instead, he connects to them on a more emotional level, which leads him to act irrationally. Updike turns what could have been another typical teenage story into a satire of society’s expectations on sexuality and gender.…

    • 2050 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A&P vs. Araby

    • 676 Words
    • 2 Pages

    John Updike’s A&P and James Joyce’s Araby are very similar yet very different in many ways. Each short story has a normal kid with an obsession over a girl. The big difference between Sammy in A&P and Jimmy in Araby is just that they were raised differently and have different values. The way Jimmy talks about his fantasy girl is on a more religious level while Sammy in other words is kind of impolite about how he describes the three girls that walk into the market. From the narrator’s point of view in each story to the use of imagery and the main characters motivation, each story has multiple points of comparison to compare and contrast.…

    • 676 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    1. At the end of "Araby" the narrator sees himself as "driven and derided by vanity." One meaning of "vanity" is that state of being empty, idle, valueless." Another meaning is "exaggerated self-love." Still another is "hunger for praise or admiration." Each of these definitions of vanity could apply to the narrator. The definition of vanity meaning "exaggerated self-love relates to the narrator because at a point in the text, the boy realizes that his romantic feelings for Mangan's sister are a delusion. The definition of vanity meaning "a state of being empty, idle, valueless" relates to the narrator as well because at the beginning of the poem, the boy's house has the sense of a dead present and a lost past. He lives on a street that is…

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Araby

    • 529 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Araby is about escaping into the world of fantasy. The narrator is infatuated with his friend's sister; he hides in the shadows, peering secluded from a distance trying to spy her "brown figure"(Joyce 38). She is the light in his fantasy, someone who will lift him out of darkness. I see many parallels to my life as a boy growing up in the inner city of Jersey City. We looked for escape also, a trip uptown to Lincoln Park, or take a train ride to New York City where we would gaze at the beauties on 7th Ave.…

    • 529 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Araby

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages

    James Joyce’s “Araby” is a short story of a nameless boy in Dublin who has a typical crush on his friend Mangan’s sister, and because of it, journeys to a bazaar called Araby, where he finally comes to a realization about his immature actions. This is the basis for the entire story, but the ideas Joyce presents with this story revolve around how the boy reacts to these feelings, and ultimately how he realizes his tragedy. Joyce spends some of the story introducing the boy’s thoughts on the area in which he lives, and similarly how he feels about the life he has lived thus far. Joyce builds up the boy’s dislike for the simple aspects of his daily life, and how he feels bored with where he lives and what he does. Then Joyce shows us what excites the boy; the girl with whom he is obsessed. The key to his crush is in what it makes the boy do, and how it forces him to act without thinking.…

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    While we pity the narrator for the shame and anger he feels when he discovers the difference between fantasy and reality, perhaps we also hope that, in the future, he will learn to love real people instead of the idealized versions of them he creates in his head. While the idea that people must live in such mind-numbing conditions may cause us heartache, we may take refuge in the fact that the narrator has survived, and is able to recount to us the story he now tells us: obviously his imagination has not been stifled. And while we may find solace in counterbalancing these themes against one another, we must weigh our equivocations against the exorable onslaught of dark, drab, impecunious imagery that Joyce assaults us with in "Araby" to create a vision of childhood that is vitiated of both life and hope.Romantic elementsAraby follows the nelson monomyth structure. However, the story is an anti-romance; the young boy is infatuated with romance stories, and is confronted on all sides by reality, and sexual oppression. [1] The boy 's naïve journey to buy a wonderful gift for his neighbor 's sister ends with the young boy coming to terms with the "unbridgeable chasm between desire and reality"[2]. He returns frustrated and without his gift, his dream world shattered:…

    • 1749 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The story of “Araby” by James Joyce is one of many stories in the book Dubliners. Here we follow the protagonist as he slowly discovers the truths of adult life. He’s at that stage in his young life when nothing seems to make sense. Joyce shows how the frustration of love can breakdown the barrier between the safety of childhood and the uncertainty of adolescent years.…

    • 914 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    James Joyce, an icon of the modernist era had many works that were moving away from the classical styles of literature put before him. Joyce is known for leading his characters towards some kind of personal insight and on the surface, Araby seems to be only about a boy learning about the truth of capitalism. As you dive deep in to his words and meaning however, it is apparent that Joyce’s message is not as black and white as it appears on the surface. This story is also about the relationship between men and women. It is about how women are capable of influencing a man’s actions/behaviors and why men feel as if they need to exert their “dominance” over women.…

    • 1051 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    James Joyce's Araby

    • 1755 Words
    • 8 Pages

    James Joyce is one of the best known novelists of the modernist period and his 14 Dubliners stories, of which one has the title Araby, are “the epitome of a revolution in the use of fiction” (Head i). Furthermore, Araby belongs to the childhood narratives (Brunsdale 4). Thus, the story is about a boy who is in love with the sister of a friend, and it seems to be his first love. He then wants to buy her a gift on the bazaar, to rejoice her. Finally, the story ends with the boy having an illumination about sexuality, which threatens his illusion about love. This epiphany/illumination happens when the saleswoman, which can be seen as a ‘representative’ for society, lets the boy down and destroys his romantic ideal of love at that moment. This could point towards social criticism, which later on will be discussed. Another indication for social criticism can be found on Joyce’s emphasis on gloominess by connecting it to the adults and their dark souls – the uncle and the marketer –, which probably stand for society as a whole. The gloominess of the text is expressed literally by the repetition of the theme of darkness and by the metaphors of the latter. This is also the reason why the mention of “light”, of which the meaning can be interpreted as the pure soul of a child, is rarely emerging throughout the text. By discussing the text’s epiphany ant its theme of darkness and light, this essay will argue that Joyce’s purpose is to criticize society. The metaphor of light and primarily the mention of darkness define the figurative language in the text, and especially in the last sentence…

    • 1755 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    On its simplest level, "Araby" is a story about a boy's first love.On a deeper level, however, it is a story about the world in which helives-a world inimical to ideals and dreams. This deeper level is in-troduced and developed in several scenes: the opening description ofthe boy's street, his house, his relationship to his aunt and uncle, theinformation about the priest and his belongings, the boy's two trips-his walks through Dublin shopping and his subsequent ride toAraby.…

    • 862 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Araby by James Joyce

    • 321 Words
    • 2 Pages

    James Joyce writes about the realization of reality in "Araby". The story opens with a description of North Richmond Street, which if filled with decaying conformity and false piety. The boy's house contains the same sense of a dead present and a lost past. The former tenant, a priest, died in the back room of the house, and his legacy-several old yellowed books, which the boy enjoys leafing through because they are old, and a bicycle pump rusting in the back yard-become symbols of the intellectual and religious vitality of the past. Every morning before school the boy lies on the floor in the front parlor peeking out through a crack in the blind of the door, watching and waiting for the girl next door to emerge from her house and walk to school. He is shy and still boyish. He follows her, walks silently past, not daring to speak, overcome with a confused sense of sensual desire and religious adoration. In his mind she is both a saint to be worshipped and a woman to be desired. One evening he goes to the back room where the priest had died and clasps the palms of his hands together, he murmurs, "love! love!" in a prayer not to God, but to the concept of love. Finally the girl speaks to the boy. She asks him if he is going to Araby, and he replies that if he does he will bring her a gift. The second part of the story depicts the boy's inevitable disappointment and realization. In such an atmosphere of "blindness"-the aunt and uncle unaware of the boy's anguish, the girl not conscious of the boy's love. His love, like his quest for a gift to draw the girl to him in an unfriendly world, ends with his realizing that his love existed only in his…

    • 321 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Wife of Bath

    • 262 Words
    • 2 Pages

    They are both different when it comes to the women of the tales over the overall point of the stories are the same; love, passion and…

    • 262 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    First, let’s start analyzing the conflict in James Joyce’s Araby. As mentioned, it’s a short story narrated by an adult talking about how he was suddenly introduced to the adulthood and how it was different from his expectations. The protagonist in this story had that “confused adoration” for a girl which took him far away from reality, and this can be noticed in many of his statements just as describing his body as “A harp and her words and gestures were like fingers running upon the wires” (Joyce 110). When the girl first talked to him she told him about a Bazaar called Araby and her desire to attend but could not. Because he was a “foolish blood”, he thought that she had feelings for him too, this made him go far away with his imagination, but then, when he went to the bazaar, he was shocked with the objective reality and the materialism of the modern world. The…

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Story Of Keesh Analysis

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In both stories the loss of life is a factor in both stories, they each lose a beloved member or someone important to them. In the Story of…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In Araby, the protagonist, who is also the narrator, is a young boy who becomes attracted to a friend’s sister. He begins the story by describing his environment as dark and bleak, and later on speaks of Mangan’s sister with her figure being “defined by the light from the half-opened door.” In a literary analysis, Donschikowski (2006) writes, “His youthful imagination sees her always surrounded with light; she is the contrast to his dark world” (p. 12). He thinks of her all the time, although he does not fully know her, as he “had never spoken to her, except for a few casual words.” Every morning, he tries to get a glimpse of her and follows her on the way out until they have to go their separate ways.…

    • 1766 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays