top-rated free essay

Commentary on Hbr Case: When Consultants and Clients Clash

By bluegem Dec 15, 2010 570 Words
Commentary on HBR Case: When Consultants and Clients Clash
-by Vinodkumar Pralia, Section-D1, 341/47
Is the business relationship between the Statler Group and Kellogg-Champion Securities a lost cause? How should the consultants and the client handle the status meeting? The crux of the problem is the incorrect framing of tasks to be undertaken by Statler Group consultants. This has been the cumulative result of the lack of understanding of merger situations by Kellogg and over-estimation of the progress of the merger by Gray. Since Kellogg hasn’t been involved in the people aspect of his firm and also, this being his first exposure to a merger situation, his understanding about the complexities arising out of mergers is limited. Despite important post merger tasks like finalizing hierarchical levels, reporting structures, executive titles still remaining, Kellogg is of the opinion that the merger is almost done. On the part of Gray, he has taken client’s viewpoints as the starting without himself doing any fact-finding to ascertain the progress of the merger and the tasks remaining for completion of the merger. This has led to situation where consultants’ task formulation includes only policies realignment without considering status of the other tasks. It’s next to impossible for the consultants to complete their assigned task of policies realignment without settling of the hierarchical levels and reporting structure. Even if we assume that the policies realignment task is achieved somehow, it will not be in the client’s interest as once the hierarchy and reporting issues are handled, need for policy changes would invariably arise. To tap the synergies of the merger, the client has to settle these pressing needs before it looks into the policies. As the scope of the work is bound to increase with the addition of new tasks, the first thing Gray has to do is be present in person for the next meeting to show his seriousness to the client and also to show that Statler Group has competent people to do the job. He should present to Kellogg how important it is to complete the hierarchy and reporting issues before beginning with policies realignment. To back this he should use his team’s findings in the firm till now and other research data on mergers. This would help Kellogg to understand the complexities involved in a merger situation. He should tell Kellogg that a merger situation is bound to create conflicting interests in its employees and it would help the firm to remove arising uncertainties as soon as possible. Gray should acknowledge the fact that he over-estimated the progress of the merger and should present a proposal for reframing the engagement to include the additional tasks like recommending hierarchical levels and reporting structure. Along with this he should present in details how he plans to accomplish them. He should share with Kellogg that the most important decision criteria for the tasks should be maximize the synergies which can be derived out of the merging entities. One of the key actionable of his plans should be getting Kellogg to introduce the team to the senior management to have everyone on the same page as far as their mission objectives are concerned. The management should come out with circulars stating interim policies till the process is on. This will serve in bringing down anxiety of the employees arising out of the merger situation.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • When Consultants & Clients Clash

    ...Creating Customer Value & Customer Relationship Management “When Consultants & Clients Clash” 1. At which stage of the relationship life-cycle would you position the business relationship between the Statler Group and the Kellogg-Champion Securities? In order to elaborate and analyze this question, someon...

    Read More
  • When Consultants and Clients Clash

    ...When consultants and client clash: Problem Essay Statlers have failed to get their clients to acknowledge the differences in thinking about the merger. The rationale behind every merger is that the sum is greater than the parts. Typically, clients identify synergies for the merger and from then on consultants suggest the decisions necessary f...

    Read More
  • When Key Employees Clash: Case Study

    ...business. If only he had been in Florida, he might have been able to cut this issue in its grass roots without letting it go out of bounds. Moreover, he promoted Ronnie to a managerial position for the first time based on this exceptional performance over the time and did not emphasize on proper transitional training to Ronnie. He just assumed t...

    Read More
  • Case: Right Management Consultants Succeeds by Managing Change

    ...Case: Right Management Consultants Succeeds by Managing Change 1. What are the challenges faced by Right when the downsizing effort no longer is a popular human resource strategy? When the downsizing effort is no longer a popular human resource strategy, Right will need to find other methods to use. The strategic approach to HR management h...

    Read More
  • Lawford Case Study Hbr

    ...Lawford Electric Company Case Analysis Lawford Electric Company Case Analysis In this case, Robert Allen, a Field Sales Engineer for the Systems Controls department at Lawford Electric Company, has lost a very large sale with Bayfield Milling. Bayfield Milling’s average annual purchases with Lawford ...

    Read More
  • Apple Hbr Case Analysis

    ...Executive Summary The case " Apple Computer's Supplier Hubs: A Tale of Three Cities" deals with the imple-mentation of supplier hubs as an instrument to improve the flow of materials along a sup-ply chain based on the experience at Cork, Ireland and Fountain, Colorado. Since the demand of Apple's desktop PC and server PC prod...

    Read More
  • Gillette Case Study Hbr

    ...Division A Group 5 Gillette’s Marketing Strategy for Indonesia Executive summary The analysis has been done to achieve the country manager, Chester Allan’s objective to increase the market share by 19% through identifying the new customer segments, and increase brand loyalty. The problems faced while achieving the objective are as follow...

    Read More
  • Hbr Cases Solved

    ...CASE STUDY , Au Bon Pain This is a company which has achieved great success and soon had become the leader on the market. If we could describe them by only one word that word would be: Quality. Very quickly they became recognizable. Despite that they gained a lot of competition in the market they were still trying to develop. The company bega...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.