Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Commentary: An Advancement from Learning by Seamus Heaney

Good Essays
830 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Commentary: An Advancement from Learning by Seamus Heaney
Commentary: An Advancement of Learning by Seamus Heaney

In An Advancement from Learning by Seamus Heaney, he describes a retrospective childhood experience. The narrator compels himself to face a deep-seated and preposterous fear which he consequently conquers. He shares his terror and revulsion by implementing vivid and vibrant imagery presented in nine quatrains. The conquest of an irrational fear depicted in this poem is perhaps a metaphor for overcoming greater fears in life.

As the title suggest, this poem is about An Advancement of Learning- facing and subsequently conquering sometimes strong and private fears. Heaney describes a lone stroll along a polluted, ‘oil-skinned’ river bank. The almost sombre introspective tone of the opening two stanzas rapidly changes into one of revolt and terror as a rat emerges from the river. In a moment of panic, the poet attempts to escape, only to find another on the far bank, which encouraged a deeper impact. The second rat provoked the author to question his response to and fear for these animals. He then ‘incredibly’ decides to courageously maintain his ground and face the rodent. Despite Heaney providing the reader with a vibrant image of the animal to reinforce his contempt, he almost battles the rat until he ‘stared him out’. Eventually, as if the narrator won the ongoing battle, the rat retreats into a sewage pipe. Heaney then advances his way and triumphantly crosses the bridge, as he conquered a fright which has bedevilled him since childhood.

An Advancement of Learning is written in nine quatrains consisting of short and sharp lines, which almost present the reader with a succession of flashing images. Heaney employs a loose and alternate rhyming scheme- stanzas one, three, six, eight and nine follow the pattern abcb, whereas stanzas two and four follow the abac pattern. Where the seventh stanza follows the abab pattern, Stanza five has the different but effective rhyming scheme abbc. The regularity of the rhythm in this stanza contributes to the reader’s sense of the poet’s rising self control.
Heaney makes active use of enjambment and caesura to emphasise many of his emotions and sentiments. The astute use of enjambment from lines ten to sixteen increase the tempo and excitement of the poem, which in turn aid to convey the poet’s fright and aspiration to flee. Furthermore, the writer applies enjambment between one stanza and the next to allow his descriptions to flow smoothly, which appropriately reflects the fluidity of the river described. Interesting is that the verses reflect the writer’s gradual gaining of self control.

The main entity in the poem is the bridge as it symbolises the tree stages in the writer’s conquest of fear. At the sight of the first rat, the poet initially refuses to cross the bridge. Once faced with his ‘enemy’, he establishes a ‘dreaded Bridgehead’ which in military terms means to hold a defensive position. He is fearful but determined. Finally, as the poet defeats his foe and fear, he, with a vestige of triumph, ‘walked on and crossed the bridge.’ The bridge is mentioned at these three key stages of Heaney’s experience as well as structurally in the first, central and closing stanzas to emphasise the stages of overcoming his fear gradually.

Heaney’s most striking feature in terms of style and language are unmistakably his effective use of alliteration and sibilance, as well as the appealing use of lexis. The repetition of the sharp consonant sounds s and c, especially conspicuous in the third stanza, contribute to both the sickening nature of the rat and the writer’s feelings towards it. An example of words carefully chosen to enhance and reflect the meaning of the poem is ‘Insidiously listening’, which is despite its impact, neither alliteration nor assonance. The narrator also employs extraordinary and emotive vocabulary, such as ‘slimed’ and ‘nimbling’ to describe the rats, allowing the reader to accurately experience the fear and loathing which he suffered. Remarkable about this poem is that as the writer overcomes his revolt and fright, the description of the animal becomes more forgiving. Where at the beginning the rodents were Insidious, ‘slobbered’ and ‘slimed’ around, they are, less forbiddingly, observed as animals with ‘the raindrop eye’ and ‘the old snout’ towards the end. This indicates how the writer’s fear and terror disappears with the rat into the sewage pipe, and how he now views the rodent in its proper perspective.

An Advancement of Learning successfully conveyed the writer’s feelings and emotions while conquering a lifelong phobia. The use of enjambment and caesura as well as the alternating rhyming patterns, which reflected the increasing order of the situation, all contribute to the vibrant image the reader is provided with. Furthermore, the poet employed the motif of the bridge as a foundation for the poem’s structure while adding more dimension to the text by enforcing it as a symbol of the poet’s route to overcoming his deep-rooted fears.

[809 words]

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The story portrays a story of a fisherman who has the rare opportunity to meet an amazing creature. This is why he describes the fish as “venerable”, “homely”, and “battered”. He also stated that the fish did not fight at all; which does not become significant until near to the end of the poem when he realizes that this “tremendous” fish has finally submitted itself and given up.…

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Richard Connell’s “The Most Dangerous Game,” Sanger Rainsford is hard hearted and does not care about the animals that he pursues; however, when Rainsford is being hunted he realizes the fear of the prey, and his perspective shifts, therefore, he gains empathy for the quarry.…

    • 252 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Waking Poem Analysis

    • 549 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Roethke wrote ‘The Waking’ after a series of intense poems such as ‘Praise to the End!’ and in it he describes the process of enlightenment through waking (living) and sleeping (dying). Two main themes are repeated in the villanelle form of the poem. ‘I wake to sleep’ and ‘I learn by going where I have to go’ are alternately repeated at the end of…

    • 549 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On the both poems, D. H. Lawrence’s “snake” and Elizabeth bishop’s “Fish,” both author mentions about animals. Both writer treated animals as animals at first, but later on, they compare those animals with human. The explanation of visual, the time when two authors think those animals as human, and the ironic feeling that both author have demonstrate that both speakers state of mind change.…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Diction In The Rattler

    • 536 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As the snake dies it “strikes passionately once more at the hoe” and “there is blood in his mouth and poison dripping from his fangs.” The imagery dramatizes the image of the snake’s power being drained. The reader can visualize the transition from a once fierce snake to a lifeless carcass. In response to the killing of the snake, the man feels regret for the necessity of the circumstance, as “it was all a nasty sight, pitiful…” and “he could see it as he might have let it go, sinuous and self respecting in departure over the twilit sands.” This is a reflection of what could have been, and reveals the man’s conflicting feelings on what was necessary. The pitiful scene of the snake’s death adds to the man’s regret. The imagery in the passage emphasizes the idea of “what could have been” and therefore the man’s internal…

    • 536 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagery In The Swamp

    • 374 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The poem is presented with a unique formation. The descension of the poems words adds a sense of panic. It begins with long lines only to taper off into short strokes. This cultivates a feeling of being trapped or close within the swamp itself. The author fears what is within it and is able to present that fear by having a uniform formation, with each stanza tapering off which emulates short, quick breaths associated with an anxiety attack. This combines to demonstrate the anxiety the author has when thinking…

    • 374 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Conflict is a key factor presented in life whether we try to avoid it or not. In most cases the battle is fought against yourself. In the poems “Woodchucks” by Maxine Kumin and “Traveling through the Dark” by William Stafford, the poets both focus on animals and self confrontation in humans. Descriptive language and the overall theme provides the reader with the insight necessary to understand the speaker’s psychology as they are driven beyond the boundaries of what’s morally right and wrong.…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Rattler Comentary

    • 661 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The author's Diction heightens the rancher's commitment to protect the people and the doubt he feels about the decision. Although the man's first “instinct” was not to kill the snake, he realized that it was his “duty” to kill it because of the “ominous” danger it posed to the ranch. The man's natural “instinct” and his moral “duty” to protect the ranch do not align, creating the conflict that the reader identifies with. The man recognizes the “ominous” danger posed by the snake, leaving him with an obligation to remove the danger. At first, the rancher's thought was to “let [the snake] go” for the rancher “never killed” an animal and not “obliged” to kill, but he “reflected” that it posed as a threat to the ranch, thus having to remove it. The rancher wanted to “let [the snake] go” for he has “never killed an animal” because he does not “feel the satisfaction” of killing as a sport. The rancher was very hesitant to kill, but he “reflected” that he needed to protect. The man's obligation and regret about killing the snake creates a conflict that generates the readers emotions through Diction; the Imagery further illustrates this conflict.…

    • 661 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Sgee

    • 1090 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Harwood’s two part poem ‘Father and Child’ connects the two ideas of growth from innocence to experience and the confrontation with mortality. In both parts of the poem, the speaker’s transition from childhood to adulthood is evident as he/she is forced to face the reality of death. In ‘Barn owl’, Harwood presents the child as innocent because he/she is unaware of the consequences of killing of the barn owl. Hoddinott’s view that the child’s cruelty is a part of “the complex journey through the adult world of experience” provides a valuable insight into these key ideas because it is through the confrontation with death that the child gains experience and understanding. The speaker’s confidence at the beginning of ‘Barn Owl’ is signified because the owl is initially objectified as the speaker’s “prize”. This metaphor facilitates the speaker’s act of killing the owl, as it significantly diminishes its importance. After the killing, the tone becomes regretful in the line “I watched afraid by the fallen gun, a lonely child” to illustrate the child’s understanding of the enormity of the death. The emotive language reinforces that the child is solitary and responsible for the action. This is highlighted through the use of rhyme in “I saw those eyes that did not see mirror my cruelty” which highlights the complexity of the child’s journey into adulthood. Hence, Hoddinott’s view is clearly evident as once the child kills the owl, he/she begins to understand the complexity of death which is an inevitable part of life. Therefore, Harwood’s ‘Barn Owl’ has permitted me to synthesise the ideas of gaining understanding through the confrontation with mortality.…

    • 1090 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    By the conclusion of the poem, an emotional change is established where at the start he was unsure of his path but by the end, it was clear to him he wanted to walk his path alone ‘with guts and determination’, he demands he wants to continue his…

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The poem is about how bravery gives us the power to break through our barriers, the ones that hold us back. In this case the barrier is the maze.Those who conquer this great foe,…

    • 257 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Relationships can prevent or encourage change within a person but it is ultimately time and the individual’s own mental endurance to lead progress into the world. ‘The Story of Tom Brennan’ by J.C Burke explores the main character, Tom Brennan and his family, dealing with the dramatic event that the oldest son, Daniel, creates in a drink driving accident. In the novel Tom is in a state of uncertainty, Tom’s life come to a drastic change caused by Daniel which within this time of family crisis Tom is forced to mature and step into the world but unprepared. The hyperbole and exaggeration with the use of colloquial terms which express frustration and hopelessness, the “cave” is symbolic of their oppressive home and state of mind. In the poem ‘THE DOOR’ by Miroslav Holub also establishes drastic changes as the poem presents the resistance to change and the attitude that change inevitable. The change from child view into an adult’s view shows the change in life physically and mentally as you grow up, this is inevitable as everything changes and grows. Tom Brennan, inevitable makes this transition from child to adult.…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Through extended metaphor, the poet shows how facing something very difficult—some all encompassing problem—can lead to a triumphant, even exultant outcome, a chance for renewal which defies the enervating effects of time, and the negative, self-fulfilling prophecies of fear and stagnation.…

    • 552 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Revelation Essay

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The quote, “at the threshold of his outhouse”, is the turning point in the story. This is a symbolic quote that states you must go over a line before starting a new life. In the poem a young girl is standing in the area between safety and danger. The line is significant as the pause creates a series of tension building up to a sense of danger. The girl’s initial perceptions of the creature are conveyed in,…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bishop begins with the personification of the fish into a figure of defeat and age. The speaker mentions that the fish had not fought at all, as though he had given up all hope. She compares the fish's skin to old wallpaper which would not be securely attached to the wall as skin loses firmness with age. In addition, Bishop details the extent of the fish's injuries, everything from lice and barnacles to the fresh blood of his wounds. Such imagery invokes feelings of decay and abandonment as parasites are allowed to slowly consume him. The speaker also contemplates the fish's innards, suggesting that his has become a mass of flesh and bone without spirit. The speaker furthers the personification of the fish by looking into his eyes and remarking that he had not looked back fully. Instead, the fish had only shifted his stare a little towards the light, further suggesting lack of will while giving the fish a very human feeling of dejection. Not caring about the face of his conqueror, the fish only seeks to confront death, represented by the light that he turns towards. The focus on the fish's physical structure denotes the fish's lack of spirit yet it is this very lifelessness that gives the fish the human emotions of apathy and hopelessness. Through the personification of the fish, the poet shows the speaker's projection of lack of spirit and hope onto the fish.…

    • 589 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays