Preview

Commanding Heights Essay

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
7534 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Commanding Heights Essay
Commanding Heights documentary notes

Notes meant to amplify the documentary’s points are shown in square brackets. [ ]

Episode 1: The Battle of Ideas

Friedrich Hayek and John Maynard Keynes were contemporaries and economists with rival views. Their two schools of thought dominated Western economic theory in the 20th century. Each had their period of dominance over the mainstream. Hayek was a believer in free markets whereas Keynes believed in strong government regulation of markets.
Lenin opposed international trade and only wanted the USSR to trade with fellow Communist nations. He was therefore against the “global economy.”
Keynes was a prominent economic advisor to the British government during and after WWI. He strongly opposed the Treaty of Versailles terms that forced Germany to make ruinous war reparations to the Allies because he saw it would destroy their economy, which in turn would lead to sociopolitical instability.
During this period, Hayek became a central member of the “Austrian school” of economics. This was a small group of free market economists that formed in Vienna after WWI. They were marginalized during this period.
Lenin’s hardcore Communist policies were a disaster in the USSR: Food production and industrial output virtually collapsed and the county started falling apart. He had to abandon the most extreme Communist practices early on because they just didn’t work in real life.
Stalin introduced the economic practice of central planning to the USSR.
As Hayek predicted, German hyperinflation after WWI completely destroyed the value of all personal bank accounts and bonds held by average Germans. The hard-earned savings of millions of middle- and working-class Germans were wiped out. The German mainstream became outraged and desperate, and they blamed the democratic Weimar government for the problems and became open to extremist alternatives, such as Communism and Nazism.
[In Mein Kampf, Hitler cited broad-based anger

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Over the period from 1855 to 1964, Russia saw various reforms and policies under the Tsars and the Communist leaders that had great impacts on its economy and society both positive and negative. Lenin definitely implanted polices that changed society and the economy for example with war communism. However whether his policies had the greatest impact is debatable and in this essay I will be assessing the view whether Lenin had the greatest impact on Russia’s economy and society than any other ruler between the period from 1855-1964.…

    • 2039 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lenin a Red Tsar?

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Lenin went on to say that based on the disproportion between economic development of the monopoly stage, which is the beginning of full socialism, and capitalism, which is the meaning of a private life and freedom from others. The only problem with that theory is that a Monopoly and Capitalism are complete opposites of each other, and were bound to cause problems. Lenin knew of this problem, but considered it a stepping stone in the right direction. He predicted problems, but thought in due time his economic machine would operate with great success, and make Russia into a world mega power. Lenin’s plan of communism for Russia was supposed to be great. People were supposed to get free education, free medical care, everybody makes the same amount of money, working equally as hard, and everybody was supposed to get the same advantage in life.…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Brave New World-Allusions

    • 1351 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Vladmir Lenin (1870-1924) founded the communist party in Russia and the world's first communist dictatorship. He believed in Karl Marx's theories that government is affected by underlying economic forces. Lenin's dictatorship resembles that of Mustapha Mond for both of them controlled their people for the nation to prosper.…

    • 1351 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    His way of thinking is known as "state capitalism". He wanted to continue the way ,Vyshnegradsky had gone.By heavy taxation and forcing exports to generate capital the government got more money for investing in e.g. railways.…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    As well as this, after Lenin's death, Stalin wanted to employ a policy of ‘Socialism in One Country’. This meant that he wanted socialism in only the USSR. This again differed from Marxist ideas as it went against internationalism. It was also in contrast with Trotsky, who wanted a ‘Permanent Revolution’ across the world. The main reason Stalin did this was to agree with Lenin’s ideas, as he was trying to appear to be the natural successor to Lenin.…

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Milton Friedman and John Maynard Keynes were two respected economist throughout the 1900s. Friedman, an American economist, was a prominent advocate of free market. Whereas keynes, his rival, was a firm believer of fiscal policy. Although Friedman and Keynes seemed to rarely agree on their ideology, both made a substantial impact on the economic world. Despite the fact that they were two influential economist, Friedman’s Theory of Consumption Function is what made him superior to Keynes.…

    • 177 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lenin and the communist party only had a vague idea how the communist philosophy should be put into practise. This included especially the economic proposals of the communist philosophy. The first economic ideas to be put into practise were reactionary and were formulated to please the Bolsheviks (the communist party). One of these ideas was the Land Decree of 1917 which was a radical change for Russia. It abolished all private ownership without compensation and all ranks in the army. In addition, most of the economy was taken over, on the behalf of the people, by the government.…

    • 1767 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Vladimir Lenin was responsible for the Bolsheviks growing hold on power in the years 1917-1924. One reason for this was his ability to be a pragmatic leader. During the Russian Civil War of 1918-1921, Lenin created War Communism. War Communism steered Russia into the direction of military production and aimed to create a social equality. Private property and money were abolished and military service and work became compulsory. In order to fulfill rationing; food was requisitioned from the peasants but were given nothing in return. As of this, it led to the Bolsheviks becoming increasingly unpopular with the people and in 1921 Sailors of the Kronstadt threatened military action against the communists unless war communism was ended and democracy restored. Lenin abruptly responded and ordered the Red Army to go to the Kronstadt naval base and kill the sailors. 10,000 were killed. Despite having just killed off the opposition, Lenin took into account what the sailors had said and realized that war communism could not continue. As a result of this, the New Economic Policy was issued which embraced a limited form of capitalism. The NEP legalised private trade, replaced grain requisitioning with tax-in-kin and reintroduced money. Although Lenin had already compromised by reintroducing money in 1922, the money that was minted did not have the Romanov emblem and so the Russian…

    • 836 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Hayek found a few faults with Keynesian Economics. First off he pointed out that Keynes’s argument about savings is actually an argument about the dangers of hoarding. “It’s agreed that hoarding money is deflationary in its effects. No one thinks that deflation is in itself desirable.” So…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Vladimir Lenin was the first person to make a country completely communist. With his uniting of the Soviet Union, Lenin integrated his communist ideologies into its member countries. Lenin derives many of his beliefs from his time when he was a member of the Bolshevik faction. This is where he accumulated Marxism fundamentals. Unlike in Brave New World, Lenin believed in a single class. Brave New World, invasions a perfect society with multiple social classes. In these classes, all of their members are perfectly fit with where they stand in society. There is neither backlash nor hatred among the population against the other classes. Lenin, however, believes that having different classes arouses hatred amongst a society’s citizens.…

    • 1657 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Hayek vs. Keynes

    • 959 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Hayek’s beliefs were shown through his book, The Road to Serfdom. He supported the free market and laissez-faire capitalism. He also wrote that the government has a role to play in the economy through the monetary system and that government intervention in markets would lead to the loss of freedom. He was very much against government intervention and even went so far as to say, “too much government means too much government power. Too…

    • 959 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lenin stuck to many of his promises, which he had made before and during the revolution. One of the Bolshevik ideals is that there will be work for everyone, and fairer working conditions. After the revolution, Lenin made several changes to industrial workers lives. In November he made it law that ‘A maximum 8 hour day and 48 hour working week for industrial workers’ and ‘employment insurance introduced for workers, for injuries, illness and unemployment’. These changes were very beneficial for the industrial workers, as now they have free employment insurance, which helped many sick workers keep their jobs, and millions more to secure jobs. In addition the maximum 8h workload per day meant that workers weren’t allowed to work ridiculous hours, and have more leisure time. Later in December, the factories were all put under the control of the workers committees instead of being run by factory bosses. This allowed workers to have more of a say over the changes being made in the factory as they now had the power to do so. Lenin certainly kept to his promises in the extent of improving workers lives.…

    • 1222 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    _The Commanding Heights: The Battle of Ideas_ episode explains the economy's change in structure between 1914 and 1970, as well as the functioning of the markets and government during that time. John Maynard Keynes and Friedrich von Hayek both had influential roles on the economy in the 20th century due to their opposing arguments regarding aggregate demand and classical liberalism, respectively. Keynes' "planned economy" idea and Hayek's "market economy" both fought to shape the economy into what they hoped was ideal for modern day society. Between the two, Keynes' argument seemed to have the most success, especially in times of great need, which is why I found his the most compelling.…

    • 770 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Foreign policy was essential in the first phase of Lenin’s premiership. Despite Pipes’ view that Lenin ‘never believed that the revolution could be confined to Russia’2, it can be argued that Lenin opted for an ‘isolationist’ approach which lasted up till 1940 and the Russo-Finnish War, and this seems more likely because of the fact that the Soviet Union had been ostracised by the rest of the world and had to opt for ‘isolationist policy’ as they had been isolated entirely by other nations which was clearly displayed when the Soviet Union wasn’t granted permission to join the United Nations. It appears that Lenin was solely responding to crisis with his foreign policy, using foreign policy as a form of crisis management to defend…

    • 3048 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Keynes and Hayek

    • 332 Words
    • 2 Pages

    John Maynard Keynes was an economist whose ideas have greatly affected the theory and practice of modern macroeconomics, and informed the economic policies of governments. He built on and greatly advanced earlier work on the causes of business cycles, and is widely considered to be one of the founders of modern macroeconomics and the most influential economist of the 20th century. His ideas are the basis for the school of thought known as Keynesian economics, as well as its various offshoots.…

    • 332 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays