Preview

Clotel Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
771 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Clotel Analysis
Clotel is an interesting piece of literary work by William Brown, as it exposes the depraved social conditions of Chattel Slavery and its effect on Marriage relations between slave and slave owner. Interestingly, I recognized the stereotypes that can develop from conditions of race and class in our society. More importantly, we see how race and class present higher priviledges to mulatto slaves (quadroons), than what William coins as the "real negro." Undeniably, there is a stereotypical belief in today 's society that light skin or fairer skin people have an esteemed privilege than that of dark skin people. Although fictional characters, Currer, Clotel, and Althesa are real-life representations of that belief because they were mulattos. One may imply that it is quite stereotypical to say that light skin people have a higher privilege that is not necessarily given to dark skin people, although many believe it to be true as a result of the conditions faced by non-mulatto slaves. However, others may not agree.

Currer and her two daughters Clotel and Althesa are all protagonists in this literary work. Currer, a bright mulatto was a housekeeper for slaveholder Thomas Jefferson, upon which she beared Clotel and Althesa. Currer being of the higher class of slaves was permitted to hire her time for more than 20 years. Surely Currer wanted nothing more than to raise her daughters to attract attention in efforts that they might marry into their freedom. Compared to ordinary slaves, Currer and her daughters had once lived in luxury due to privileged conditions of being a mulatto slave. Nevertheless, they were still slaves, and often reminded that they were no different than ordinary slaves.

For example, Clotel was only 16 when she was purchased by Horatio Green, son of a wealthy gentleman of Richmond whom promised to make her "mistress of her own dwelling." She lived in luxury for a while, and even beared a child named Mary with Horatio. The time came that Horatio

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    As outlined in the article, a person's skin color outlined the inferiority in society. The darker the skin color the more inferior you where as a person, as a class as well as a race. White servants were not subject to hard labor because Iberians did not think of them so much as laborers but as good investments, because of the money they could receive from them and the possible religious outcomes. People of dark color were thought of as not having…

    • 345 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Harper’s use of the mulatto: The anti-slavery novels of the antebellum period, such as Uncle Tom’s Cabin stereotypically portrayed their mulatto characters as the all but white, tragic offspring of a slave owner and a slave (often of mixed blood, as Marie, Iola’s mother was) with such admirable qualities as intelligence, sensitivity, pride, and nobility (good coming out of bad, perhaps?) yet racked with tragedy and bitterness because society has defined them as Black, therefore sealing their…

    • 1238 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This view that white waged slavery is a sentence worse than being black demonstrates that the upper class did not give a damn for them and saw class as a bigger divide than skin color. This idea that “blackness is widely understood in the mid nineteenth century as a state of becoming” tells the reader that class is a construct where once cannot move in society; conversely, the reality is true (qtd. in Pfaelzer 50). Skin color cannot be changed; but class placement can and should be worked…

    • 1661 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    This chapter is based on two types of stories which are story line and testimonies. Story lines as the socially shared tales that are fable-like and incorporate a common scheme and wording (124). Testimonies are accounts in which the narrator is a central participant in the story or is close to the characters in the story (124). The book talks about four major story lines of color-blind racism. The first one is “The Past Is the Past,” which mean that people must put the past behind them. It is also a such term call ex affirmative action that do a reverse by letting the racial flame be alive. The respondents feel as if it is necessary to let go of the past and move forward and to also forget about what happened back then. Next is the “I Didn't Own Any Slaves,” this statement is to let others know that the generation now is not responsible for the ills of slavery. These respondents felt as what slavery got to do with today race. And that Blacks does not need to be played for anything. Then another story line is “If Jews,…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    D’Aguiar’s central purpose is to make us reflect upon American society during the slavery era and to acknowledge its realities so that we understand the capability for evil that exists in society. D’Aguair has used Whitechapel and his memories to encapsulate the brutality and inhumanity of slavery. The succeeding narratives further our understanding of the society and these are presented in a manner that forces the reader to accept D’Aguiar’s judgements. The characters represent all of the voices of the society including people from different races, social status’s and both genders so that the reader can see the position society imposed upon all citizens. The forms of the individual narratives help us to understand the reality of society because they allow the characters to emerge as individuals, telling their own stories with undisguised honesty. The Longest Memory is told from the oldest to the youngest character showing how society instilled its ideals on each generation in an uncompromising manner and so the stories overlap and intertwine, to illustrate this D’Aguiar has used an overwhelming tone of sadness and despair to emphasise the negative feelings that society created.…

    • 795 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Despite the progress our country has made since its inception, we still live in a racially categorized society. Some of us are the causes, and some are the victims of it. But what exactly does it mean to racially categorize somebody? Could it be by skin color, by dialect, by culture? Most commonly, one would not be able to give a clear answer, or the same answer as another would. The majority of our peers just go along with these ideas and they are taught generation after generation. However, there are those select few people who question the idea of racially categorizing people, and seek an understanding and a reason. Most of the time they come up empty-handed, for they find there is no logical understanding. Racial categories are simply man-made and created by society. A few thinkers during Antebellum America to have different views of society during the time of slavery were Frederick Douglass, Harriet Beecher Stowe and Herman Melville. Several of these different views were on the institution of slavery and racism. The Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, Uncle Tom’s Cabin, and Benito Cereno are the three corresponding texts. These three classic American texts prove that race is purely a social construct and that slavery is an institution that only results in violence and tragedy. In addition, they deploy the use of irony to voice their abolitionist arguments.…

    • 1998 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Migrants of mixed-race origin - like Leila in The Final Passage, inherently suffered against racist attitudes in 1950’s Britain. In Black, white or mixed race? It is noted that: ‘mixed-bloods’ were seen as anomalies, demonstrably neither one race not another and as such they tended to arouse discomfort.’ This distaste for racial mixing was reflected in the derogatory names given by white people to those of mixed parentage such as ‘mulatto’ the Portuguese word for ‘mule’. The latter resulted in offensive connotations of animal breeding. It is this recognition, that to be ‘half-caste’ is neither belonging to the black or white culture, which causes Leila to recognise her identity crisis. Leila’s racial background provokes feelings of suspicion…

    • 281 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the short story ‘Jesse’, by Joy Boothe, the author presents the idea that your ethnicity determines your worth in the eyes of other people with assumptions made about who you are without getting to know you and this is shown through the use of point of view and dialogue. Boothe suggests people have preconceived ideas, are quick to judge and do not take the time to change their views. Point of view in the story is used to show the opposing sides of the characters and how they perceive the other race. “Granny brought me up on stories about what nigger men do to little white girls if they get the chance … Boy Granny was wrong, but I can't tell her. She'd have a hissy fit if she knew Daddy let Jesse carry me through the mill.” Whilst growing up Jesse was always told that ‘niggers’ were…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    From a symbolic interactionist viewpoint color stratification among blacks is something that they live with everyday because light skinned people are viewed as beautiful. Due to their lighter tones they are able to receive some of the advantages of white privilege but never able to “pull the race card”. Margaret Hunter believes that because lighter tones are associated with beauty and beauty operates as social capital for people especially for females.…

    • 1277 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In North America, white female and black male sexuality became central to the development of its racial caste system. The European settlers brought ambiguity towards sex from conflicting ideologies of middle class urban values and traditional sexual freedoms to their frontiers. Fredrickson alluded to Shakespeare's Othello, which he argued showed that "blacks [were] used to symbolize tensions or anxieties that they had little or no role in creating" even before the colonialization.2 In the North American colonies, these anxieties helped shape the creation of race among the permanent settler societies. Legally, the planter class, faced with legal ambiguities as they transitioned from indentured labor to slave labor: white indentured servants began marrying black men, threatening the continuation of slave labor by providing greater freedoms to their children because of the matrilineal nature of slavery.3 Yet Fredrickson also pointed to "the myth of black hyper-sexuality also [playing] a role in the origins of the American miscegenation complex"4: white males may have felt threatened by the idea of competing with black male…

    • 315 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Walker created A Subtlety, or the Marvelous Sugar Baby. Her work meant to comment on the sugar plantation trade, the workers who were underpaid, degraded and killed. Her work did not only comment on that, it also commented on stereotyping in relation to the representation of the black bodies in imperial discourses – proving that power relationships between the two binary oppositions(Black – White) from times of slavery have not been lost, they are still very much there and haven’t lost their roots and sting. This essay will look at how Walker’s work – the subtlety, challenges and comments on the practices of essentialising, Reductionist, and Naturalising practices of stereotyping in relation to the representation of the black bodies in imperial…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Overall, the tragic mulatto myth perpetuates the idea that the mixing of races is unnatural and harmful to offspring. Rather than blame racism for the challenges biracial people face, the tragic mulatto myth holds race-mixing responsible. There are three types of tragic mulatto. The first one is a woman that is fair enough to pass for white, usually fall in love and married to a white man; the next one is the woman who appear white that hides her mix race status thinking she is not black, she thinks she is Spanish with high standing in the community; the last one is women that has passed completely and accepted in the middle and upper classes, however, she’s forced back to being a slave and she is also sexually dominated by the plantation owner. One scholar states, “Since Armand figured that he knew his past and who he actually was and he assumed that Desiree was the reason why their baby is mixed. Also, because of the fact that Desiree was adopted and did not know what her ethnicity was Armand felt like her race, which he assumed was black, changes everything” (TeenInk). Desiree is defined as racial stereotype because her family heritage is unknown. Everybody thinks just because Armand family is known and Desiree’s isn’t, it’s Desiree who is the…

    • 1522 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Oppression Vs Oppression

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The black man woke up, wishing he had not, knowing that he was viewed and treated as less than human, figuring that death could not be much worse: ¨What if I was not black?” A woman went to bed, dreading having to lay next to the same man who beat her hours earlier, telling her that she was nothing without him: ¨What if I was not a woman?¨ These questions prompted Frederick Douglass, author of ¨My Bondage and My Freedom,¨ and Kathryn Stockett, author of The Help, to explore the roots of oppression and its effects on humans. Although Douglass focuses on slave culture and Stockett on racism and sexism of the twentieth century, both make it clear that oppression is wrong in all of its forms. But the question still remains, who is to blame? Through…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Race as a Social Construct

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages

    "The thought occurred to me, that here in the U.S. we operate under a caste system that is determined by the shade of your skin. We make immediate judgments about a person's place in the hierarchy based on the color of their skin. We…

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Race, Class & Gender

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The matrix of domination framework discussed in our textbook Race, Class, & Gender: An Anthology, recognizes that race, class and gender are an intertwining group of concepts that rely on each other when operating in society. “Within this structural framework, we focus less on comparing race, class, and gender as separate systems of power than on investigating the structural patterns that join them” (4). The author of “Chappals and Gym Shorts” is a firsthand experience of how race, class and gender operate together for an Indian Muslim woman who has feminist beliefs. Another framework discussed in the textbook is the difference framework which “tends to focus on unique group experiences”. Many times, when a book or narrative is analyzed through the difference framework, a reader will find that the writer will compare their story to one of another group that may seem unrelated (6). This occurs in the reading “Back to the Future: An Examination of the Native American Holocaust” where the Native American author makes connections between the Indian boarding school to the Jewish Holocaust of the 30s and 40s.…

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays