Classical India and China

Powerful Essays
Writing Assignment #2

INSTRUCTIONS:

1. Read question and readings listed.

2. Complete outline before coming to class.

3. You will write your essay in class.

Q: Judging by the cultural standards of classical periods in China and India, were women better off in classical India or classical China?

Background information:
See attached reading and p. 50-57 in Stearns reader.

OUTLINE

I. Introduction A. Thesis B. Overview of position

II. Position: Hint: India better off, China better off, neither A. Reason 1 1. Proof #1 – cite from a reading 2. Proof #2 – cite from a reading B. Reason 2 1. Proof #1 – cite from a reading 2. Proof #2 – cite from a reading C. Reason 3 1. Proof #1 – cite from a reading 2. Proof #2 – cite from a reading

III. Conclusion A. Restate the thesis B. Summarize reasons for your position

.

Sarah Shaver Hughes and Brady Hughes:

Women in the Classical Era

India

Women’s rights deteriorated after the Vedic period (1600-800 BCE). No one has been able to prove why this happened. Scholarly interest has focused on women’s exclusion from performing Hindu rituals, which was in effect by 500 BCE…Julia Leslie thinks that women’s exclusion resulted from intentional mistranslation of the Vedas by male scholars, as the rituals became more complicated and as the requirement for property ownership was more rigorously enforced at a time when women could not own property.

The falling age of marriage for Indian women is another illustration of their loss of rights. In 400 BCE about sixteen years was a normal age for a bride at marriage; between 400 BCE and 100 CE it fell to pre-puberty; and after 100 CE pre-puberty was favored. These child marriages also affected women’s religious roles. Because girls married before they could finish their education, they were not qualified to perform ritual sacrifices. Furthermore, wives’ legal rights eroded. As

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Classical China and Classical India Classical China and Classical India are one of the most unique early civilizations during the Classical Period. They are known for their contributions to its modern world. China and India are similar and different in many ways. Both China and India had many similarities and differences in politics, economics, and religion. The Qin and Han dynasties of Classical China developed a kind of government called bureaucracy. The Qin stressed central authority…

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Though they had some different qualities, Classical China and India were very similar. The complexities of both India and China’s social hierarchy systems were very different. However their religious views and ideas were similar, and they both began to decline but were able to recover and maintain stability. Both China and India used social hierarchy systems, but they were used differently. India used a very strict system called Varna, or the caste system. People only associated with people in…

    • 602 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Classical China and Classical India have many similarities, but some ideas like politics and the social classes can differ from one or another. Politics was a way on how these classical civilizations had a government and what made the government had power to lead their civilization. Social class was a way to put people in ranks which was also a way for the different types of jobs they did. Politics also goes with social class since it showed that only certain types of people could be in the government…

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    and Contrast Classical China and India The foundations were set for these two Classical developing empires: China, separated from other developing empires and India, supported by them. While both Classical China and India had hierarchy’s based on agriculture and organized patriarchal societies, India developed multiple institutions, such as language, while China developed one united dialect. Agriculture helped set a hierarchy for these classical civilizations. For example, China categorized groups…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Classical China and India Comparisons The political developments of Classical China and India were similar in how they expanded their territory, but were different in ways they governed their territory, as well as their attitudes towards religious freedom. Within Classical Indian and Chinese civilizations, they both began with expansions due to military conquests. The Mauryan rulers depended heavily on their large armies, more so than the Guptas. They used their large armies to forcefully…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Lifestyles of Different Social Classes in Classical India and China Classical China and India both had very defined social structures made up of peasants, merchants, and elites. The lifestyles of these classes shared some similarities and differences between the two societies. Each level’s role was affected by their civilization’s religion, government, and economy. The variations of jobs and wealth in this hierarchy also resulted in a varying levels of respect and prestige. Peasants are perhaps…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Around 350 B.C.E., the classical empires of China and India emerged. Classical civilizations were hierarchical and patriarchal, but varied in the organization of their societies. Both China and India, like most classical empires, were patriarchal societies which allowed women little to no independence. Women were inferior to men and were restricted to domestic lives as wives and mothers. Chinese women were forced to spend their days at home because of Confucian values which emphasized the importance…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    CAC between India and China When analyzing cultural traditions and innovations, economic relationships, and social classifications and expectations during/between the periods of classical China and classical India. Classical China lasted from 2000 B.C.E - 600 C.E, while classical India lasted from 600 B.C.E – 600 C.E. There are quite a few similarities and differences between these two civilizations. With regards to cultural traditions and innovations both developed similar technologies in their…

    • 749 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Classical China and India have some differences, but the civilizations also have many similarities such as both having a caste system, something that has many differences and similarities are both China and India’s religion. Government is another thing influenced both Classical China and India. Both India and China has a caste system but the systems are not the same, they have a few differences. In India a person born into a caste can never change caste or mixed with members of other castes…

    • 625 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    China in the Classical Era Dr. George Stone History 111 07/01/2012 The gender systems of the Classical era in China can almost be summed up with this phrase: “How sad it is to be a woman!” (Strayer) According to the Chinese traditions when a girl child is born the family is definitely not happy about the birth. The mothers of the girl child must do three things; “first she must make the child sleep under the bed this shows the baby that she is lowly and weak, second she must give the baby a…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays