Civil War Essay

Topics: Slavery, American Civil War, Slavery in the United States Pages: 5 (1541 words) Published: July 17, 2010
A comparative analysis of slavery

A comparative analysis of Stanley Elkins historical interpretation of slavery with James McPherson.

James J Williams

Student

Abstract

Stanley Elkins and James McPherson are two great authors with many years of teaching and writing history. They both seem to share some of the same historical interpretations on slavery. But McPherson’s discussion seems to be more accurate than Elkins because He gives a more detail discussion on the black experience during the reconstruction and on antebellum American slavery prior to the Civil War. McPherson’s writing is more up to date (2001) than Elkins. Elkins seem to rely solely on critical commentary from other authors when discussing slavery. His basis is on the growing interest in black culture, which had some significant contribution to work published on slavery in the 1970s. Elkin’s was not as up to date as McPherson with his latest edition. Elkins last edition on slavery was published in 1976.

A Comparative Analysis of Stanley Elkins historical interpretation of slavery with James McPherson.

Stanley Elkins and James McPherson are two great authors with many years of teaching and writing history. They both seem to share some of the same historical interpretations on slavery. There are some arguments. McPherson’s discussion seems to be more accurate than Elkins because He gives a more detail discussion on the black experience during the reconstruction and on antebellum American slavery prior to the Civil War. McPherson’s writing is more up to date (2001) than Elkins. Elkins seem to rely solely on critical commentary from other authors when discussing slavery. His basis is on the growing interest in black culture, which had some significant contribution to work published on slavery in the 1970s. Elkin’s was not as up to date as McPherson with his latest edition. Elkins last edition on slavery was published in 1976.

Elkins, Stanley M. Slavery: a problem in America institutional and intellectual life.

Stanley M. Elkins is the Sydenham Clark Parsons professor emeritus of history at Smith College. Elkins devoted a full year of research to write his book while having a fellowship with the Rockefeller Foundation. He has also published the Debate over slavery: Stanley Elkins and his critics.

McPherson, James M. Ordeal by fire: the Civil War and Reconstruction

James M. McPherson is Professor of American History at Princeton University, where he has taught since 1962. He received his B.A. from Gustavus Adolphus College in 1958 and his PhD from The John Hopkins University in 1963. He has been a Guggenheim Fellow, a national Endowment for the Humanities Fellow and a Fellow at the Center for Advanced Studies in Behavioral Sciences at Stanford. A specialist in Civil War and Reconstruction history and in the history of race relations, McPherson is the author of The Struggle for Equality: Abolitionists and the Negro in the Civil War and Reconstruction (1964); The Negro’s Civil War (1965).

Stanley Elkins and James McPherson are two great authors with many years of teaching and writing history. They both seem to share some of the same historical interpretations on slavery, but there are some arguments to be made on their different views. Elkins considers the discussions and criticism occasioned by this controversial work on slavery and ideology. Elkins takes into consideration the substantial body of critical commentary when discussing Slavery and Ideology. He also considers the growing interest in black culture, which had some significant contribution to work, published on slavery in the 1970s. Elkins last edition on slavery was published in 1976.

McPherson writings blend many up to date interpretations based on years of research, including the black experience during reconstruction. He gives a pretty accurate discussion on antebellum American...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Were Slaves Free After the Civil War? Essay
  • Essay On Cause Of Civil War
  • Civil War Essay Shania Copy
  • Civil War Essay
  • The Civil War Research Paper
  • What Caused the Civil War Essay
  • Causes of the Civil War Essay
  • Essay about African Americans in the Civil War

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free