Preview

Charlotte Gilman Herland

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
927 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Charlotte Gilman Herland
Since the early ages, people have been dreaming of creating a perfect place, a place where everyone is going to be satisfied. Charlotte Perkins Gilman was one of the many authors who developed these utopian ideas in their works. In 1915 she wrote a short novel Herland about an utopian maternal community. This novel is quite unique because the society depicted in the book wasn’t simply utopian. It was an ideal state created by women. This very idea was considered radical in the early 1900’s. But no matter how unusual and strange it is, people can’t help but recognize that it makes a great sense. Gilman’s Herland was quite successful and functional as a state. It seems that such state could exist, but without some completely fictional aspects …show more content…
Besides describing the differences between the feminine society and ours, the author raises lots of very controversial social questions concerning equality and social order. We can certainly see some signs of the socialist ideas in the description of the utopian Herland. Chapter 6 of this book starts with a discussion about “women wage earners.” In this imaginary feminine society this phrase could be applied to every single woman of the working age, whereas in early 20th century America most of the women didn’t have any job, but housekeeping. Only the lower class one-third of the female population had to work for living, and it probably wasn’t their choice, they had to do it to be able to feed their family. Why is this so? Historically, societies in almost all parts’ of the world were patriarchal. Men had leading roles in all aspects of the social life, they were the ones who worked to feed their families and they also had more independence and power. Women weren’t obliged to work, but they had to care about the family and do domestic work. There were exceptions: higher class families hired servants to do the work, while women …show more content…
But the amazing detail in which Charlotte Gilman describes Herland, make it seem very possible. I think that the author gives us a clue, that if we did try to establish a successful utopian society, women should have a greater role in it, because it isn’t possible to create an ideal state such as Herland without women’s essential qualities, especially their love and tolerance. This world would surely be a better place to live without wars and conflicts. Even historically, almost all of the conflicts were started because of men’s ambitions and desire to fight. Women would have stopped the struggles if only they had more political power and freedom. So, the first step to make this ultimate dream come true is to give women more responsibilities and power. In my opinion, the modern world is getting closer to this utopian dream; and the main reason for this is that women have a much larger role in the society as a whole than they had a hundred years ago. We should move towards gender equality, it is essential to successful development of our

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The feelings of the ladies in Gilead is parallel to the emotions of the females in the 1960s and ‘70s. Both report to a male “guardian” who have no legal right to property or money. Also, in each society, it is difficult or forbidden for women to hold an occupation. By creating a realm of female suffrage in The Handmaid’s Tale, Margaret Atwood was able to criticize the social issues of anti-feminist viewpoints that she witnessed growing up. Although women have more liberties today, the message of The Handmaid’s Tale should not be forgotten- no gender alone can run the…

    • 663 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Britain in the 19th century was a patriarchal society and the dominant idea was that there are irrefutable natural differences between genders. Therefore, males, who occupied the dominant positions, were born for business, finance, and politics, while women were expected to marry, manage the family, and take care of the children. It seems that females in that period were thought to be miserable, tragic, and wretched and did not have suffrage rights, the right to sue, or the right to own property. Their inferior jobs such as babysitter or textile worker were barely enough to survive on. Worse still, most working women were employed in the unskilled, unorganized, service jobs and were paid a lower salary. Some of them were even required to become prostitutes out of desperation. Later, females entered some male dominated industries, but they only got one third of a man’s salary. There were still a large amount of women who lived as housewives, like Mrs. Thorold was pretending to do in the novel. They merely managed the family or were considered decoration in the living room. Women’s social value and working rights were denied by men, who were the heads of society.…

    • 1618 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Playing Beatie Bow

    • 694 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Life in the 19th century was particularly difficult for women, as not many women had rights and were treated different to men. “Because I’m a girl, that’s why, and girls canna become scholars. Not unless their fathers are rich, and most of their daughters are learnt naught but how to dabble in paints, twiddle on the pianoforte, and make themselves pretty for a good match!” P.59 this quote explains how girls and women like Beatie can’t have a different job other than being a housewife unless they have grown up in a wealthy family. Women didn’t have rights in property, vote, employment and more. Most men would marry a woman based on how good they are at cooking, cleaning and housework.…

    • 694 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mr Griffen Murphy

    • 651 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Victorian Britain was in almost all ways a period of oppression and exploration of women. Women in Britain during the Victorian age were seen largely as second class citizens in a so called “man’s worlds.” Women lacked the right to vote and the own property and inherit money once they were married, and where seen as the property of their husband to do almost anything that they so pleased. Though there are many reasons for why we can see that Victorian Britain was a time of exploration for women, in this essay the main points that will be focused on will be, women in the workplace, the role of women in marriage and the view that society had on women and their role within society. After looking at these points one will clearly see that Victorian Britain was a period of oppression and exploration of women.…

    • 651 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women were underpaid, expected to stay at home to run the household, and abused, all without others taking a second glance at the morality of these situations. From the 1830s to approximately the 1860s, women who chose to work in mills made about three to three and a half dollars a week; this was about one third to half of a man’s wages (Dublin, Working Class Women). At that time, three to three and half dollars was much more than a farmer’s daughter could earn but was still not enough for a single person to live off of. (Dublin). A single woman making low wages could only afford to pay their rent; they were unable to buy extra necessities such as food or clothing. Due to low income and being unable to support themselves, a woman's goal was to get married. After marriage, she would be supported by her husband’s income and no longer had to worry about the financial burden alone. Consequently, married life could be considered almost as hard as the life of a single woman. Women were still required to get a job after marriage to help pay for needs. Women also tended to eat less than their husbands and children to ensure their family was their main priority and was managed adequately. Women who failed to manage the household sufficiently or those who spent too much money were often abused. The abuse would go unintervened unless a man beat another man’s wife or death was suspected. (Working Class Women). Women of this time were second rate compared to men and had much less important than males. This caused tension among feminists who believed that men and women should be treated equal. With this in mind, those same women who saw the unequal treatment of women during this time in history, were probably women who started the fight for women’s…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The fact of work for women was contradictory since businesses desired women to work for them to make money they were losing, and they knew women could not refuse. Some men were so ashamed of their non-existent jobs that they abandoned their wives and families. A 1940 survey revealed that 1.5 million women had been abandoned after their husbands lost their jobs to The Depression (Gervase). Men were so afraid of losing their authority in the household that they felt it was women to blame, however, it could not be further from the truth. The public media drilled the view into people that women were somehow at fault for wanting work in hard times to support their families. Men saying it was irresponsible for leaving their duties at home for something as ‘ridiculous’ as working. More than half of all employed women in the 1930s worked more than fifty hours a week and one-fifth of those worked over fifty-five hours. (“Working Women” ) Even with this extreme work environment, and hours, a woman’s annual pay was only $525 to a man's $1027, and yet people still said that women were undeserving of work and steal their money (“Working Women” ). Women were constrained into taking the low wage even if it did not meet their home expenses. During the Depression women’s wages dropped lower than ever, and businesses took advantage of…

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Starting off by explaining the typical family roles in the turn of the century, Piess expresses how while the men may spend his evenings at a local saloon, at a baseball game or reading his daily paper, the women would often be expected to work her “double day”. Piess explains this concept of the double day to be that the woman is expected to go about her daily work day of typically “domestic servants, needlewomen, laundresses…” (Peiss 1986), and come home to start her other job, being the housewife. The housewife duties usually entailed cooking, cleaning, washing, scrubbing, and most importantly… making her husband and kids happy. All the while, when the woman got her hard earned paycheck, it was expected to go towards family needs. Even as young women in the family home, young working girls were expected to hand over their paychecks in their entirety while their male counterparts were only asked for a small portion of their earnings. Even though women were getting paid at lower wages and it being justified because women were seen as “temporary wage-earners who worked only until marriage” (Peiss 1986), Piess automatically…

    • 1679 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    During the 1900’s women’s main purpose was to get married and look after her husband and children, they were treated as second class citizens with few rights. Women were burdened with heavy duty unpaid domestic work within the home. Life for women then consisted of backbreaking housework, without electricity and household aids. Young girls were expected to help with household chores even when they were in full time employment, whilst young boys were exempt from such chores.[1]…

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    A number of “Utopian” communities began to spring up in the 1840’s -50’s. One of the best examples of these communities were the shakers, they let the outcast of society such as black and Indians, join them as long as they follow the rules. They would focus on shared labor and liberty. One of the major differences between the different utopian communities was the equality between men and women. A person’s sexuality was not important in American “Utopian” Communities, except for the Oneida. The Oneida are the most arguable because of it strange practice of complex marriage. Yet, the Oneida community was considered the most successful out of all utopian communities. Document F stresses the alliance among the people for the greater good of everyone. Document B explains that once the churches are reformed the sinners will be reformed, awakened and converted to better members of the society.…

    • 573 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the Victorian era, men were more socially accepted because of their gender. They had more social power because society gave more trust, responsibility, and rank to men. The choices women made were based on the men they lived around. Males were the dependents of the woman’s future, whether it was as family, or workers. Yet this was the perspective of everyone, it was not always fair, nor true.…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “The Ways of Her Household” by Laurel Thatcher Ulrich, we read about the daily work that three women did to keep their households running. In our class discussions we mentioned how a woman's work in the house was crucial to the household economy because if women did not do housework, men would need to stay home to get the housework done and would not be able to earn wages. In Jeanne Boydston’s article “To Earn Her Daily Bread: Housework and Antebellum Working-Class Subsistence” we again read about unpaid labor as a form of employment for women. Boydston writes, “Within the household, wives’ labor produced as much as half of the family subsistence.” Boydston also writes that a woman’s labor is, “necessary to produce a husband’s labor-power.” Ulrich and Boydston are both arguing that women's labor is important, even if they are not earning wages, which Lydia Maria Child would also…

    • 1969 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Herland, Gilman is suggesting that society and education could change for the better if motherhood rather than manliness became the cultural ideal. The people of Herland are strong, intelligent, independent women that have successfully built a society on their own, where the community’s needs come before their own. Gilman obviously feels that her society is unjust to women and does not allow them to achieve their full potential. In Looking Backward, it is evident that Bellamy’s feelings toward his society is that American independence led to the creation of an economy run by the wealthy which then created an oppressive class structure and weakened the freedom of…

    • 286 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Herland Paper

    • 1813 Words
    • 8 Pages

    In a secluded region of the world a society developed in isolation from external influences. Physical barriers allowed this culture to evolve uninhibited, and thus, be unique in almost every aspect of their society. The people work together as a collective whole for the betterment of the group. A person is secondary to the nation, which created a system of cooperation and growth. Traditional gender roles are non-existent. Women do not need protection from men, due to the ability to act as a whole to counter the possibility of a threat. Subjugation of any person would lessen their contribution to the group, so every person is respect as an equal member. This society is the fictitious "Herland" created by gender activist Charlotte Perkins Gilman. Through analytical study of Gilman's book Herland, and extrapolating from the information provided, scholars can theorize about the path the characters, as well as this nation, would take in the years following this story.…

    • 1813 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the early 19th century, there were not many options outside of marriage for middle-class women which is likely due to the taboo that surrounded woman of the middle-class needing to work. The opening paragraph James Hammerton’s article “Feminism and Female Emigration” explains that even education for these women was geared toward preparing them for married life, which ultimately hindered those with the intent of entering the female workforce. Incidentally, there was a disparity between the population of women and men at the time, so many women did not have the opportunity to be married. This ultimately prompted many to search for jobs, but only within the boundaries of what their class deemed acceptable, especially within the borders of the…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Continuing, Wollstonecraft also focuses on the education system of the 18th century as continuing a dilemma, in which women are trained to focus upon their bodies and sexuality. Similar to Rousseau, who divides women into the categories of “good and dissolute, or whores,” Wollstonecraft also categorizes women based on their vanity and their sexuality. Accordingly, Wollstonecraft attempts to base the vindication of a woman’s rights upon her ability to distance herself from her physical appearance or sexuality, by condemning vanity and sexuality as a means for re-classify a woman from her position as a wife to mistress, diminishing the societal worth and self-worth of a female. Consequently, the focus on a woman’s role as a modest wife and mother…

    • 1096 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics