top-rated free essay

Celia, A slave

By facebookbot1993 Feb 07, 2014 1004 Words

A Dictatorship Created Inside the Union

Professor Name
A question could easily be aroused from the usage of slavery in the South. Was it possible to create a dictatorship type of role inside of what we believed to be a Union? The answer may seem to be a “no”; however, the use and management of slavery in the South would suggested a different answer. In the book Celia, A Slave, the author, Melton A. McLaurin, argues that Celia’s story demonstrates “Stanley Elkins’ contention that slaves were powerless to protect their most basic humanity from the predations of the master,” as opposed to later scholarship that emphasizes the slaves’ ability to resist despite living in such an oppressive society. 1 I believe that this argument made by McLaurin is true. Slaves tried many different tactics in order to separate themselves from the power of their master; however, their efforts weren’t able to help the issue. Slaves were powerless to their masters due to their inability to have equal rights with the whites. Whites saw themselves as more superior than the blacks, and this could be seen through the way they treated slaves during court/trial. White females usually received justice in court, but for black slave women, not so much. 2 In the case from McLaurin’s book, Celia, was a black slave and was being accused of the murder of her master. He explains how Celia was just trying to defend herself, given that her master was trying to sexually exploit her; however, the judge seemed not too concerned of this issue. 3 Section 29 of the second article of the Missouri statutes of 1845 was implemented to provide justice for those in Celia’s situation. 4 It seemed pointless to have this section of law, since the court wasn’t going to abide by it. Celia wasn’t provided justice, and this made the slaves seem powerless to the schemes of their master, and even society as a whole. Without proper representation in the court, any attempt for slaves to defend themselves and fight back would just fall against them in the court system. Another way slaves were subject to their master’s will was through their inability to prevent themselves from being sexual exploited. In the South, it wasn’t uncommon for white men, mainly the owners, to sexually exploit a slave. Robert Newsome, who was the owner of female slave Celia, would exemplify this when he went to buy her just for the soul purpose of sexually exploiting her. He evened did so before he could make it back to his farm after he purchased her. 5 Female slaves, like Celia, were powerless to these attacks by men. The attacks effected all of them psychologically, and lowered their ability to want to resist. Celia, however, did resist, but as explained earlier, it didn’t help the situation. Female slaves had no choice in their fate; do nothing and just continue to be sexually exploited, or resist and put their lives at risk. Either way, their life was in the hands of their master. Although slaves were subject to their master’s will, there were ways in which slaves tried to revolt. These included doing things like running away, breaking equipment, abusing animals, working slow, and pretending to be sick. 6 These things irritated the whites more than it helped the lives of the slaves. If anything, it made it worse on them. Owners wanted to make sure that they could contain their slaves and that they could force out any desire to rebel. One main rebellion, Nat Turner’s rebellion, was a key factor that shaped how owners needed to make sure that they maintained control over the blacks. Although, whites died and blacks hoped for a chance of a better life, the whites quickly put a close on it and destroyed the morale of slaves once again. 7 Slaves attempted to resist the power of their masters’; however, these attempts were to no avail. They would need to wait until the Emancipation Proclamation was established before they could finally break that dictatorship chain off of their masters. In McLaurin’s story, Celia takes matters into her own hands, but this would result in her death. This shows just how much slaves didn’t stand a chance and breaking the stronghold that their masters had on them. Lastly, whites showed little, to no, sympathy towards slaves, causing whites feel as if they should rule over them. Whites never really understood how bad their treatment was toward slaves since they never really considered them people in the first place. There would be times where whites were aware of things such as sexual exploitation going on, but wouldn’t take any form of action upon them. 8 People were too distracted by other issues going on rather than the lives of slaves. During the 19th century, there was a lot of tension between pro-slavery advocates and abolitionists. People like David R. Atchinson were pushing towards making Missouri a slave state, while others would argue on this subject. 9 Overall, slaves stood no chance of not allowing themselves to be powerless to their masters. Slaves were seen more as property than as people, and this was evident through their treatment in law and court issues, sexual abuse, and the lack of sympathy shown by others, mainly whites. Slavery provided great prosperity to the South; however, the conditions that slaves lived in weren’t as great. Female slaves had the roughest time, as can be detailed in McLaurin’s book. What slavery owners may have called business, slaves would probably call a dictatorship. Their lives were placed in the hands of their masters’ and these people didn’t really care for the feelings of the slaves, since all they needed from them was their labor on the farm. Going back to the question: Was it possible to create a dictatorship type of role inside of what we believed to be a Union? With slavery, one may suggest that it was possible.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Celia, a Slave

    ...Celia, a Slave was a factual interpretation of one isolated incident that depicted common slave fear during the antebellum period of the United States. McLaurin used this account of a young slave woman's struggle through the undeserved hardships of rape and injustice to explain to today's naive society a better depiction of what slavery could ha...

    Read More
  • Celia, a Slave...

    ...CELIA, A SLAVE. A MIRROR TO SLAVERY AND INJUSTICE? A critical overview Celia, a Slave was a factual interpretation of one isolated incident that depicted common slave fear during the antebellum period of the United States. Melton A. McLaurin, the author, used this account of a young slave woman's struggle through the undeserved hardships of ...

    Read More
  • celia a slave

    ... Celia, A Slave: A True Story Celia, A Slave by Melton A. McLaurin is the story of Celia a fourteen year old slave that is purchased and abused by her master, until one day she kills him. The relationship that Celia and Robert Newsome had was very interesting and the book touches on race and gender hierarchies, power in the relationship, a...

    Read More
  • Celia, a Slave

    ...Celia, a Slave is the epitome of the relationship between slaves and their owners and also the slaves and other whites in the 1850’s. This is based on her interactions with her owner Robert Newsom and her reactions mainly with the community involved in her court case. These relationships affected more so the women slaves rather than the men sl...

    Read More
  • Celia, a Slave Book Review

    ...of stories from the years when African-Americans were used as slaves on the plantations or farms of affluent, white farmers. One intriguing story of slavery and the struggles with it was written by a guy named Melton A. McLaurin. Released in 1993, Celia, A Slave was written as a true story of a young slaved girl who broke some of the most unbre...

    Read More
  • Moral Madeline of Celia, A Slave

    ...Melton McLaurin s book Celia, A Slave is the account of the trial, conviction, and execution of a female slave for the murder of her master in 1855. The author uses evidence compiled through studying documents from Callaway County, Missouri and the surrounding area during the middle of the Nineteenth Century. Although much of what we can determi...

    Read More
  • Celia, a Slave Book Review

    ...Celia, a Slave Book Review Celia, A Slave is a story that takes many different historical facts from the era that the book was placed in, and uses a slave named Celia’s story to tie them all in and show how these events that didn’t directly affect her, would indirectly affect her, and the other slaves in this time as well. The author, Me...

    Read More
  • Celia, A Slave

    ...Celia, a Slave In the summer of 1855, a slave named Celia committed a crime that would test the laws and precedents placed on slaves in Missouri during this time period. Celia was only fourteen when purchased by a slave owner, Robert Newsom in 1850. Five years after being purchased, she murdered her owner in self-defense because he tried to...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.