top-rated free essay

Catholic vs Lutheran

By sab1119 Aug 02, 2010 1024 Words
For my final project, I chose to compare the Catholic and Lutheran religions. I was born and raised in the Roman Catholic faith and have always attended a Catholic church. In fact, I even attended Catholic schools my entire life, so I am very familiar with the religion. I chose the Lutheran religion for comparison because I hear that it has some striking similarities to the Catholic religion and it interested me to find out both the similarities and differences between the two.

The Lutheran religion was founded in the 1500’s by a German monk and professor, Martin Luther, and is the oldest Protestant denomination. Luther was born into a very traditional German Catholic family, but as he grew into adulthood and became a monk, he studied the Bible very carefully and felt there was a great disconnect between what was written in the Bible and what was actually practiced and taught by the Catholic Church. He also became very discouraged and disillusioned by the corruption and abuses he witnessed within the Catholic Church. His initial hope was to create reform in the Catholic Church by his sermons and writings, but what ended up happening was the creation of an entirely new religion. “Martin Luther taught that salvation comes by the grace of God and faith in Christ alone, and the many rituals and works prescribed by the church were not only unnecessary, but a stumbling block to salvation. He rejected such traditions as the intermediary role of priests, priestly celibacy, the Latin Bible and liturgy, purgatory, and transubstantiation, and advocated for the scriptures to be available to the laity in their own language.” Even though Luther rejected much of the Catholic teachings, he still accepted and taught the concepts that he felt accurately reflected what was in the scriptures. It is because of this that the Lutheran religion still has a similar “feel” to the Catholic religion and it is what differentiates it from other, more strict, Protestant denominations. Today, Lutheranism is one of the largest Protestant denominations with over 71 million members worldwide, 7.5 million of those in the United States alone. The largest concentration of Lutherans is in Germany with 12.5 million members.

There are several different bodies of the Lutheran church in the United States. The two largest are the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA), and the Lutheran Church – Missouri Synod (LCMS). There are many differences between the two bodies, but overall, the ELCA is less conservative than the LCMS. For example, the ELCA will ordain women and homosexuals to the pastoral office while the LCMS will not. Another difference between the two is their disagreement regarding the authority of the Bible. The LCMS believes and teaches that the Bible is actually the Word of God and, therefore is free from any error, while the ELCA “tolerates and encourages methods of interpreting the Scripture that presuppose that the Bible contains error and is unclear about various doctrinal matter.”

To further my research of the Lutheran religion, I chose to attend a local Lutheran church in my town of New Braunfels, TX. It is somewhat fitting that I chose the Lutheran religion to research because the town I live in was also founded by Germans and still has an active German population. The particular church I chose was Cross Lutheran Church, a member of the Lutheran Church – Missouri Synod. It began in 1925 with a group of 6 members who met in various places until they officially organized in 1928. Today the congregation is made up of over 600 people who are led by their Pastor, Don Fraker. Pastor Fraker has been with this church since 1998. Although this particular church is over 80 years old, they have fairly new and modern facilities, dating back to only 2002. According to the bulletin I received at the church, they offer adult Bible studies several times a week, they have 6 different bell choirs, a very active youth group and they also have a school that teaches pre-kinder through 8th grade.

For the interview portion of this project, I chose to interview a friend of mine who is Lutheran and also attends the Cross Lutheran Church. She also happens to have been born and raised Catholic, so I was especially interested in her take on the two religions. It appears that both Catholics and Lutherans celebrate some of the same religious holidays such as All Saints Day, Easter, and Ash Wednesday. However, Catholic rituals and practices such as saying the Rosary, Lenten sacrifices and Stations of the Cross are not practiced by Lutherans. She describes the Lutheran religion as “Catholic Light” and says that it is not as solemn or ritualistic as Catholicism. However, there are enough similarities between the two religions, that she felt very comfortable and at ease through the transition. One of the biggest differences she described was that of the sacraments. Whereas in the Catholic religion there are seven, in the Lutheran church, there are only two. The two sacraments are Baptism and Eucharist (Lord’s Supper), which are also in the Catholic religion. I asked my friend how and why she moved from being Catholic to being part of the Lutheran religion. Her reason was that her husband was born and raised in the Lutheran church and that was his religious preference. When she made the decision to convert, she had to attend a series of classes and make an affirmation of the faith. This apparently is different than being baptized. If you have been baptized and/or confirmed in another Christian church, then you do not have to be baptized again, only make the affirmation of faith.

With all the contrasts between the two religions, there really seems be more similarities than differences in the actual beliefs. The major differences appear to be in the physical aspects of practicing the religions and in the worshipping.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Catholic Lutheran Topics

    ...Demian Tejeda-Benitez Write 2 paragraphs on the Lutheran Views of each topic: Lutheran views on Grace: Grace is known and viewed as the central doctrine for all Lutherans. They also believe in the concept of “faith alone” meaning the only way to believe is through the practice of faith and grace alone. The beliefs of Lutherans believe t...

    Read More
  • Roman Catholic vs Baptist

    ...Roman Catholic vs. Baptist Church Roman Catholic and Baptist Church are the two leading Christian religions in America. They have some similarities, such as; 1. Both believe in the Trinity, Father, Son and Holy Spirit 2. Both believe that Jesus was fully God and fully man. 3. Both believe that good works is necessary 4. Both believe in...

    Read More
  • Hispanic Roman Catholics vs. On-Hispanic Roman Catholics

    ...A Roman Catholic Hispanic By: Charles Hamlett Ethics/105 April 26, 2013 The Hispanic and Latino Roman Catholic Non-Hispanic vs. Hispanic Both Hispanic Roman Catholics and Non-Hispanics Roman Catholics share most of the same beliefs about the Roman Catholic religion with few exceptions. The Hispanics are much stronger believers than t...

    Read More
  • Catholic Church vs Martin Luther

    ...Marriage and Sex: Catholic Church VS Martin Luther The views on marriage and sex differ greatly between the Catholic Church and Martin Luther. Though both agree to a different set of rules and regulations, Catholicism is a strict religion while Luther strived for a more accepting practice. Luther’s opinions on these topics agreed more with t...

    Read More
  • Catholic vs Protestent 1500

    ...Protestant Movement was started in England teaching that through baptism all people were dedicated to the worship of God making us all priests. While the Protestant was making there mark the Catholic church was growing finatually with wealth from selling indulgences to followers that promised pardoned sinners from punishment in the afterlife. ...

    Read More
  • Catholic Christianity vs. Islam

    ...Catholic Christianity versus Islam November 30, 2007 Catholicism has been around for along time although it has evolved over the years. Some Catholics are more liberal and accepting of new beliefs while others remain true to the original doctrines. The Roman Catholic Church traces its history to Jesus Christ and the Apostles, (Roman Cathol...

    Read More
  • Baroque Art: Protestant vs. Catholic

    ...Baroque: Protestant vs. Catholic Before the purity of Neoclassicism, even before the carefree artists of the Rococo era, there was the dramatic and emotive Baroque. The term "baroque" is said to have been derived from the Portuguese word for an irregular pearl, and is certainly an adequate description. In the wake of what has become known as ...

    Read More
  • Baptist Vs Catholic Church

    ...Norielyn Perez Baptist Church Visit Christ the King Baptist Church, that’s the name of the church I recently attended, and although it was a lot different from my own catholic faith, I enjoyed it very much. There were a lot of people in this service; around 35 to 45 people were present. Everyone that was there was dressed semi-formal, casu...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.