Case study analysis

Topics: Life, Pregnancy, Organism Pages: 4 (656 words) Published: April 27, 2015


Case Study Analysis
Paulina Oleksiak
Grand Canyon University: HLT-310V-O191
May 3rd, 2015

Case Study Analysis
In this specific case study by GCU, (2015), about fetal abnormality there is the mother-to-be Jessica, the father-to-be Marco, the aunt named Maria and Dr. Wilson who is the attending physician in the county hospital. Jessica who is four months pregnant goes to the hospital with her husband to see Dr. Wilson. He informs them about the rare fetal abnormality and possibility of Down syndrome. The following paragraphs will explain the theories that are being used by each individual in the case study: Maria: the aunt believes that Jessica has a “responsibility as a mother” to go through with the pregnancy as “God intends” it to happen. (GCU, 2015) She believes that prayer and involvement of the priest is the appropriate action. She may believe that all living organisms have a moral status including the fetus. To her, the fetus is sentient and able to feel the mother but not yet able to smell or see her. (Sentient, 2015) The fetus will become a person, even though it may be imperfect and deformed, it will be as God made it. Dr. Wilson: he believes that Jessica should have options and that is ultimately her final decision, no one else’s. He tells her about the “scientifically” appropriate plan of aborting the pregnancy as one of the medical alternatives due to the likelihood of the child having poor quality of life. To Dr. Wilson, the fetus may not have amoral status because he or she does not have self-awareness, language, or rationality. (Sebo, n.d.) The fetus, even if born may be mentally and physically disabled. As a fetus, it is unable to be aware for example of dangers posed by upcoming tsunami or a hurricane. Is it really a person? According to Glubilini and Minerva, (2011), “although fetuses and newborns are not persons, they are potential persons because they can develop, thanks to their own biological...

References: Grand Canyon University (GCU), (2015). Case study: Fetal abnormality. HLT310V
Glubilini, A., Minerva, F. (2011). After-birth abortion: Why should the baby live? Journal of Medical Ethics. doi:10.1136
Sebo, J. (n.d). Moral status. [Web video]. Retrieved from https://www.khanacademy.org/partner-content/wi-phi/value-theory-1/v/moral-status
Sentient (2015). In Merriam-Webster online. Retrieved from http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/sentient
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Essay on MGMT591 Case Study Analysis
  • Essay on Case Study Analysis
  • Case Study Analysis Paper
  • Case Analysis Study Essay
  • Case Study Analysis Research Paper
  • Case Study Analysis Essay
  • Essay about Case Study Analysis L
  • An Example of a Case Study Analysis Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free