Case Brief People of Nys V Mccray

Topics: Crime, Law, Mental disorder Pages: 2 (616 words) Published: February 5, 2013
The People of the State of New York
V.
Donald L. McCray

Nature of the Case: Appeal upon a verdict convicting defendant of the crimes of assault on a police officer and criminal use of a firearm in the 2nd degree. Concise Rule of Law:Mental Hygiene Law § 9.41 which permits persons who appear to be mentally ill and acting in a manner that threatens safety of self or others to be taken into custody. The Penal Law § 120.08 imposes strict liability with respect to the serious injury aspect of a crime. Facts of the Case:In August 2008, McCray alerted Sunmount Developmental Disabilities Office (SDDO) and Franklin County Emergency Services he was armed and had intended on commit suicide. McCray was eventually found in a canoe to the Raquette River by a variety of police agencies including State Troopers and officers from Department of Environmental Conservation(DEC). This resulted in a standoff for many hours during which McCray maintained aim of the loaded shotgun at himself. A trooper seized an opportunity to grab the gun, along with a DEC officer. A struggle ensued and the gun went off causing massive injuries to a Troopers hand. After being arrested, McCray was charged by indictment with assault on a police officer and criminal use of a firearm in the 2nd degree. Following a trial, McCray was convicted as charged and sentenced to 15 years in prison followed by 5 years of post-release supervision, defendant appeals.

Issues of the Case: Was McCray’s mental health status such that he qualified for consideration under Mental Hygiene Law § 9.41 or Penal Law § 120.08 which addresses the element of the intent? Did McCray’s attorney represent him effectively?

Was his punishment considered harsh or excessive?

Holding of the Case: Mental Hygiene § 9.41 does not impermissibly criminalizes defendant’s mental illness. Penal Law § 120.08 does not negate the requirement to prove intent.
McCray was not impermissibly criminalized.
McCray’s...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Case Brief: Caperton v. Massey Research Paper
  • Case Brief of Terry v Essay
  • Case Brief People V Green Essay
  • Gonzales V. Raich Case Brief Essay
  • Mapp v. Ohio Case Brief Essay
  • Essay on Marbury v. Madison case brief
  • Case Brief
  • Case Brief: US v. Conti Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free