Preview

CASE ANALYSIS: "THE BLAST IN CENTRALIA NO. 5"

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1166 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
CASE ANALYSIS: "THE BLAST IN CENTRALIA NO. 5"
CASE ANALYSIS: "THE BLAST IN CENTRALIA NO. 5"
The Problem
The obvious problem with Centralia No. 5 is that an explosion killed 111 people. However, prior to the actual explosion, the problem is less obvious, especially since Centralia No. 5 was similar to so many mines that did not explode. In this analysis, I will examine the possible roles and responsibilities of Driscoll O. Scanlan, the mine inspector, given the "corruption of modern administrative enterprises" prior to the accident. From this perspective, the perspective of a public official in the field, the problem is that a potential danger exists and the regulatory machinery in place to address the danger is ineffective. As an expert, Scanlan recommended that the mine be "dusted" with non-explosive, pulverized stone to diminish the possibility of the coal dust's exploding. However, his expert advice alone was not enough to motivate a response.
History
The chronology of the case shows a progression of "appropriate" action within the existing law and according to organization or bureaucratic norms. On an organiza¬tional level, the players include the State of Illinois, the U.S. Government, the Centralia Coal Company, the United Mine Workers of America, and the miners themselves, who could hardly be said to have been well represented by any of the others.
Beginning in 1941, Scanlan's reports of "excessive coal dust" in the Centralia No. 5 mine were sent to Robert Medill, the Director of the Department of Mines and Minerals, and handled as "routine" by Robert Weir, the Assistant to the Director. All three positions were appointed by the Governor, Dwight H. Green. Also in 1941, the U.S. Bureau of Mines began making inspections of mines. The first inspection of Centralia No. 5 was in September 1942. However, only the State of Illinois had any power to enforce compliance, and reports from the Bureau there¬fore had primary significance as further documentation in the hands of the Department of Mines and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The Pullman Case

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In 1894 a strike known as ‘the Pullman strike’ took place. It was destructive and revolutionary, involving both the employees who protested and their employer, George Pullman. The employees felt that Pullman was taking advantage of them, so they joined the American Railroad Union (ARU). This caused a lot of mixed feelings and many people had different perspectives on the event. Several different views can be observed when analyzing this case and its consequences. All of these views can be analyzed by interpreting first-hand accounts and documents from the time of the incident.…

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Centralia Mine

    • 1226 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The layers of bureaucracy created a group of administrators that were out of touch with those that they were hired to protect. Rather then focusing on results that created change, they focused on meetings and memos that essentially did nothing but create a paper trail that lead to a disaster. In the case of the Centralia #5 Mine, failure to act was responsible for the death of 111 men, the widowing of 79 women and leaving 76 children under the age of 18 without a Father.…

    • 1226 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the United States during the late 1800’s many industrial workers, both foreign and domestic, banned together to stand against wealthy elites to obtain better compensation for their strenuous work. In this time of rising conflict, many labor unions attempted to speak out and demand better reward. Many big name companies owned by rich businessmen were mistreating their workers and eventually groups like the “Knights of Labor”, “The Workingmen’s Party of Illinois” and “The Lehr and Wehr Verein” were assembled to unify the workers allowing them to resist oppression. Many of these big name companies dealt with the major manufacturing of goods such as lumber and steel, while many others were more focused on the construction of the railroads that transported these goods or the press that advertised them. Because businesses were privately owned and singularly managed, there was little to no government attempt at setting up guidelines on how business owners should administer their employees. Taking advantage of the lack of governmental regulations, these businessmen were able to obtain massive amounts of money and power and leave their workers overworked and underpaid.…

    • 1429 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    On Thursday, August 5, 2010, thirty-three Chilean mine workers became trapped 2300 feet underground after the San Jose mine entrance ramp in collapsed. With the escape shaft blocked off, there was not a way for them to evacuate safely, as well as no clear way for the 130 man rescue team to get inside to free the miners. Once communication had been set up between the miners and the rescue team, it was found that all of the miners were still alive. They would remain trapped for exactly sixty-nine days before a drill would be used to create an exit hole large enough to extract all of the miners. It was later discovered that in the past the company received some citations for unsafe conditions at the mine. It was unclear whether or not the company had been at fault at the time of the collapse. Despite the obvious blessing and gratefulness of the miners and their families, thirty-one of the thirty-three miners filed a lawsuit claiming negligence. There was a substantial judgment against the company that released $541K for each miner.…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    On March 25, 1947, a blast in Centralia Coal Mine killed 111 workers. Centralia Coal Mine No. 5 had been operational since 1907 and had never suffered a major disaster. Prior to this event only four shotfirers were killed in 1921 (Fleege). Because of the safety record of the mine, it was considered relatively safe and a disaster seemed remote. The United States had just ended a war and the economy was picking up and production needs were relatively high. Mine operators were being pushed by the federal government to produce as much coal as possible to meet the demands of the robust economy. Because of the demand, safety factors in the mines were not a top priority, therefore, conditions deteriorated tremendously during this period.…

    • 1428 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    On August 5, 2010 the world watched as reports came in from Chile, a small copper mine caved-in leaving 33 mine workers trapped underground (Weik, 2010). Initial reports did not know if there were any survivors. It was 17 days before any contact was made with the trapped miners (Hughes, 2010). The family members and the rest of the world were relieved to know that all of the miners had survived the collapse. The mine officials in this terrible disaster had much to consider when addressing the many audiences connected to this disaster. The family members, the media, and the mine employees would all have to be addresd in different ways.…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Centralia Explosion No.5

    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Medill the director of the Illinois Department of Mines and Minerals, Scanlan Should have directly reported his findings to the Governor of Illinois, the U.S. Bureau of Mines and the State Mine Board to ensure safety measures and further infestations were established .Also, Scanlan should have developed some type of fail-safe or escape route. By having…

    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    United States Coal Commission, Report, 5 parts, Senate Document 195, 68th Congress, Second Session. Washington, DC: U. S. Government Printing Office,…

    • 1753 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The workers were furious after hearing their work place, mill, was closed. Not allowing people or workers to enter, the workers decide to set a plan for attack. Even though the mill was private property the workers wanted the mill and their job. The workers then gathered weapons and began their plan. The fight happened for hours, until, the Union hold the white flag. Handing themselves in to the workers they were removed from Homestead. Even though, the workers got their job and managed to retrieve the mill, questions were brought up. Many owners believed that the workers broken the law. They trespassed or interfered with private property. Some believe the workers didn't do nothing wrong getting their jobs back. After the debate, the law was enforced and compromised.…

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Was the Bloodshed Necessary?” “How do you confuse a West Virginia coal miner? Show him two shovels and then ask him to take his pick.”- Unknown Post-Civil War years in Appalachia was a difficult time for the coal miner. Transgressions piled and tension soared in the Mountain State, while the region hurdled down an inevitable path towards industrial development.…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Black Lung

    • 2559 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Bibliography: Berkes, Howard. "As Mine Protections Fail, Black Lung Cases Surge." NPR. NPR, 09 July 2012. Web. 05 Dec. 2012. <http://www.npr.org/2012/07/09/155978300/as-mine-protections-fail-black-lung-cases-surge>.…

    • 2559 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Facts: Hugh Caperton, C.E.O. of Harman mining (here on labeled as Caperton), filed a lawsuit against A.T. Massey Coal Company (here on labeled as Massey) alleging that Massey fraudulently canceled a coal supply contract with Harman Mining, resulting in its going out of business. In August 2002, a Boone County,West Virginia jury found in favor of Caperton and awarded $50 million in damages. Massey went on to appeal to the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals. During the interlocutory period Don Blankenship, C.E.O. of A.T. Massey Coal Company was involved in a campaign for the election of State Supreme court candidate Brent Benjamin against incumbent Justice Warren McGraw. Blankenship invested over $3 million in Benjamin's campaign through a non-profit organization called "And For The Sake of The Kids". Mcgraw lost to Benjamin in November 2004. When the case came before the West Virginia Supreme Court in 2007 the court ruled in favor of Massey and overturned the $50 million verdict in a split 3 to 2 decision. Caperton sought rehearing and the parties moved for disqualification of three of the five justices who decided the appeal. Photos had surfaced of Justice Spike Maynard vacationing in the French Riviera while the case was pending. Justice Maynard recused himself after possible bias due to friendship was brought into argument. Next, Blankenship petitioned for Justice Larry Starcher's recusal after the two shared a public feud over Blankenship's role in the 2004 elections. Caperton petitioned for the recusal of Justice Benjamin because of Blankenship's monetary contributions to his election campaign. Justice Benjamin declined, but Caperton was given a rehearing. In April 2008, the court again ruled in favor of Massey with Benjamin again joining the 3-2 majority. Caperton filed a petition with the United States Supreme Court concerning Blankenship's contributions…

    • 815 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The impact of the NUM’s defeat in the Miners’ Strike encompassed the entire social, political and economic spectrums, making some significant contribution in all of the three areas in some way or another. However, whether they are evidence of the Miners’ Strike’s significance or of another factor outside of its sphere will be made clearer through further analysis of the year-long crisis in the coal industry.…

    • 1796 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Centralia No 5

    • 861 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Scanlan addressed many issues concerning the safety of all of the employees and ways he felt that they could be resolved. Scanlan could have addressed some other issues as well, in hopes that he would get anyone to know what the dangers of what he was finding out. Scanlan investigated the mine over and over again several times and he should have addressed the fact that too many workers were in the mine at a time. The special commissions did their investigation, and they found that there should be “no more than a hundred men working on a single split, or current, of air” (Stillman, 2010). The second thing that Scanlan could have investigated was Ben Schull and the issue of wanting to remove the valuable information concerning the mine needing a sprinkler system, to offset the duct from all of his reports. What Scanlan should have done as soon as he found out was to report Mr. Schull to the Mining Board immediately, and if they don’t do anything then Scanlan needed to go to someone in a higher authority. He should have done this to ensure someone will know that the miners would be in serious trouble. The third thing that Scanlan could have addressed was the fact that special commission investigated the mine; no one was informed of the date of the appointment. It was up to them to make sure that the Union knew of when their investigation was going to take place. By not doing so they were considered to be unprofessional, because the commission should have had the workers show them all of the current charges that were put forth against the mine. The forth and the last thing that Scanlan could have addressed was the reported findings of a possible explosion to other professional but all failed to follow the safety procedures and allowed the men…

    • 861 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    1st Class Exam Dgms

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages

    EXAMINATION FOR MINE MANAGER’S CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY RESTRICTED TO MINES HAVING OPENCAST WORKINGS ONLY UNDER THE METALLIFEROUS MINES REGULATIONS,1961…

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays

Related Topics