Preview

Carol Berkin's 'Revolutionary Mothers'

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2164 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Carol Berkin's 'Revolutionary Mothers'
Britny Valdez
Professor LeClaire
U.S. History 1301
23 July 2015
Revolutionary Mothers Book Report
When people talk about the revolutionary war, they think of a bunch of men fighting. Not many people know that women actually did take part in the war and had a great influence in it. In “Revolutionary Mothers” by Carol Berkin, she writes about all of the different ways that women were affected by the war and how they influenced the war. Berkin explains with detail about the enormous workloads that women had before the war and the way it doubled during the war. The wives and sisters had to step up and take on the role of their men who left to fight in the war. Women were not only emotionally disturbed but physically as well due to the raids and
…show more content…
Men were angered and wanted to join the militia to defend their new nation while women were afraid of the dangers of war. They knew about war but only from afar. Women understood this was a home front war and their husbands, brothers, and fathers were going to participate. Many women opposed this and blamed the draft workers for convincing their men to leave and basically commit suicide because they weren’t sure if they would make it. Aside from worrying about their husbands, they still had to tend to their everyday duties, add their husband’s duties, and make sure that their children and homes were safe from the relentless British men. The British men would enter the American women’s homes and raid them. Many even threatened to kill them. And just like any other situation, many other women encouraged men to fight and pushed for the revolution. Whichever they chose, to encourage or oppose, they all faced the unbearable loneliness at the end of the day. They all struggled to maintain their homes and have something for when the men came home. They even went to extremes to get whatever little resources they could get. The British soldiers were violent when they invaded the homes. Some soldiers would arrive drunk and shooting their guns, which resulted in many accidental deaths. Although, that quickly escalated to more dangerous situations, “British forces committed conscious acts of fierce brutality” …show more content…
One reason English men didn’t like Indians was because of their culture. Indian women had a voice and position in political affairs. “To the English colonists, this division of labor defied all they knew to be true of male and female aptitudes and appropriate roles” (page 108). Yet through the very different cultures, a woman and a man came to love each other. They opened a hope that the two cultures could coexist with each other. But, the revolutionary war only forced them to choose sides. British or Colonial. Indians became accustomed to the ways of the white men and women power gradually faded. “Indian women’s political voice was rarely acknowledged by American governments, and thus women’s power and authority waned” (page

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the book Revolutionary Mothers: Women in the Struggle for America’s Independence, author Carol Berkin provides a voice for the women of the American Revolution. Berkin exposes the war through the eyes of patriot and loyalist, American and British, Native American and African-American women. In doing so, the author permits the reader to comprehend the war not as black and white, but rather in shades of grey. Berkin reasons “it is important to tell the story of the revolution and its aftermath with the complexity it deserves” (Berkin, xi). The ultimate goal of the book explains the impact women had on the outcome of the Revolutionary War.…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The role of a women in the American Revolution was originally a supportive spouse. They would tend to household needs and take care of their husbands businesses while they were away at war. Like in the picture “Banner of Washingtion’s Life Guard” she watches the man leave her behind as he goes to war. She is in a dress and is holding on to American symbols behind her which shows that she will be waiting for him to come back. Another painting that shows how women were expected to be is “Liberty in the Form of a Goddess of Youth Giving Support to the Bald Eagle”. She is giving life to the bald eagle by feeding him and crushing the British symbols with her foot. She is holding firm to her beliefs and feeding the bald eagle at the same time. Women…

    • 368 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The main point I find after reading the article “Women and the American Revolution” is that women during Revolutionary War times had the same issues as women today with many more piled on top. Many women today are stay at home mothers like the women were then but they have more freedoms now. If a woman wants to serve their county by joining the military it is accepted now but it was not then. Women then were not even expected to give their opinion on many matters. The few women known to have served in the military during the Revolutionary War were said to be disguised as men when they did so.…

    • 503 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Revolutionary Mothers: Women in the Struggle for America’s Independence by Carol Berkin, is based on the argument that the American Revolutionary War is a story of both men and women. According to Berkin, Women, same as men, played a vital role in freeing the American people from the British colonialists in many ways that most history books never lets out, but even if they ever care to mention, their role is often greatly romanticized. In this book, the author proves that women actually played a critical part in the Revolution by documenting a social history that lays focus on the women of the time. Native Americans, colonial white women, and the African-American women of all social classes, and regardless of the sides they took in the long struggle between the Patriots and the Loyalist have been covered in great details. To cut the long story short, Ms. Berkins has done a stellar job in presenting the…

    • 964 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Berkin claims, “In New York City a group of brides-to-be said no to their fiancés, putting a public notice in the local newspaper that they would not marry men who applied for a stamped marriage license” (14). From this example it is evident that women were very involved. Giving up marriage because they refused to pay a British tax shows some women were very devoted. While the revolution took place husbands and older male household members were most likely off fighting in the war. With many of the tasks normally completed by males not being completed, women began to takes these chores, in addition to their own. These jobs varied; some included taking care of children, working in shops, and working on harbors (Berkin 31). Women taking on men’s jobs during the war were great contributions to the success of the war. Without the extra support from females at home everything would have been thrown out of balance. The production of certain goods would not have existed without the hard work at home. Basically, women during the revolution who had determination and involvement in a household can be considered one of the largest contributions to the war. In American in the 1700s it was uncommon for women to join battles or war. Men were thought to protect women from violence and…

    • 914 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the book Sophia’s War by Avi, this book was about a young girl named Sophia who stood up to be a spy and was able to get things done, even by herself. In the article, “ Meet the Women of the American Revolution” by Amanda Coletta, is about different women who had impacted society, by doing different duties, to be recognized, not to be insignificant, but to be heroes in the American Revolution and to show that women are just as capable as men. These women share similar characteristics like Sophia. The women who share the same characteristics like Sophia and who have made a huge impact on society, are, Anna Strong, Sybil Ludington, and Emily Geiger, the women who changed History.…

    • 906 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Women's Role In Ww2 Essay

    • 1810 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Later after America got more involved in the war, women started taking a bigger part. They took different roles in the army, combatant and noncombatant, in which they served the rest of the troops. Not only did they get involved in the army, women also took a role in the industry. They helped produce many weapons, uniforms, boots, and parachutes. In communities women got involved in volunteer organizations and critical jobs. Without the women in communities, there would not have been a nuclear ‘era’ and advance weapons would not have been made. The United States and it allies’ victory was made possible through the many roles that women took. Without women serving, getting involved in production, and organizing volunteer organizations and taking roles in critical jobs, the outcome of the war would have been…

    • 1810 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Carol Berkin clearly states her thesis in the introduction of Revolutionary Mothers. “Despite the absence of radical changes in gender ideology and gender roles for most women, the Revolution did lend legitimacy to new ideas about women’s capacities and their proper roles”. (Berkin 2005) In two thousand and fourteen it is questionable about how clearly women’s roles have changed especially in the areas of economics and politics at least it is obvious that the revolution did not bring equality. Legal status has changed. Of course, educational opportunities have expanded greatly; however, it often appears the more things change the more they stay the same. Even our popular vernacular demonstrates an entrenched gender inequality. “You throw like a girl” reveals poor physical performance. To concretely state subordination a person need only to make another their “bitch”. Female autonomy is usually used to denote weakness. While women now have the right to vote it is interesting that in the US Senate only 20 of the 100 senators are female. Look to Fortune 500 CEO’s and you will find only 24 female CEO’s. (Fairchild 2014) It is standard knowledge that while women are legally entitled to their wages they make 82 cents to the dollar of a male’s wages and even lower percentages for women of color. (US Department of Labor 2014)…

    • 1716 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the 1700’s, women performed all the domestic tasks as they were not seen equal to men. During the Revolutionary War women stepped up and proved that they were not beneath men. Showcasing that they could be as strong as the men and that they weren't just made to cook and be tasteful companions for their husbands. Without women's support in the Revolutionary War, the war wouldn't have been as successful. They managed businesses, became secret soldiers, and opposed British Policies, proving that they could perform tasks just as well as men.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    But while the men enlisted and fought in the war, it was the women who faced managing on their own. Not only did these women have to provide their families with the roles of mother and father, but these women made sure that when their soldiers returned home, there would be a home to come back to and these women also had to improvise when materials ran out. The women stood together during their time alone. Women shared their secrets, helping other families out. Dealing with the household themselves was not all terrible.…

    • 1650 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The roles played by women and other minority groups during the Revolutionary War were mostly working the house like doing chores and such. “Women at Valley Forge gathered wood, cooked, washed clothes, and nursed the sick, and the injured”(Discovery Education). This shows that the women did things to impact the war. “When their survival at home was threatened by dwindling supplies or enemy advances, women had no choice but to follow the army. Gathering up children, pets, and valuables,…

    • 262 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Why did the 13 small colonies of England with a rag tag army win the Revolutionary War against the strongest military of the time? Some say luck or God’s providence while others explain that it was the people in the background doing cooking, cleaning, spying, and occasional fighting; some say the answer to the question is women. Without women participating in the Revolutionary War through boycotting British goods, spying on the British, and helping their men in various ways the British would have won the war against the colonists. Women held power people did not realize: they chose what to use to cook or anything else around the house and they chose not to use anything from England. The men never paid attention when women were in the room during meetings or other events and the women were able to collect valuable information. Women also donned uniforms to fight and helped when they saw a man fall on the battlefield. The Patriots had the “home field advantage” in the war because they had thousands of women supporting them.…

    • 2415 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Not only did women take on critical roles in the family, they also made numerous contributions to the revolution. Women from all parts of the country-- women of Pontarlier, Besancon, Chalons and several others-- sacrificed their dowry and wedding rings to provide financially for these soldiers who are fighting in the fronts lines of the revolution. These women were able to send 20,000 pounds of sheets to aid the wounded, and make clothes and knit stockings to clothe their husbands and sons who were serving in the revolution. The women did not just sit around waiting for their men to get back; while their husbands and sons were fighting in the front, women gathered together to fight an internal battle at home. Great examples of women really actively serving amongst the men are the women of Lons le Saulnier, Macon, and Cote who at the start of war against Austria “armed themselves with pitchforks and pans and declared they would defend their homes and children in the absence of their men, and if their men were defeated than they would make a last stand (p.100).…

    • 1459 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Like most places in the world, until recently, women were considered an extension of their husband or father. They were given none or little rights both socially and politically. During the French revolution spanning from1789-1794, most social groups went though great changes from the nobles of the second estate, to the common man of the third. The revolutionary changes experienced by women in France were insignificant compared to most other social groups around them; their place in society stayed relatively stagnant. Revolutions often change things for everyone and the French revolution is an example of change at its minimum, at least for women. Most men and women agreed…

    • 880 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Revolutionary Mothers: Women in the struggle for American independence, Berkin depicts the lives of all women affected by the war, showing the role each one played and how their class, race, or marriage had an effect. Berkin emphasizes in her writing that the Revolution is often just depicted as a man’s war and often the women’s role is minimized. Within each chapter she will focus on a specific struggle women faced and how they helped shape the nation with their contribution. Revolutionary Mother, shows how women played a role in our nation no matter what conflict there were facing, it shows how ordinary women lived throughout this horrendous period of time.…

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays