CASES OF EXECUTIONS
THE RANGS-BILLA KIDNAPPING CASE
The Ranga -Billa Kidnapping Case was a notorious crime in New Delhi in 1978. Two children, Geeta and Sanjay Chopra, were kidnapped by two young men, Ranga Khus (Kuljeet Singh) and Billa (Jasbir Singh), who planned to demand ransom from their parents. Their plans went awry when their car was involved in a traffic accident with a public bus. They subsequently raped Geeta, murdered the children and fled the city. They were arrested on a train a few months later, tried and hanged for the crime in 1982.The children were reported missing on 26 August 1978 and their bodies discovered on 29 August 1978.Medical examination confirmed that Geeta was raped. It later transpired that they had been kidnapped while hitching a ride from outside Gol Dak Khana near Connaught Place.Both culprits were found guilty and sentenced to death. Both were then hanged.
Charles Brooks Jr.
Charles Brooks Jr. (April 1, 1942 – December 7, 1982) was a convicted murderer who was the first person executed by lethal injection in the United States. It was the first execution in Texas since 1964.Brooks was raised in a well-off Fort Worth family and attended I.M. Terrell High School, where he played football. He had been to prison before, serving time at the United States Penitentiary, Leavenworth for illegal possession of firearms. On 14 December 1976 Brooks went to a car yard saying he wanted to test drive a car. The mechanic, David Gregory, accompanied him in the car. After picking up Woody Loudres, the mechanic was put in the trunk of the car and they drove to a motel. There the mechanic was bound to a chair with coat hangers, gagged with tape and then shot once in the head. Neither Brooks nor Loudres would say who fired the shot. Because of legal complications, Lourdes received a 40 year sentence, while Brooks received the death sentence. William kemmler
William Kemmler was a vegetable peddler in the slums of Buffalo, New York. An alcoholic, on March 29, 1888, he was recovering from a drinking binge the night before when he became enraged with his girlfriend, Tillie Ziegler. He accused her of stealing from him and preparing to run away with a friend of his. When the argument reached a peak, Kemmler calmly went to the barn, grabbed a hatchet, and returned to the house. He struck Tillie repeatedly, killing her. He then went to a neighbour’s house and announced he had just murdered his girlfriend. Kemmler's resulting murder trial proceeded quickly. He was convicted of first-degree murder on May 10. Three days later he was sentenced to death, destined to be the first person executed in an electric chair under New York's new execution law replacing hanging with electrocution.
Arguments in favour of capital punishment
Least cruel mode to deter crime
JS Mill, in an 1868 address to the House of Parliament, argued that the death penalty could be justified because it was “the least cruel mode in which it is possible adequately to deter crime”. Mill attacks the argument that life imprisonment and hard labour are more lenient and merciful to the criminal. Leaving a man to rot in a prison cell was tantamount to confining him in a tomb for Mill, and inflicted far more suffering than the “short pang” of a rapid death exacted by the death penalty. Moreover, the hard toil inflicted through labour provided no quality of life and no hope of real reward. In addition, Mill argued that the death penalty conjures up in people’s minds a disproportionate amount of fear, even though the threat of life imprisonment is in reality a far more fearful proposition. Mill rejects the argument that the “sanctity of life” should take priority over the death penalty by stating that the real priority should be lessening human suffering. Although life imprisonment might respect the sanctity of life, it does not respect humanity’s capability for suffering.
This argument states that real justice requires people...
Please join StudyMode to read the full document