top-rated free essay

Canterbury Tales

By katrina1128 Feb 27, 2013 770 Words
Katrina Nicholas
Ms. Dixon
British Literature
November 9, 2012
Revenge is Sweet – Affairs are Sour
The Reeve’s and Miller’s Tale contradict each other in many ways towards the characters ambitions and personalities. The Miller and Reeve try to get revenge on each other by insulting one another through these parables. The main themes in these stories are as follows: jealousy, revenge, and trickery. Jealousy is shown in the Reeve’s Tale because the scholars and the miller try to get even with each other throughout the entire story. Revenge is also exhibited in the story whereas the students, Alan and John, copulate with the daughter and wife of the miller, respectively. Trickery was applied in both stories, but most famously, the Miller’s Tale because John, a carpenter, is unknowingly involved in an affair with his wife, Alison and a scholar, Nicholas. Therefore, the themes and characters of each story do have similar traits, but contradicting points about the characters deception to the main character of each story.

First, the Reeve’s Tale teaches that the people whom you stole from can come back to haunt you. This tale does not teach finder-keepers-losers-weepers, but thieves can be stolen from as well; as it is said, “Who evil does should not expect some good” (Chaucer 4320) One of the names in the stories are the same, such as John, whom in the Reeve’s Tale was one of the scholars along with Alan whom copulate with the wife and daughter of the miller, Simkin, respectively (Chaucer 4195 – 98; 4228 – 33). While in the Miller’s Tale, John is the rich, old carpenter that has an eighteen-year old wife, Alisoun, whom he is overprotective of and gets extremely jealous easily. These two characters contradict each other as one is a jealous old man, while one is an attractive college student. It shows that there is a pattern; for example, Nicholas can be compared to the John from the Reeve’s Tale and the John from the Miller’s Tale can be compared to Simkin from the Reeve’s Tale.

Secondly, the Miller’s Tale shows the theme: trickery and deception because John not only was tricked to believe the next Great Flood was coming (Crowther 327 – 35), but unknowing that his wife was cheating on him with a young scholar. Nicholas did not have a partner in crime like the two scholars from the Reeve’s Tale, but a rival, Absolon. Absolon can be a very jealous man as well, and very selfish just like Alisoun’s husband. The miller however, can also be compared to the carpenter because of his pride over his wife. The trick in the Miller’s Tale is quite complicated and revolting; John, the scholar, deceives the wife to have sex with him as do, Alan, whom deceives the daughter.

Lastly, Absolon and Nicholas’ rivalry can be contradicted to John and Alan’s friendship. Nicholas and Absolon were not exactly neither friends nor enemies until they met Alisoun, the girl whom they both fall in love with at the same time. John and Alan were poor and young (Chaucer 4002) as were Absolon and Nicholas. However, the rivals fought over love while the friends fought for bread. While the friends were equally passionate, the rivals were very different in affection. Absolon would try everything to get the girl he wanted (Crowther 162- 77; 197 – 99) but these advances were in vain however, as Nicholas has already stolen Alisoun’s heart. Both rivals do know how to sing (Crowther 28-29: 142), play the guitar (Crowther 27; 174), and have a favorite type of study such as astrology for Nicholas and drama for Absolon.

In conclusion, the Reeve and the Miller seem to try to take retribution of one another because of their personal differences in these tales. Some of the characters personalities can be similar but may be disparate. While the Reeve’s story is mostly about theft, the Miller’s story is about deception. In both, adultery or cheating was involved along with the storyline and the themes of the stories. The short stories may also be a way to insult one another by mixing up each other’s story to make it seem like a tease to show that one’s story is better than the other; which is probably why is slightly similar but also different.

Works Cited
Chaucer, Geoffrey. "The Reeve's Tale." The Reeve's Tale. Trans. Ronald L. Ecker and Eugene J. Crook. N.p., 1993. Web. 08 Nov. 2012. <http://english.fsu.edu/canterbury/reeve.html>. Crowther, John, ed. “No Fear The Canterbury Tales.” SparkNotes.com. SparkNotes LLC. 2009. Web. 17 Oct. 2012.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Canterbury tale and medieval art

    ... Canterbury Tale and Art in middle Ages The Middle Ages have been regarded as extending approximately from the end of fifth century AD to 1600s. The Middle Ages were a society significantly more civilized and developed than previous times. Some sections of Italian society had begun to mimic the art and philos...

    Read More
  • Canterbury Tales Analysis

    ...The Canterbury tales analysis “all his pilgrims are severely distinguished from each other. The matter and manner of their tales and of their telling are so suited to their different education, humor and callings, that each of them would be improper in any other mouth” John Dryden It is said by Dryden that all of the tales are made f...

    Read More
  • The Canterbury Tales

    ... Fall 2013 Paper Number 1: The Canterbury Tales by Geoffrey Chaucer The Canterbury Tales-The Wife of Bath The Wife of Bath is a character that Chaucer presents as an attractive female in its prologue. She is a headstrong and very self-confident woman of her time who thinks highly of herself. Chaucer’s descriptions of her facial and b...

    Read More
  • Canterbury Tales Essay

    ...The Canterbury Tales AP Literature & Composition October 7, 2009 A fabliau is aptly categorized as a scandalous tale meant to satirize the bourgeois through the depiction of bourgeois characters. This is the genre Chaucer writes “The Miller’s Tale,” from his The Canterbury Tales, in so he can distinguish the social class levels of th...

    Read More
  • Satire in Canterbury Tales

    ...The aim of any true satirical work is to poke fun at a certain aspect of society, while also inspiring reform to that very same aspect in one way or another. In Chaucer's Canterbury Tales, Chaucer satirizes the Medieval Church and those associated with the church. Medieval society was centered largely around the Church. Ideally, the people were ...

    Read More
  • The Canterbury Tales; Embodiment of the Middle Ages.

    ... The Canterbury Tales; Embodiment of the Middle Ages. Geoffrey Chaucer's “The Canterbury Tales" is more than just an entertaining collection of stories and characters; it is a representation of the society Chaucer lived in. In the late 14th century England the traditional feudal system was changing as the church was losing its importanc...

    Read More
  • The Millers Tale

    ...(1) “The Miller’s Prologue” From The Canterbury Tales by Geoffrey Chaucer Lines 12 – 26 The Millere, that for dronken was al pale, So that unnethe upon his hors he sat, He nolde avalen neither hood ne hat, 15 Ne abiden no man for his curteisye, But in Pilates vois he gan to crye, And swoor, “By armes and by blood and bo...

    Read More
  • Canterbury Tales the Squire: Love and Loss

    ...Love and Loss In Geoffrey Chaucer’s The Canterbury Tales in “The Squire’s Tale” the Squire is the hopeless romantic. “A lover and cadet, a lad of fire” (Chaucer 5). His passion for the love of other is overwhelming. Throughout the tale different type of romances were explored. No matter if you were a bird or person dealing with a...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.