Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=945278 Call Center Outsourcing: Coordinating Staffing Level and Service Quality
Z. Justin Ren Yong-Pin Zhouâ
July 7, 2006
In this paper, we study the contracting issues in an outsourcing supply chain consisting of a user company and a call center that does outsourcing work for the user company. We model the call center as a G/G/s queue with customer abandonment. Each call has a revenue potential, and we model the call center's service quality by the percentage of calls resolved (revenue realized). The call center makes two strategic decisions: how many agents to have and how much effort to exert to achieve service quality.
We are interested in the contracts the user company can use to induce the call center to both staff and exert effort at levels that are optimal for the outsourcing supply chain (i.e., chain coordination). Two commonly used contracts are analyzed first: piece-meal and payper- call-resolved contracts. We show that although they can coordinate the staffing level, the resulting service quality is below system optimum. Then, depending on the observability and contractibility of the call center's effort, we propose two contracts that can coordinate both staffing and effort. These contracts suggest that managers pay close attention to service quality and its contractibility in seeking call center outsourcing.
Operations and Technology Management Department, Boston University School of Management. â Department of Management Science, University of Washington Business School 1
Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=945278 1 Introduction
An increasing number of companies are moving their call center operations offshore. According to market researcher Datamonitor, the total value for the U.S. outsourcing market will be worth almost $24 billion by 2008, compared with the current $19 billion. According to Datamonitor, "By 2008, 1 in 15 agent positions (workstations) will be outsourced to a foreign market, from 1 in 24 currently. By year-end 2003, offshore outsourcers, climbing to 201,000 by 2008, will staff 121,000 agent positions.â1
Despite lower labor cost, companies in practice have experienced mixed results from outsourcing their call centers. In fact, some companies' outsourcing strategies have backfired, causing them to re-evaluate or abort their outsourcing mission. In November 2003, DELL was forced to move its call center operations for OptiPlex desktops and Latitude laptops from India back to the U.S., after customers complained about language difficulties and delays in reaching senior technicians (Financial Times, November 26, 2003). During the same time period, Lehman Brothers, a leading financial services company, had to shift some call center operations from India back to the U.S. after its customers complained about the quality of service (Financial Times, December 17, 2003). One important reason not all companies benefit from outsourcing is the lack of understanding of the economics of outsourcing, and how to coordinate the outsourcer to better serve the company that initiates the outsourcing (we call this the user company, or user). Indeed, it has been noted that, "Expectations in cost reduction are not always met because outsourcing contracts can be developed with a poor understanding of current costs . . . â (United States Government Accountability Office, 2004)
This lack of understanding of the call center outsourcing contracts may be attributed to the fact that there has been little academic research on the call center outsourcing supply chain and its coordination. The call center outsourcing supply chain differs from the physical goods or inventory supply chain in that when a unit of physical goods is sold to the customer, the retailer, who 1http://callcentermagazine.com/shared/article/showArticle.jhtml?articleId=17200246 2
owns the inventory, reaps a revenue; however, in a call center outsourcing...
References:  Aguir M.S., O.Z. AkÂ¸sin, F. Karaesmen, and Y. Dallery (2004). "On the Interaction Between
Retrials and Sizing of Call Centers.â€ Working Paper, KoÂ¸c University.
 AkÂ¸sin, Z., F. de VÂ´ericourt, and F. Karaesmen (2004). "Call Center Outsourcing Contract
Design and Choice.â€ Working paper, KoÂ¸c University.
 Bassamboo A., J. M. Harrison, and A. Zeevi (2005). "Dynamic routing and admission control
in high-volume service systems: Asymptotic analysis via multi-scale fluid limitsâ€
 Brandt A. and M. Brandt (1999). "On a Two-Queue Priority System with Impatience and its
Application to a Call Center.â€ Methodology and Computing in Applied Probability
 Brown L., N. Gans, A. Mandelbaum, A. Sakov, H. Shen, S. Zeltyn, and L. Zhao (2005).
 BusinessWeek (2003). "The Hidden Costs of Outsourcing.â€ Business Week (October 27, 2003).
 Cachon, G. and M. Lariviere (2005). "Supply chain coordination with revenue sharing contracts.â€
Management Science 51(1):30-44.
 Cachon, G. (2003). "Supply Chain Coordination with Contracts.â€ Handbook of Operations
 Chevalier P., Y. De Ronge, N. Tabordon, L. Talbot (1998). "Service Subcontracting: An
Economic Analysis.â€ Proceeding CEMS Conference, 1998.
 Cohen, M. A., T. H. Ho, Z.J. Ren, C. Terwiesch (2003). "Measuring Imputed Costs in the
Semiconductor Equipment Supply Chain.â€ Management Science 49(12):1653-1670.
 de VÂ´ericourt F. and Y.-P. Zhou (2005). "Managing Response Time in a Call-Routing Problem
with Service Failure.â€ Operations Research 53(6):968-981.
 Falin, G. I. and J.G.C. Templeton (1997). "Retrial queues.â€ Chapman & Hall. London.
 Gans, N., G. Koole, and A. Mandelbaum. (2003). "Telephone call centers: Tutorial, review,
and research prospects.â€ Manufacturing & Service Operations Management 5(2).
 Gans, N. and Y.-P. Zhou (2005). "Call-Routing Schemes for Call-Center Outsourcing.â€ Working
paper, University of Washington Business School.
 Garnett, O., A. Mandelbaum, and M. Reiman (2002). "Designing a Call Center with Impatient
Customers.â€ Manufacturing and Service Operations Management, 4(3):208-227, 2002.
 Gurvich I., M. Armony, and A. Mandelbaum (2004). "Staffing and Control of Large-Scale
Service Systems with Multiple Customer Classes and Fully Flexible Servers.â€ Working Paper,
 Harrison, J. M., and A. Zeevi (2005) . "A method for staffing large call centers based on
stochastic fluid models.â€ Manufacturing and Service Operations Management
 Helber, S. (2004). "Profit-Maximizing Multi-Period Agent Allocation in Different Types
of Inbound Call Centers.â€ Call Center Workshop at the Centre de Recherches
 Hoffman, K. L. and C. M. Harris (1986). "Estimation of a caller retrial rate for a telephone
information system.â€ European Journal of Operational Research, 27: 207-214.
 Koole, G. and A. Pot (2004). "Profit maximization and monotonicity results for inbound call
centers.â€ Working paper, Vrije Universiteit.
 Mandelbaum, A. and N. Shimkin (2000). "A model for rational abandonments from invisible
queues.â€ Queueing Systems 36(1-3): 141-173.
Press, New York, 1990.
 Pasternack, B. A. (1985). "Optimal pricing and returns policies for perishable commodities.â€
Marketing Science 4:166-176.
 Shimkin, N. and A. Mandelbaum (2004). "Rational abandonment from tele-queues: Nonlinear
waiting costs with heterogeneous preferences.â€ Queueing Systems 47(1-2): 117-146.
 Shumsky, R. and E. Pinker (2003). "Gatekeepers and Referrals in Services.â€ Management
Science 49(7): 839â€"856.
 Sisk M. (2003). "U.S. Banks ' Cost Cutting is Lucrative Gig for India.â€ USBanker 113(9):32.
 Taylor, T. A. (2002). "Supply Chain Coordination under Channel Rebates with Sales Effort
Effects.â€ Management Science 48(8):992-1007.
 Tsay, A. A. (1999). "The quantity flexibility contract and supplier-customer incentives.â€ Management
Science 45(10): 1339-1358.
 United States Government Accountability Office (2004). "Current Government Data Provide
Limited Insight into Offshoring of Servicesâ€
 Whitt, W. (2004a). "Efficiency-Driven Heavy-Traffic Approximations for Many-Server Queues
with Abandonmentsâ€ , Management Science 50(10): 1449-1461.
 Whitt, W. (2004b). "Staffing a Call Center with Uncertain Arrival Rate and Absenteeism.â€
To appear in Production and Operations Management.
 Zeltyn, S., A. Mandelbaum, and M. Reiman (2004). "Call Centers with Impatient Customers:
Many-Server Asymptotics of the M/M/n+G queue.â€ Working paper, Technion, Israel.
 Zohar, E., A. Mandelbaum, and M. Reiman (2002). "Adaptive behavior of impatient customers
in tele-queues: Theory and empirical support.â€ Management Science 48(4): 566-583.
Please join StudyMode to read the full document